Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 23

Thread: Draft Rankings

  1. #1

    Draft Rankings

    I've finished QBs. Who I chose to evaluate was based on either CBS Sports or ESPN (which are the two sites I trust the most on draft rankings) giving the player a draftable grade. Then, I threw in any player who was invited to the combine. I'd occasionally throw in a player who I was intrigued by.

    At QB the following QBs were given a draftable grade--except Josh Woodrum, Trevone Boykin, and Jake Rudock. Woodrum and Boykin were invited to the combine. Rudock intrigued me, mainly because the guy started at Iowa and put up decent stats one year. Then, transferred to Michigan, started, and put up decent stats the next year. That gave me a list of 20 QBs to evaluate.

    RANKINGS

    Code:
    Pos  Rk  Rd     Player                School                CRk  CRd    Hgt   Wgt  40yd  Sht   3-Cone  Vert  Broad
    QB   1   1      Carson Wentz          North Dakota State    1    1      6'5"  237  4.77  4.15  6.86    30.5  118
    QB   2   1      Jared Goff            California            2    1      6'4"  215  4.82  4.47  7.17    27.0  110
    QB   3   1-2    Paxton Lynch          Memphis               3    1-2    6'7"  244  4.86  4.26  7.14    36.0  118
    QB   4   3      Connor Cook           Michigan State        4    1-2    6'4"  217  4.79  4.28  7.21    33.0  113
    QB   5   3-4    Cardale Jones         Ohio State            8    4-6    6'5"  253  4.81                36.0     
    QB   6   4      Jacoby Brissett       North Carolina State  7    3-5    6'4"  231  4.94  4.53  7.17    31.0  113
    QB   7   4      Dak Prescott          Mississippi State     6    3-4    6'2"  226  4.79  4.32  7.11    32.5  116
    QB   8   5      Kevin Hogan           Stanford              9    5-6    6'3"  218  4.78  4.31  6.90    32.5  113
    QB   9   5-6    Christian Hackenberg  Penn State            5    2-3    6'4"  223  4.78  4.33  7.04    31.0  114
    QB   10  5-6    Jeff Driskel          Louisiana Tech        14   5-FA   6'4"  234  4.56  4.25  7.19    32.0  122
    QB   11  6      Brandon Allen         Arkansas              11   6-7    6'1"  217  4.84  4.33  7.06    28.0  110
    QB   12  7      JAKE COKER            Alabama               16   7-FA   6'6"  244                              
    QB   13  7-FA   Vernon Adams          Oregon                15   7-FA   5'11" 200  4.83  4.20  6.82    29.5  114
    QB   14  PFA    Brandon Doughty       Western Kentucky      12   5-FA   6'3"  213  5.22  4.52  7.49    27.0  103
    QB   15  PFA    Cody Kessler          USC                   10   5-7    6'1"  220  4.89  4.00  7.32    29.5  104
    QB   16  FA     Joel Stave            Wisconsin             18   7-FA   6'5"  236  4.80  4.33  7.29    33.5  115
    QB   17  FA     Nate Sudfeld          Indiana               13   7-FA   6'6"  234                      29.0  105
    QB   18  FA     JAKE RUDOCK           Michigan              17   7-FA   6'3"  199                                
    QB   19  FA     Josh Woodrum          Liberty               19   FA     6'3"  231  4.80  4.31  6.74    31.0  117 
    QB   20  FA     Trevone Boykin        TCU                   20   FA     6'0"  212  4.77  4.40          32.0  110
    Code:
    Pos  Rk  Rd     Player                Size   SAA    Arm    Acc    Mech   Pre    Post   Poise  Leader  Scheme Fit       Comparison
