Overreaction to last year? Or prudent policy given the current crop of starters?

Nelson (old and coming off injury)
Cobb (young vet but also coming back from injury, probably never your #1)
Adams (horrific 2nd year, bit of unknown, injuries)
Monty (young and injured for much of 2015 and 2016 offseason)
Abby (young and concussion prone)
Janis (ST ace, athletically gifted, still hasn't caught up on offense, also injured)
Davis (young, thin and injured = unreleased David Bowie album and persona)