Quote Originally Posted by Pugger View Post
But not above Starr, Graham, Marino, Peyton, Young, Unitas, Brady and Montana.
I imagine you are old enough to have seen all these QBs but I am only old enough to have seen half of them play. You really believe Peyton has been better? More efficient? Maybe but hardly what I would call clutch based on seeing several of his meltdowns in big games. Plus he is boring as hell to watch. Marino never won a SB and he had lots of shots so I cant agree with that. Young would be about equal IMO except that he never could beat the Favre led Packers other than TO's catch game which Jerry Rice had already fumbled away.