Question for you

[b bulldog]

What QB would you take out of these three QB's and why?
Eli Manning
Phillip Rivers
Ben Rosthlisberger

[Badgepack]

I'm taking Big Ben, proven winner, big tough QB.

Eli is too frail, may get hurt, but had a heck of a postseason.

Rivers seems like a total prick, bad personality for a team.

[b bulldog]

All three have been very successful. I think next year, Rivers will get his ring.

[RashanGary]

I could see the Colts winning next year. If we dont' win another, I'd like to see Peyton add another to his trophy room.

[b bulldog]

Colts are a good choice imo but they have some age at key positions and they have some big decisions to make regarding their UFA's

[HarveyWallbangers]

Roethlisberger

[Deputy Nutz]

I think I go with Eli, after this performance in the playoffs maybe he finally gets his confidence under control and becomes steady when faced with a challenge.

[BF4MVP]

All three have been very successful, but I think next year, Favre will get another ring.
Fixed 8-)

[BF4MVP]

I'll take Roethlisberger. He has as many rings as Eli, but over the course of their careers, Big Ben has had more success. Eli was an average quarterback at best until about week 16 of this year..

[BallHawk]

Eli with Roethlisberger a close 2nd. Rivers has some talent but I think his arrogance hurts him.

Speaking of young QBs, we will see Trent Edwards become a top 15 QB in the next year or two.

[b bulldog]

Agree and the Bills are a team on the rise but I don't like their coach.

[gbgary]

I'm taking Big Ben, proven winner, big tough QB.


Roethlisberger


I'll take Roethlisberger.

http://www.digitalcorvettes.com/forums/images/smilies/iagree.gif

[b bulldog]

Ben is very good but the Steelers are on the way down in their division, Rivers will have a great chance next season to get his ring and he is surrounded by the most talented roster in football and Eli has had a great stretch of games but it is still very early in his progression to see if this is what he will be for the long haul.

[Partial]

Big Ben. It pains me to say it for personal reasons.

[Harlan Huckleby]

I go with Eli because he's got good genetics.

[The Shadow]

I suppose Old Man Rivers - beacuse he jes keeps a'rollin' along.

[MadtownPacker]

I go with Eli because he's got good genetics.I'll agree with this little buttercup. He talks like he knows how to pick good men.

[Cheesehead Craig]

Big Ben. Least likely to get hurt by a non-motor vehicle accident of the three.

[4and12to12and4]

Eli is the easy choice right now because he just slayed four giants. (pun intended) But, he still has to prove he can do it with consistency. Rivers hasn't proven anything to me except he's a bigger asshole than Palmer, so, Ben seems to be the choice. I don't think any of them are that great, I'd rather have Aaron Rodgers.

[vince]

I'd rather have Aaron Rodgers.
:wow:
I like the way you go out on a limb 4and12. That's a bold statement to make with not much more than a a few preseason games and one good game to go on.

I think I'd take Ben, but given Rodgers' good arm strength, mobility, McCarthy's proven success developing QB's who make good decisions, and the way this team is being built around him, I'm not so sure that you won't be right in the end.

[MJZiggy]

I go with Eli because he's got good genetics.I'll agree with this little buttercup. He talks like he knows how to pick good men.

Does he give lessons?

[pbmax]

Ben. Although its close, Manning won with many of his eventual weapons hurt at key points during the season.

[LL2]

Aaron Rodgers. Let's see what the guy can do.