I hugely admire Jay Cutler. He is that 1 in a thousand person who genuinely doesn't care what people say about him in the press. He just is who he is, and he makes no concessions to criticisms about how he looks or what people think his personality is like. The fact that players who actually know him respect him makes me think he is probably OK. It's possible he is not great in the role of a leader, since cheerleading is part of that, I really don't know.