    QB   1   1      Carson Wentz          Great  Great  Good   Great  Solid  Great  Solid  Good   Great   Versatile        Carson Palmer
    QB   2   1      Jared Goff            Good   Avg    Solid  Good   Great  Great  Good   Solid  Great   Precision        Matt Ryan
    QB   3   1-2    Paxton Lynch          Great  Solid  Good   Good   Avg    Good   Solid  Great  Good    Versatile        Joe Flacco
    QB   4   3      Connor Cook           Good   Solid  Solid  Solid  Solid  Good   Good   Avg    Avg     Precision        Kirk Cousins
    QB   5   3-4    Cardale Jones         Great  Good   Great  Solid  Poor   Poor   Avg    Good   Solid   Vertical/Option  Daunte Culpepper
    QB   6   4      Jacoby Brissett       Good   Poor   Solid  Solid  Avg    Solid  Avg    Solid  Good    Versatile        Brett Hundley
    QB   7   4      Dak Prescott          Avg    Solid  Solid  Avg    Avg    Good   Avg    Poor   Great   Option           David Garrard
    QB   8   5      Kevin Hogan           Solid  Good   Solid  Good   Poor   Great  Great  Solid  Great   Precision        Ryan Fitzpatrick
    QB   9   5-6    Christian Hackenberg  Good   Solid  Good   Poor   Solid  Solid  Avg    Poor   Solid   Vertical         Blaine Gabbert
    QB   10  5-6    Jeff Driskel          Good   Great  Good   Avg    Good   Avg    Avg    Poor   Good    Vertical   
    QB   11  6      Brandon Allen         Poor   Solid  Solid  Solid  Solid  Good   Solid  Solid  Great   Precision        Case Keenum
    QB   12  7      JAKE COKER            Great  Avg    Good   Avg    Poor   Solid  Avg    Solid  Solid   Vertical         Dan Orlovsky
    QB   13  7-FA   Vernon Adams          Poor   Good   Solid  Solid  Avg    Avg    Avg    Poor   Great   Precison/Option  Seneca Wallace
    QB   14  PFA    Brandon Doughty       Solid  Poor   Poor   Good   Solid  Great  Solid  Poor   Great   Precision        A.J. McCarron
    QB   15  PFA    Cody Kessler          Poor   Solid  Avg    Solid  Solid  Solid  Great  Solid  Good    Precision        Matt Flynn
    QB   16  FA     Joel Stave            Great  Solid  Solid  Avg    Solid  Avg    Poor   Poor   Solid   Versatile   
    QB   17  FA     Nate Sudfeld          Great  Poor   Solid  Solid  Poor   Solid  Avg    Avg    Good    Versatile        Sean Mannion
    QB   18  FA     JAKE RUDOCK           Solid  Solid  Poor   Solid  Avg    Good   Good   Solid  Good    Precision   
    QB   19  FA     Josh Woodrum          Solid  Good   Avg    Solid  Poor   Solid  Avg    Poor   Great   Precision   
    QB   20  FA     Trevone Boykin        Poor   Good   Avg    Solid  Poor   Solid  Poor   Avg    Solid   Option           Pat White
    I won't get into why I like or don't like certain players because I don't have the time right now, but I thought I'd throw this out there to start a draft conversation. The second column is my ranking. The third column is my projection of where I'd draft the player. CRk is the consensus ranking of CBS, ESPN, and Draft Countdown. CRd is the range of when the player is projected to get drafted amongst those three sites. I generally don't trust sites like Draft Countdown, but this site usually ranks high in the rankings of rankings. I'll replace this one with McGinn's rankings when they come out. McGinn's rankings are normally at or near the top when it comes to rankings of rankings. The other columns are explained in more detail below. The last two columns are scheme fit and NFL comparison.

