Crosby was fine the first half of 2012, fell apart the second half, just as Masthay did in 2014. In 2012, through the first 7 games Crosby missed three field goal attempts, from 51, 52 and 58 yards. From game 8 on, he struggled. The next year Crosby started by hitting his first 9, and went 33/37 over the season. Unlike Masthay, he didn't let his poor half-season one year carry over to the next season.

Hate to say it, but I think Masthay is broken. I really liked him as a punter in GB. Now, I shutter to think how he might perform when the weather turns bad.