Pittsburgh - 1995 finale I presume.
I recall McMahon playing in mop-up duty in '96. He still threw a nice deep ball. Of course there was no Gault to run under it so it fell harmlessly to the turf about 5 yards away from the receiver (Freeman?). I think that was his only incomplete pass for the Packers. He had a 105.2 passer rating to Favre's 95.8.