Studs and Duds, New Year's Eve, 2023:

[MadScientist]

Stud: Love, Jones, Reed, Melton, OLine

Dud: Toure, Carlson

[Fritz]

Stud: Love, Jones, Reed, Melton, OLine

Dud: Toure, Carlson

Carlson leads the league in missed extra points. It's almost weird, as if he's good for one a game.

Toure is only active at all any more because the rest of the position group is hurt. Dude's been passed by Heath Malik and Bo Melton and the water boy.

I would also like to add Rich Bisaccia to the "Duds" list. there was one long run-back at what could have been a key moment. Plus the Toure fumble, plus the missed extra point.

[SudsMcBucky]

Carlson leads the league in missed extra points. It's almost weird, as if he's good for one a game.

Toure is only active at all any more because the rest of the position group is hurt. Dude's been passed by Heath Malik and Bo Melton and the water boy.

I would also like to add Rich Bisaccia to the "Duds" list. there was one long run-back at what could have been a key moment. Plus the Toure fumble, plus the missed extra point.

I would say you could put blame on RB for the long run back for a poor scheme possibly, but he doesn't teach Toure to fumble or Carlson to kick OUTSIDE the goal posts.

[CaptainKickass]

Reed is the first rookie in NFL history to post 100-plus rushing yards, multiple rushing TDs, 60-plus receptions, 650-plus receiving yards and eight-plus receiving TDs.

Note that the stat says "NFL History" and not "Packers History".

Clearly Reed is in the STUD category. He's gonna be fun to watch continuing to develop.

[Fritz]

Note that the stat says "NFL History" and not "Packers History".

Clearly Reed is in the STUD category. He's gonna be fun to watch continuing to develop.

I don't disagree, Cap'n. I would only remind everyone that when we talk about Reed breaking Sterling Sharpe's record, he also did it in sixteen games - same number of games that Sharpe had. That's impressive.

[Patler]

I don't disagree, Cap'n. I would only remind everyone that when we talk about Reed breaking Sterling Sharpe's record, he also did it in sixteen games - same number of games that Sharpe had. That's impressive.

Minor detail, but Reed actually did it in 15 games played. He was inactive for the Carolina game.

[Fritz]

Minor detail, but Reed actually did it in 15 games played. He was inactive for the Carolina game.

Even more impressive.

When players break season records now, it bothers me that people don't talk about the fact that teams have an extra game now, and an extra three games compared to the earlier days when teams played fourteen games. So for Reed to not need that "extra" game was impressive to me.

[Patler]

Even more impressive.

When players break season records now, it bothers me that people don't talk about the fact that teams have an extra game now, and an extra three games compared to the earlier days when teams played fourteen games. So for Reed to not need that "extra" game was impressive to me.

yup, or 5 games more than the 12 game seasons that I remember from the '50s and early '60s. Reed will shatter Sharpe's record in his first 16 games, kind of making up for the jet sweep "passes" that I think should be considered rushing more than passing.