They both flashed pretty well their rookie year. Enough the Packers (and everyone else) let Hayward go. With Shields, Randall, and Rollins, the CBs looked set for another five years. Then concussion and injury/regression.
It really is a bit confusing. Randall, at least, looked like he was going to be a real player. Now he's a dollar short and a day late.
"The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."