RB Ratings at FoxSports ridiculous

[Guiness]

Here's the dumb list (http://msn.foxsports.com/fantasy/story/5495694)

As a charter member of the Samkon Gado fanclub I call BS on this list. Talk about no respect! They got him rated as the 58th back in the league, between Eric Shelton and Greg Jones. There are at least four draftees, with zero carries, rated ahead of him.

The first 7 are roughly right, if debatable. Personally, I'd take LT over Johnson or Alexander, but it could be argued either way.

But - how does R. Brown rate #8? And speaking only of GB backs, if Davenport should be rated above Gado, I'll eat my shorts.

[BlueBrewer]

Can you post the list?

[Guiness]

Link is in my first post

1 Larry Johnson KC
2 Shaun Alexander SEA 1
3 L. Tomlinson SD
4 Tiki Barber NYG
5 Clinton Portis WAS
6 Edgerrin James ARI
7 Rudi Johnson CIN
8 Ronnie Brown MIA
9 LaMont Jordan OAK
10 Steven Jackson STL
11 Julius Jones DAL
12 Carnell Williams TB
13 Tatum Bell DEN
14 Willis McGahee BUF
15 Domanick Davis HOU
16 Deuce McAllister NO
17 Reuben Droughns CLE
18 Willie Parker PIT
19 Kevin Jones DET
20 Thomas Jones CHI
21 Brian Westbrook PHI
22 Chester Taylor MIN
23 Jamal Lewis BAL
24 Warrick Dunn ATL
25 DeShaun Foster CAR
26 Dominic Rhodes IND
27 Ahman Green GB
28 Corey Dillon NE
29 Reggie Bush TBD
30 Fred Taylor JAC
31 Curtis Martin NYJ
32 Chris Brown TEN
33 Frank Gore SF
34 Priest Holmes KC
35 Joseph Addai IND
36 Mike Anderson BAL
37 Laurence Maroney NE
38 Kevan Barlow SF
39 Ron Dayne DEN
40 Cedric Benson CHI
41 Chris Perry CIN
42 Ryan Moats PHI
43 Duce Staley PIT
44 Marion Barber DAL
45 Brandon Jacobs NYG
46 T.J. Duckett ATL
47 Mewelde Moore MIN
48 Najeh Davenport GB
49 DeAngelo Williams CAR
50 Travis Henry TEN
51 Marshall Faulk STL
52 Maurice Drew JAC
53 Maurice Morris SEA
54 Michael Pittman TB
55 LenDale White TEN
56 Anthony Thomas BUF
57 Eric Shelton CAR
58 Samkon Gado GB
59 Greg Jones JAC
60 Michael Bennett NO
61 Maurice Hicks SF
62 J.J. Arrington ARI
63 Verron Haynes PIT
64 Adrian Peterson CHI
65 Ladell Betts WAS
66 Michael Turner SD
67 Cedric Houston NYJ
68 Lee Suggs CLE
69 Antowain Smith HOU
70 Shaud Williams BUF
71 Zack Crockett OAK
72 Shawn Bryson DET
73 LaBrandon Toefield JAC
74 Marcel Shipp ARI
75 Mike Alstott TB

[BlueBrewer]

How can Tatum Bell Be 13, i thought they weren't even sure he would be the starter.

[Joemailman]

This list was for Fantasy Football purposes. Because nobody really knows who will emerge as the Packer's starting running back, it goes to reason that none of the Packer backs would be rated very highly. Therefore, an average back like Detroit's Kevin Jones rates higher than any of the Packer backs simply because Jones is clearly the starter. Gado could be a great "sleeper" pick in fantasy football if he doesn't blow his cover with a great pre-season.

[Guiness]

This list was for Fantasy Football purposes. Because nobody really knows who will emerge as the Packer's starting running back, it goes to reason that none of the Packer backs would be rated very highly. Therefore, an average back like Detroit's Kevin Jones rates higher than any of the Packer backs simply because Jones is clearly the starter. Gado could be a great "sleeper" pick in fantasy football if he doesn't blow his cover with a great pre-season.

Got that, and that's also why Brown is rated so high - Williams is out of town, so no more sharing.

BUT Gado has a chance to get some serious carries in GB. Davenport? Nyet.

[Packgator]

Don't give to much credit to the guy who made this list. Look who he has ranked 32 on the "kicker" list.

http://msn.foxsports.com/fantasy/story/5515288

1 Adam Vinatieri IND
2 Shayne Graham CIN
3 Neil Rackers ARI
4 Mike Vanderjagt
5 John Kasay CAR
6 Josh Brown SEA
7 Lawrence Tynes KAN
8 Jay Feely NYG
9 Ryan Longwell MIN
10 Jeff Reed PIT
11 Jeff Wilkins DEN
12 Jason Elam STL
13 Matt Stover BAL
14 David Akers PHI
15 Olindo Mare MIA
16 Nate Kaeding SD
17 Phil Dawson CLE
18 Rian Lindell BUF
19 S. Janikowski OAK
20 Todd Peterson ATL
21 Kris Brown HOU
22 Jason Hanson DET
23 John Carney NO
24 M. Gramatica NE
25 Josh Scobee JAC
26 Joe Nedney SF
27 Mike Nugent NYJ
28 Rob Bironas TEN
29 John Hall WAS
30 Matt Bryant TAM
31 Robbie Gould CHI
32 B.J. Sander GB

[Harlan Huckleby]

Alstott is the worst? That's a little harsh. And how can Green be ahead of Gado after poor season and serious injury?