    CHART

    Code:
    Trait                                 Column      Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Size (Hgt)                            1 - Size    6'5"   6'4"   6'3"   6'2"   6'1"
    Speed, Acceleration, & Agility (SpR)  2 - SAA     71+    66-70  61-65  56-60  55-
    Arm Strength                          3 - Arm     Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Accuracy                              4 - Acc     Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Mechanics                             5 - Mech    Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Pre-Snap Reads                        6 - Pre     Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Post-Snap Progressions                7 - Post    Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Poise In The Pocket                   8 - Poise   Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    Leadership & Toughness                9 - Leader  Great  Good   Solid  Avg    Poor
    The first two traits are based on measurables. For SAA I use a modified SPARQ rating that I found on a Seahawks board a few years ago. There was analysis on what drills correlate to success in the NFL at each position. For QBs the only combine measurable (besides height and hand size) that really meant anything was SAA which combined 40 time, 3 cone drill, and short shuttle to measure mobility. Wentz, for example, had a solid 4.77 40 (2nd best in this draft, but historically slightly above average), but his measurements in the short shuttle and 3 cone suggests he has really good mobility (which I think the tape validates).
    Last edited by HarveyWallbangers; 03-13-2016 at 01:54 AM.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  2. #2
    Great. I spend all of that time and then the formatting of the table is all screwed up. It looked fine when I was previewing the post. I'm gonna see if two tables works. It did.
    Last edited by HarveyWallbangers; 03-13-2016 at 01:52 AM.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  3. #3
    I didn't realize a post couldn't be more than 10,000 characters until now.

    I will say that I like Carson Wentz. I'm not quite as high on him as Winston and Mariota from last year, but I like him better than Bortles, Carr, and Bridgewater from two years ago. I tried to be as objective as I could. My "ah ha" moment for him was watching tape of him against South Dakota State on the road. SDSU was a top 5 team with comparable talent, and the Bison blew them out. Wentz showed a lot of NFL throws in that game. His receivers are slow (probably the biggest weakness on the Bison the last two years), so he's often throwing into tight windows--which I think has helped him. The other thing is there really isn't tape of him having bad games. His footwork was inconsistent his first year starting, but improved dramatically as a senior. There are some bad throws, but most games I came away impressed. Even a guy like Goff had some atrocious games (USC and Utah games stand out).

    People make assumptions about the level of competition, but the Bison played a pro style offense. Wentz had a lot of pre-snap responsiblities (both with play call and protection). Often, pre-snap reads were more important than post-snap progressions (think ARod with the Packers), so at times it appears that he just locked onto his primary target, but I don't think that's true. When he has to, he's shown the ability to progress through his reads, both high-low and east-west. I think he's probably further along than people realize, despite the level of competition. The knocks I have on him are: 1) he's had some injuries, 2) he can be careless with the ball when he's scrambling, 3) he sometimes trusts his arm too much (but in a way I like that; he's no game manager).

    Something else to chew on. Division I-AA QBs don't generally get drafted in the first round because they have to overcome the level of competition doubts. When they do, they are generally successful. Three of the last four Division I-AA QBs to get drafted in the first round took their team to the Super Bowl. Two won the Super Bowl, and McNair was two yards short of winning. That doesn't count Super Bowl winning Division I-AA QBs like Doug Williams and Kurt Warner because those guys didn't get drafted in the first round.

    I'd love some feedback. It makes me defend my positions, and it opens my eyes to things I haven't seen or makes me step back and look at more film of a player.
    Last edited by HarveyWallbangers; 03-13-2016 at 01:51 AM.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  4. #4
    Moose Rat HOFer woodbuck27's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    30,498
    A lot of fine work there HarveyWallbangers.

    The Cleveland Brown Organization needs your report.

    Add the Denver Broncos. What a mess their in now.
    ** Since 2006 3 X Pro Pickem' Champion; 4 X Runner-Up and 3 X 3rd place.
    ** To download Jesus Loves Me ring tones, you'll need a cell phone mame
    ** If God doesn't fish, play poker or pull for " the Packers ", exactly what does HE do with his buds?
    ** Rather than love, money or fame - give me TRUTH: Henry D. Thoreau

  5. #5
    Has anybody looked at any of the QBs this year?
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  6. #6
    Senior Rat HOFer Carolina_Packer's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Cary, NC
    Posts
    3,384
    Quote Originally Posted by HarveyWallbangers View Post
    Has anybody looked at any of the QBs this year?
    Nice work, Harv. It doesn't look like there have been any QB's climbing up the draft board. There are certain QB's who get ranked a little higher for some a little lower for others, but with no great variance. Some like Wentz, Goff and Lynch top 3, and some like Goff, Wentz and Lynch.

