ESPN Insider's 2015 quarterback rankings, voted by 35 NFL coaches/evaluators
(age this fall)
Tier 1
T-1. Aaron Rodgers (31)
T-1. Tom Brady (38)
3. Andrew Luck (26)
4. Ben Roethlisberger (33)
5. Peyton Manning (39)
6. Drew Brees (36)
Tier 2
7. Philip Rivers
8. Russell Wilson
9. Tony Romo
10. Joe Flacco
11. Matt Ryan
T-12. Eli Manning
T-12. Matthew Stafford
14. Cam Newton
Tier 3
15. Carson Palmer
16. Alex Smith
17. Ryan Tannehill
T-18. Colin Kaepernick
T-18. Andy Dalton
T-20. Derek Carr
T-20. Jay Cutler
22. Nick Foles
T-23. Sam Bradford
T-23. Teddy Bridgewater
Tier 4
25. Marcus Mariota
26. Jameis Winston
27. Blake Bortles
28. Robert Griffin III
29. Josh McCown
30. Brian Hoyer
31. Matt Cassel
32. Geno Smith
Among top QBs, only Rodgers & Luck are not in decline, IMO.