Oh, I know the likelihood of them getting it right is not that high.
Also, nobody said he was physical or that he didn't miss tackles, in fact, everyone is pretty much in agreement on those points. What you said was "he can't tackle - just a terrible, terrible tackler."
What I said was "He's no HaHa, but it is not that bad."
I think you overstated his weakness. He is not "terrible, terrible" by any stretch of the imagination.