    What's apparent to me is that if you are in the market for a QB this year, get one early. There may be a QB outside the top 3 that hits in the NFL, but who knows. Cardale Jones has a great arm, but will he be able to handle and NFL offense and reading defenses?

    Jeff Driskill, the FL kid who transferred to LA Tech may be a dark horse QB to make it in the league. If he goes to a place where he's not needed right away, which is very likely, and a place where they aren't turning over coaching staffs or coordinators every couple of years, he might be something.
    "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts." -Daniel Patrick Moynihan

  7. #7
    Moose Rat HOFer woodbuck27's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    30,498
    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2...nesota-Vikings

    Best fits for College QB's and 2016 Draft....an opinion from a source NOT mine:

    " ...Drafting a quarterback is not just about need. It’s about fit. Since they're in the most difficult position to transition from college to the pros, quarterbacks need offenses catered to their skill sets, coaching staffs willing to develop them and teammate support to encourage their growth.... "
    ** Since 2006 3 X Pro Pickem' Champion; 4 X Runner-Up and 3 X 3rd place.
    ** To download Jesus Loves Me ring tones, you'll need a cell phone mame
    ** If God doesn't fish, play poker or pull for " the Packers ", exactly what does HE do with his buds?
    ** Rather than love, money or fame - give me TRUTH: Henry D. Thoreau

  8. #8
    Senior Rat HOFer beveaux1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Louisiana
    Posts
    5,669
    Good work! You spent quite a bit of time on it. I don't think 20 will be drafted, but there might be 15 or so taken. The others will be un drafted FAs on someone's roster.

  9. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by beveaux1 View Post
    Good work! You spent quite a bit of time on it. I don't think 20 will be drafted, but there might be 15 or so taken. The others will be un drafted FAs on someone's roster.
    20 won't be drafted. Normally, 11-12 are drafted. Last year it was just 7-8. However, 18 were invited to the combine. I added Coker because national championship QBs generally get drafted (Matt Flynn anybody). Rudock intrigued me because he was a guy who was solid at Iowa. Then, he was solid in a new system at Michigan the next year. That's unusual. I gave him a priority FA grade.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  10. #10
    Oracle Rat HOFer Cheesehead Craig's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Ruling the Meadow!
    Posts
    10,786
    Come on Harv. You only have about a month to get this finished up. Get your lazy ass moving!
    All hail the Ruler of the Meadow!

  11. #11
    In my opinion, we should draft Billings, not Rankins.

  12. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheesehead Craig View Post
    Come on Harv. You only have about a month to get this finished up. Get your lazy ass moving!
    I got through most of the skill position players, but I'm running out of steam.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  13. #13
    Red Devil Rat HOFer gbgary's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    up the road from jerrahworld
    Posts
    14,529
    dang! great work!

  14. #14
    Moose Rat HOFer woodbuck27's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    30,498
    Quote Originally Posted by HarveyWallbangers View Post
    20 won't be drafted. Normally, 11-12 are drafted. Last year it was just 7-8. However, 18 were invited to the combine. I added Coker because national championship QBs generally get drafted (Matt Flynn anybody). Rudock intrigued me because he was a guy who was solid at Iowa. Then, he was solid in a new system at Michigan the next year. That's unusual. I gave him a priority FA grade.
    I was watching the NFL Network this morning and Charlie Casserly was commenting on the Draft and QB and liked these guys after Jared Goff and Connor Wentz:

    A) Connor Cook - Michigan State

    http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings...2016&genpos=QB

    B) Paxton Lynch - Memphis

    http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings...2016&genpos=QB

    Then he spoke of this fella and his athleticism his strong arm and the fact he's 'a winner':

