Kurt Warner is one of my prime examples of players who shouldn’t be in the HOF. He gets injuried and the next guy steps right into the greatest show...
Tex, can you step back and take your emotions out of this and think deeper on your preference ? No right or wrong answer, but this is not clear cut....
If it’s about stats then your boy Rodgers wins. Thought this was a career/legacy thing. Also Eli stayed with one team which I something I would want...