FOR THE LAST TIME, THE DEFENSE WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR 6-10 NOT RODGRS. YOUR BULLSHIT IS GETTING OLD. QUIT GIVNG THE DEFENSE A FEE PASS. NO ONE IS BUIYING THE BULLSHIT YOU ARE SELLING!Originally Posted by PartialTY, I ACTUALLY REALLY LIKE THIS POST
NOT REALLY, NOTHING HAS BEEN SHOWN EITHER WAY. I DON'T THINK RODGERS HAD AS GOOD OF A SEASON AS MANY HERE DO. HE WAS 6-10. WINS AND LOSSES COME BEFORE STATS. SLIGHTLY BETTER OFFENSIVE PERFORMANCES IN A FEW OF THOSE CLOSE LOSSES AND NOT RELYING SO MUCH ON THE D AND THIS TEAM IS A PLAYOFF TEAM AND MY OPINION OF RODGERS IS MUCH DIFFERENT. HE CAN'T LAY AN EGG FOR 3 QUARTERS AGAINST GOOD TEAMS.Originally Posted by Tyrone Bigguns
1. Partial tells us not to use numbers, wins and losses are how you judge a QB, but then we should be prepared for massive crow if he doesn't put up an 85. But, i thought wins and losses defined a QB.
BOTH MATTER TO A DEGREE. WHO CARES IF YOU HAVE PRETTY STATS AND LOSE? WHO CARES IF YOU HAVE UGLY STATS AND WIN? WINNING HAS TO HAPPEN FIRST AND FOREMOST.
2. Makes a comparison to VY and closing out games. VY doesn't have a large enough sample size to draw conclusions about his ability to close out games.
IF VY'S SAMPLE SIZE ISN'T BIG ENOUGH (ROTY AFTER HIS FIRST YEAR STARTING), THEN ITS PRETTY OBVIOUS THAT THE JURY IS STILL OUT ON RODGERS. I AGREE COMPLETELY THAT BOTH NEED MORE GAMES UNDER THEIR BELTS BEFORE WE CAN CONCLUDE ONE WAY OR ANOTHER.
3. Compares VY to Arod...how?
I DIDN'T MAKE THAT ARGUMENT. SOMEONE ELSE INITIALLY MADE THAT COMPARISON, NOT ME. TWO COMPLETELY DIFFERENT BALL PLAYERS. VY ISN'T SO MUCH A TRADITIONAL QB IN MY OPINION, AS I HAVE SAID ALL ALONG.
NFL IS CATCHING ON TO PARTIAL BALL. PAT WHITE AND THE WILD CAT ARE GONNA BE BIG. PUT YOUNG IN A ROLL WHERE HE ISN'T A REQUIRED TO BE A TRADITIONAL POCKET PASSER AND CAN USE HIS WHEELS AND HE'LL BE FINE.
4. Comes back with the injury prone argument. Did he miss any games last year? No. Brett was always injured, but Brett is a warrior.
NOPE, HE WAS HEALTHY IN HIS FIRST YEAR STARTING. HOWEVER, WE MISSED KEY GAMES IN 2007 WITH AN INJURY, HAD A BROKEN FOOT IN 2006, AND I BELIEVE HE GOT HURT BADLY IN 2005 AS WELL. HE'S NOT OUT OF THE WATER YET.
5. Be prepared to eat massive crow. Admin...if you don't see how he is asking for it then..well, you are just being kind. If we are suppose to be ready for crow..then he and you should be prepared for us to serve him crow...right now, since he is foolish.