Choose wisely, this is part of your permanent record.
Choose wisely, this is part of your permanent record.
Last edited by Harlan Huckleby; 08-22-2018 at 11:32 AM.
Patler will choose Bart
what is a 'QQ'?
HOFer
whats choose widely mean?
Autocorrect bit me on that one.Originally Posted by red
Autocorrect is a harsh mistress.
Cecil Isbell, baby!
"The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."
KYPack
Randy (if being this awesome is wrong, I don't want to be) Wright
We already did WOAT.
I can't decide here. Bart was the best leader, and the most successful in terms of championships, Favre was the greatest tough-guy, rocket-arm gamer, and Rodgers is the amazing, mistake-free, efficient, surgeon-of-a-QB. I refuse to pick.
What Rand said. Three different QQ’s from three different eras. Really hard to say which was best without clarifying the rating criteria.
You can clarify your own criteria. I voted for Starr because he won so much. Favre was too error prone, although he is in same league as other two. Rodgers may yet eclipse Starr.
Starr didn't have a great team around him every year he played. He was consistent.
I am surprised nobody voted for Favre yet.
I grew up watching Starr, but I didn't vote for him because he was to a great extent a product of the team around him - and the coach, of course.
I had Favre pegged as the GOAT NFL-wide - until Rodgers came along and clearly is even greater.
What could be more GOOD and NORMAL and AMERICAN than Packer Football?
on all the measureables, stats, etc...Rodgers.
on history, class, being an icon...Starr.
I was not drunk when I made this poll, I was lying in bed with a tiny android tablet I could barely read, trying to punch tiny letters with my fat fingers. It took a couple tries, but I pressed on because of the urgency of settling the GOAT QQ question once and for all. Fuck you in advance, and your mothers for what you been saying.
^^^^ It's never the crime that gets ya, but the cover-up.
I voted for bert. Win or lose, he was just so much fun to watch. Rodgers is probably better but in a boring sort of way.
Cecil Isbell -- hmmmm....
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecil_Isbell
Former NFL & Green Bay Packers record
Held the NFL record for most consecutive games with a touchdown pass with 23 games from 1940 to 1942. (These were the last 23 games of Isbell's career.) The record was later surpassed by Johnny Unitas in 1957 before Drew Brees eclipsed it in 2012. He held the Green Bay Packer record until it was later surpassed by Brett Favre in 2003.
Good company.
Isbell, Arnie Herber, Tobin Rote, even John Hadl.....
Voting fior Starr because he did win a lot; he called the plays because he had a knack for the right play at the right time.
I was a Favre loyalist. Then an “Erin” hater. Then a Rodgers stoic. Today, I idolize the Great Arm of Butte, especially since I found out where he stands on the civic rainbow (hint: far away from Tex).
Much as I now idolize Rodgers, til he wins another ring, Fave will remain the GOAT in my book. The Gunslinger won only a ring, but he single-handily turned around a moribund Packer franchise.
Win another ring, GAB!
Favre didnt single handedly do anything. Reggie signing here did.
Swede: My expertise in this area is extensive. The essential difference between a "battleship" and an "aircraft carrier" is that an aircraft carrier requires five direct hits to sink, but it takes only four direct hits to sink a battleship.
No, its gotta be Arnie Herber.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote