Pretty good list actually.
http://www.foxsports.com/wisconsin/s...erstand-091814
Printable View
Pretty good list actually.
http://www.foxsports.com/wisconsin/s...erstand-091814
http://youtu.be/MRy-D45Yf_s
Reggie was out of bounds. :lol:
They should just dump instant replay. Raiders would be happy too because the 'Tuck Rule" doesn't get applied. Those Oilers are never going to get that Renfro touchdown back against the Steelers anyway.
Quote:
Originally Posted by pbmax
Okay, so I'm getting older. I miss those old broadcasts, in which the game was the focus. And look at all the pieces in place for the Wolf-years run: Evans, White, Butler, Favre, and was that Dotson on the line, too?
In today's game I don't think that's a completed pass and fumble. It would be called incomplete because the receiver didn't make one football move...or something. ...Love me some Maxie McGee!
I think in today's NFL that would be called an interception.
If he didn't make the catch, then he could not be down by contact. If he is not down by contact, the ball never hits the ground, or at least it doesn't look like it hits the ground, then Reggie catches it out of the air - it is an interception.
If it is a catch, it can't be a fumble b/c he would have been down by contact, b/c the ball didn't come loose until after his knee had touched.
By the rules then - if he caught the ball, it could not have been a fumble b/c he would have been down by contact. So the refs blew the call at the time.
It was ruled a fumble right?? It went down in the stat book as a fumble, right??
No. The ball hit the ground, at least that's the way it appears to these old eyes. So it's not an interception. I can't see when the ball comes loose. One thing is for sure. In today's football there would be 10 different camera angles instead of just two.
I can't see where the ball ever hits the ground... it looks like it is loose as they are both going to the ground, but after the runner's knee hits; and, when Butler rolls up the ball is on his arm or left side of this body, something... and his momentum flips the ball into the air - it wasn't the ground that caused the ball to jump up, it was Butlers rolling momentum.Quote:
Originally Posted by Maxie the Taxi
I stopped it and tried to roll thru it frame by frame - which is impossible due to the poor technology and only 2 angles - I agree, in today's NFL we would have had 36 camera angles on it.
In the end, I don't see where it hits the ground at all though - if it's a completion, which is what I think they ruled, then it should have been down by contact. If it is not a completion, absent evidence that it hit the ground, it is an interception.
What it ended up being was a catch and fumble - when IMO, it should have been a catch and down by contact. Today's rules, I think it would have been an interception.
At the time, I remember thinking it was a fumble though, lol...
I don't see where it hits the ground either. It looks like the ball rolls up and over their bodies and then into the air.Quote:
Originally Posted by wist43
Does the ball come off of Butler's leg? It looks to me like it slams into the ground and bounces into White. LOL. Who knows? I doubt even Butler knows.