You may be right. I never thought Warner should have been in the HOF. He had 5 outstanding seasons out of 12. People loved the rags to riches story.
Joemailman 06-15-2024, 08:15 AMI voted ARod.
He had the better career. Manning has 1 more ring but only 1 more and he played like horseshit in one of the wins. If it
There's no rule against what he did. It's easy to judge from the couch when it's not your career.
I like him, but I also don't want to judge
Butte might be cocky as fuck, but let’s not forget that Manning reeked of the entitled prick for refusing to play for the Chargerings.
Anti-Polar Bear 06-15-2024, 01:39 AMI don't think anybody would take Rodgers career over Brady's. That would b a bad poll imo
Bretsky 06-15-2024, 12:10 AMIf Kurt Warner is a HoF'er, Eli Manning certainly is.
Patler 06-15-2024, 12:05 AMYeah, this says it all. You emphasize the damn Super Bowl; I say fuck the damn Super Bowl. I say it's all about winning the most games. You don't seem
texaspackerbacker 06-14-2024, 11:52 PMI met him, trust me there is no limit to how low he will go.
MadtownPacker 06-14-2024, 11:23 PMWhy didn’t you vote on it damn caramel troll.
MadtownPacker 06-14-2024, 11:22 PMBut Eli getting the 2nd ring will get him to the HOF. I agree he's not really good enough; but he'll get there.
there has been a loot of
Tex, can you step back and take your emotions out of this and think deeper on your preference ? No right or wrong answer, but this is not clear cut.
Bretsky 06-14-2024, 09:39 PMI thought this was a great poll. Thrown money out the window; assume you are getting the same. If you are a rookie NFL quarterback whose career would
Bretsky 06-14-2024, 09:36 PMEli will be in the Hall of Fame for sure. Should he be ? Not performance wise, but the 2nd SB win will land him there
Bretsky 06-14-2024, 09:34 PMShameful that you would even ask the question, Bretsky.
texaspackerbacker 06-14-2024, 08:09 PMReports are that Bates is signing with the Lions.
Joemailman 06-14-2024, 07:34 PMIf it’s about stats then your boy Rodgers wins. Thought this was a career/legacy thing. Also Eli stayed with one team which I something I would want
MadtownPacker 06-14-2024, 06:44 PMRodgers. Only reason Eli has 2 rings is because Giants had great defenses. Both Super Bowls Eli won were low scoring games. I'd rather be the HOF player
Joemailman 06-14-2024, 06:16 PMBoth. I meant that maybe in the old days they might do that. Likely was mafia ran so wouldn’t doubt some shady shit.
MadtownPacker 06-14-2024, 05:43 PMWe can go even farther with this. Eli still has an big NFL presence. None of the others do after retiring and I doubt Rodgers will either.
MadtownPacker 06-14-2024, 05:41 PM
WHOSE CAREER WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE IF YOU WERE A QB ???
Trophies for everyone!
sharpe1027 06-15-2024, 08:20 AMThe first championship would mean the most to me. Having consistently great teams that I was a big part of would also