If the goal is just to stop players from doing it, why make it anything other than a fine?
sharpe1027 03-28-2024, 03:50 AMOne difference I see is that a horsecollar is pretty much a horsecollar. It's difficult to accidentally horsecollar a guy. Possible, sure (we've probably
Frozen Tundra 03-27-2024, 11:54 PM25: R1 P25 DL Jer'Zhan Newton - Illinois
41: R2 P9 C Graham Barton - Duke
57: R2 P25 LB Edgerrin Cooper - Texas A&M
88: R3 P24 S
It’ll be like most rules and they’ll throw flags for first 4 games and it might affect a game.
But most likely it’ll be used for retrospective
Possibly. When the horse collar rule came out, it seemed really easy to see and even easier for a player to avoid. This one doesn't feel that way to me.
sharpe1027 03-27-2024, 09:00 PMIt would have to be a pretty long video. I think whether a tackle is a hp drop tackle has a more specific definition.
ARTICLE 1. DEFINITION
I could show you a video explaining PI and it would be really easy to spot. I just won't show you the more iffy examples.
bobblehead 03-27-2024, 03:41 PMBy gut says it’ll be as often as horsecollar, tripping, etc.
There’s a lot of rules that people have to abide by that aren’t very
These tackles are not new
A bunch of people reviewing film making a determination is not the same as calls being made on game day. Maybe
He didn't work out at Iowa's Pro Day.
Joemailman 03-27-2024, 01:49 PMThrowing in a vote for Kool-Aid here. Rumor at this link says Packers could be interested. Seems like a safe pick, if he doesn't work out on the outside
wthigoot 03-27-2024, 01:19 PMDid the xfl have something like a new 4th/15 from your own 30 or something like that?
I bet the Lions would do that a lot.
Seems
Will he eclipse his earlier numbers?
texaspackerbacker 03-27-2024, 11:39 AMI'm in favor of it. Kick-offs as they are now add little to the game.
The point is to be entertained by the game. The added entropy/chaos
Dane Brugler
@dpbrugler
Updated Pro Day for #Iowa DB Cooper DeJean:
Fully cleared and plans to work out for NFL teams
Given it wasn’t really a type of tackle since the last few years it seems kinda easy. You bear hug, jump and in the air use your body weight to bring
Fosco33 03-27-2024, 09:25 AMThe more I listen and see from the XFL how this will look, the better it's getting. When I FIRST heard this, I thought, "oh shit, this is fucking
SudsMcBucky 03-27-2024, 08:50 AMFar better to have multiple psycho owners, as Green Bay does.
Boy, that's a hell of a list Red put together. I wonder what you'd come up
There's no clear line between a legal tackle and an illegal tackle. There will be times it's really fucking obvious. Then there will be all the debatable
sharpe1027 03-27-2024, 05:20 AM