Quote Originally Posted by Pugger View Post
IMO McKinney in the first would have been a much bigger reach than Randall ever was. I wanted Anthony in that spot.
We'll see... the knock on McKinney was, as I remember, instincts. There isn't any doubt about his physical ability.

Randall on the other hand, is a huge projection to the outside, and his terrible tackling and angles shows up on film all the time. Someone posted that there were scouts that said he was a "hitter" and a good tackler... can't imagine what they were looking at, unless it was just at the number of "tackles" he was credited for. A lot of his tackles were where he was hanging on and waiting for help, or he was the nearest defender that escorted someone out of bounds.

As for making an open field tackle, or making jarring hits?? That sure as heckfire isn't Randall. Like I said, I thought he was a mid-round pick. Go on youtube and watch some of his games... it's on the tape.