I'll take Jordy over Jennings. His career stats were better (despite being a sub for his first three years), and his peak was better.
Since I started watching, it goes like this for me:
Sharpe
Lofton
Adams
Jordy
Driver
Jennings
Freeman
Hutson is #1 with Dowler and Dale getting top 10 consideration, if you go back further.
I like Jennings ahead of Driver and really close, but very different than Nelson. I’d put those two on the same tier. Never saw Lofton other than a few highlights, but I’m not surprised.