An Attempt At Discussing McCarthy's Future

[ThunderDan]

Didn't you see the game?

Did you miss anything here Thunderdan?

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com...arthy-blew-it/

Yes, I saw the game.

Yes, I read your article and still think that getting points early in the game was the right call. We were ahead by two scores with 2:30 left in the game.

Now please answer my question.

If Bostick does his job and Jordy gets the onside kick do we win the game?

[woodbuck27]

Yes, I saw the game.

Yes, I read your article and still think that getting points early in the game was the right call. We were ahead by two scores with 2:30 left in the game.

Now please answer my question.

If Bostick does his job and Jordy gets the onside kick do we win the game?

The probability of a win does improve if the Packers recover that onside kick.

Does that positive result then mean we win?

NO!

Your obviously from a management background. Your trained to blame the little guy.

Over the top too much more than the Brandon Bostick flub lent itself to the Packers blowing the game.

A game that should not have even been close if the Packers offense had been called and was executed just marginally better.

[pbmax]

The probability of a win does improve if the Packers recover that onside kick.

Does that positive result then mean we win?

NO!

Your obviously from a management background. Your trained to blame the little guy.

Over the top too much more than the Brandon Bostick flub lent itself to the Packers blowing the game.

A game that should not have even been close if the Packers offense had been called and was executed just marginally better.

And woodbuck, sometimes you seemed trained to lose the forest through the trees.

I maintain that Bostick needed to get his head out of his ass and do his job on the onside kick and the game was over.

Of course one first down by the O sealed the deal also.

[woodbuck27]

And woodbuck, sometimes you seemed trained to lose the forest through the trees.

In this argument you sure have that one backwards and 'my stance'.

Why can't your side 'the Madison Crew' ... 'see the forest from the trees' pbmax?

[pbmax]

In this argument you sure have that one backwards and 'my stance'.

Why can't your side 'the Madison Crew' ... 'see the forest from the trees' pbmax?

Dan:

I maintain that Bostick needed to get his head out of his ass and do his job on the onside kick and the game was over.

Of course one first down by the O sealed the deal also.

Woodbuck responds with:

No ThunderDan you cannot slip it all on Brandon Bostick.

Read what Aaron Rodgers is saying:

[woodbuck27]

Dan:


Woodbuck responds with:

We can get.... on the streets fricken' shitty with one another; or use the God given brains hopefully we're equipped with.

I won't argue what's over the top too obvious.

That was a top to bottom total team loss yesterday.

Time to see Ted Thompson behind a real change. Time for Ted Thompson to really manage it all.

Mike McCarthy has to be set on a different course.

I'm sure that Aaron Rodgers will have plenty of his 'in your face' to say to Mike McCarthy. He needs the support of Ted Thompson and we need to see things shaken up on the coaching staff.

[pbmax]

We can get.... on the streets fricken' shitty with one another; or use the God given brains hopefully we're equipped with.

I won't argue what over the top too obvious.

That was a top to bottom total team loss yesterday.

Time to see Ted Thompson behind a real change. Time for Ted Thompson to really manage it all.

Mike McCarthy has to be set on a different course.

I'm sure that Aaron Rodgers will have plenty of his 'in your face' to say to Mike McCarthy. He needs the support of Ted Thompson and we need to see things shaken up on the coaching staff.

Any one of six things could be changed slightly with better player performance and no coaching alterations and the game is won. Burnett's INT non-return, Jordy's near TD catch, 3rd and 1 goal line (twice), HHCD's near-INT in his freaking hands, Brad Jones FG non-play, Lacy's 3rd and 3 non-first down (Gained 2 yards), Rodgers slant pass to Cobb on 3rd down that was low and could not be turned into a first down.

Bostick's was among the most egregious because it was a mental mistake before it was a physical one. He was supposed to block the guy who recovered the ball. He didn't and then he didn't deliver. Its an obvious turning point that likely would have ended the game.

But the problem with discussing this topic with you is that you still pay NO attention to the second sentence in Dan's post, where he says the Offense could have won it too (agreeing with your ARod quote below his post). You also ignore his answer to another question that while the defense sagged, the offense had as many failings, if not more.

So you take the sentence out of context and pretend he said something he didn't. If that was done to you, we would get a 5,000 word post about how you have been slandered and that everyone should head out to the Meadow. All I am asking you to do is read the entire freaking post.

[mraynrand]

Mike McCarthy has to be set on a different course.

I hope not. 7/9 seasons of playoff football, three championship games and a Super Bowl. I would take that for the next 9 years in a second if you had the power to offer it.

[Pugger]

Yes, I saw the game.

Yes, I read your article and still think that getting points early in the game was the right call. We were ahead by two scores with 2:30 left in the game.

Now please answer my question.

If Bostick does his job and Jordy gets the onside kick do we win the game?

How much time was left, was it under a minute at that point? If so then yes, we win that game and we aren't all in mourning.