About time you leave Charter !!!
Personally, I don't know anyone where I live who has Direct TV. First of all, we don't need the Sunday Ticket to watch the Pack. Second, AT&T is the phone company here and you can get an awesome deal if you bundle your Satellite (Dish network) DSL and phone, so that is what most people here have. I pay $97 (taxes included) a month for DSL, phone and Top 200 with HD Ultimate package on three TV's.
Both DirectTV and Dish offer the same kind of programming, but if you need Sunday Ticket, that would be the reason to go with DTV. Dish seems to have better equipment as far as receivers, also. I have dual tuner receivers through Dish and I don't think DTV offers those. The nice thing about those is one receiver controls two TVs, so that eliminates having another stupid box sitting around plus having to pay an additional receiver fee. I have three HDTV's in my house, too and when I was looking at the two satellite carriers, DTV made you pay like $199 for an HD receiver. Plus at the time, they only had a few HD channels, but from what i understand, they now have the same HD lineup as Dish.
Dish or Direct - good choice....dump the cable pigs now !!!