    C) Kevin Hogan - Stanford - All this guy does is lead his team to wins. He's the most successful QB in school history. He has the most wins of any active QB in the country. He protects the ball very well.

    http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings...2016&genpos=QB
    ** Since 2006 3 X Pro Pickem' Champion; 4 X Runner-Up and 3 X 3rd place.
    ** To download Jesus Loves Me ring tones, you'll need a cell phone mame
    ** If God doesn't fish, play poker or pull for " the Packers ", exactly what does HE do with his buds?
    ** Rather than love, money or fame - give me TRUTH: Henry D. Thoreau

  15. #15
    The TE class is pretty weak. Hunter Henry is a good prospect, but I don't think he's a 1st round talent. I like both Austin Hooper and Nick Vannett, but I think they are more 3rd round talents. I'm really high on Tyler Higbee. Right now, I have him at #2 at TE. I need to do a bit more research. Hooper seems to have a higher floor, but I think Higbee has the higher ceiling. There's buzz around Jerell Adams, but when I watched him at the combine, he didn't look like a natural pass catcher. Thomas Duarte doesn't have typical TE size, but with the success of Jordan Reed, Duarte is now a bit more intriguing. Same with Kyle Carter. He's a bit undersized, but he's a good athlete. Another sleeper that I like is Darion Griswold of Arkansas State.

    Anybody think Tanner McEvoy can make a conversion to TE? Some have him as a draftable player late. Others don't. I don't know where to rate him because there's nothing to go on. It's all projection with him.
    Last edited by HarveyWallbangers; 04-06-2016 at 01:14 AM.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  16. #16
    Senior Rat HOFer Maxie the Taxi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Loon Lake, Florida
    Posts
    9,287
    Quote Originally Posted by HarveyWallbangers View Post
    Anybody think Tanner McEvoy can make a conversion to TE? Some have him as a draftable player late. Others don't. I don't know where to rate him because there's nothing to go on. It's all projection with him.
    I've been on that bandwagon for months.
    One time Lombardi was disgusted with the team in practice and told them they were going to have to start with the basics. He held up a ball and said: "This is a football." McGee immediately called out, "Stop, coach, you're going too fast," and that gave everyone a laugh.
    John Maxymuk, Packers By The Numbers

  17. #17
    Would anybody here trade Rodgers for Wentz? With Rodgers getting up there in age and with all the money you'd save, it made me question whether I'd pull the trigger. It's a bit amazing that Wentz has played so well that this even gave me pause. Of course, it could just be my Bison homerism.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

  18. #18
    Postal Rat HOFer Joemailman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    In a van down by the river
    Posts
    32,554
    He's played really well but it's still a small sample size. Let's see how he handles adversity, which he hasn't really faced yet. I thought Matt Ryan looked great as a rookie, but he's kind of leveled off. Good, but not in the Rodgers/Brady class.

  19. #19
    Legendary Rat HOFer vince's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    God's Country
    Posts
    5,363
    Blog Entries
    6
    Money would be the only reason and rookie deals don't last forever. Wentz has a ton of tools but at this point looks like he could stand to speed up his release. I don't see him having Rodgers elite mobility/ability to extend plays either. Rodgers has the physical tools and mental acumen to be the GOAT. Not sure Wentz will ever be in that territory in terms of physical ability.

    Great call on him pre-draft though. I jumped onboard too after studying him a bit.

  20. #20
    Wentz will better than Ryan. I think he and Winston are the best young QBs in the game, but I think I'd take Wentz. The guy is impressive. It's not that surprising if you watched tape of Wentz that he'd do this eventually, but to think he could look this good this early after playing FCS football and missing almost all of the preseason is ridiculous. It's not because of a gimmicky toolset (e.g. RGIII and Mariota) that teams need time to adjust to either.
    "There's a lot of interest in the draft. It's great. But quite frankly, most of the people that are commenting on it don't know anything about what they are talking about."--Ted Thompson

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •