Quote Originally Posted by Ratatouille View Post
Both have only won a single SB but Payton's offensive schemes & play calling are much better than McCarthy's. Drew Brees is a good QB but not in the same class as Rodgers. I believe if Payton & Rodgers had been paired together it would have been more than one SB. So does you question imply that McCarthy is just as good a coach as Payton?
This may be so - we'll never know unless we gain access to the multiverse - but I did read recently that Payton wanted a QB who did not "wing it" like say Fields and Russell Wilson, so he probably would've like all of Rodgers's complicated play calling. "If this, then this. If I nod with my LEFT eyebrow, I want the X reciever to go LEFT, not right, and the Y guy to go straight, not out. And if I wiggle my ass twice - not three times, twice - it means the running back needs to stay in and block, and the tight end must release immediately, but not over the middle. Never over the middle."