American Idol

[RashanGary]

Who do you like?


I think David Cook is the best of this bunch. Carly Smithson is good too, but David Cook seems like a star.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Who do you like?


I think David Cook is the best of this bunch. Carly Smithson is good too, but David Cook seems like a star.

Someone needs to kick you in the vagina.

[RashanGary]

Hahahaha, I know I acctually watch American Idol regularly. I don't even know who won last year or who was on it. The year before either. For some reason I'm watching that show this year and I like it.


Go ahead, kick me in the box :)

[Partial]

The kid is by far the best singer. He might be the best singer they have ever had on their.

[BallHawk]

Pissed that Chikeeze got kicked off. He could sing, had a bit of ol' Ray Charles in him. Just choose a bad song.

Smithson shouldn't even be on the show. Her tattoo annoys me. I hate her.

Cook is talented (has plenty of experience touring across the country. :roll: ) but he thinks way too highly of himself. Good singer, great performer, overcocky.

Archuleta is talented, but I don't think he'll win.

The asian chick kinda sucks. So does Kristy Lee Cook.

Brooke is alright. The black chick can sing but she has no personality so she automatically loses. Castro is a weak singer that hides behind his guitar and dreadlocks.

I'm rooting for Michael Johns from this point. He's the only one, now that Chikeeze is gone, that has a combination of a good voice and a good personality.

[BallHawk]

The kid is by far the best singer. He might be the best singer they have ever had on their.

He's not even top 5.

[Partial]

The kid is by far the best singer. He might be the best singer they have ever had on their.

He's not even top 5.

Who is better? I have seen a lot of people and the only one I think that was close was Constantine or Bo Bice. He is very, very, very talented. He is always in tune and has excellent range.

[BallHawk]

The kid is by far the best singer. He might be the best singer they have ever had on their.

He's not even top 5.

Are you kidding me? Who is better? I have seen a lot of people and the only one I think that was close was Constantine or Bo Bice. He is very, very, very talented. He is always in tune and has excellent range.

Are you talking about male contestants only or all contestants?

[Partial]

The kid is by far the best singer. He might be the best singer they have ever had on their.

He's not even top 5.

Are you kidding me? Who is better? I have seen a lot of people and the only one I think that was close was Constantine or Bo Bice. He is very, very, very talented. He is always in tune and has excellent range.

Are you talking about male contestants only or all contestants?

All. Kelly Clarkson has a good voice but she is not nearly as in tune. Carrie Underwood is much of the same. He won't be the most successful and I think the best Idol was Chris Daughtry but this kid is the best I've ever seen in pure singing ability on the show.

[RashanGary]

I thought this was the best performance of the year.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=GIvtcR6oeE0

[Scott Campbell]

Who do you like?


I think David Cook is the best of this bunch. Carly Smithson is good too, but David Cook seems like a star.

Someone needs to kick you in the vagina.


Harlan watches the View, and now this. It make me sick. So sick that I'm off to watch a crappy feel good movie on the Lifetime Channel.


http://ladycomp-babycomp.com/product_images/large/042105-143245_vagisil_itch.jpg

[RashanGary]

Acctually, it's not as good now as it seemed a couple weeks ago. Maybe he did better on the Billy Jean song.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=h_aiawC-9aM

[Partial]

I thought this was the best performance of the year.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=GIvtcR6oeE0

Chris Daughtry was a WAY better singer. This guy is so gimmicky. I like the guy with the dreads and the weird face better. He is far more naturally charming, has the big smile that girls like, and isn't a jerk or a Daughtry wannabe. The whole instrument thing is really dumb and deters from the competition.

[RashanGary]

I thought he did good on this Hallelujeh song.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=rmyL9Op1yXU

[RashanGary]

This girl is good too.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=fI6asc1EpE8

Gotta fast forward to 2:00

[Partial]

I kind of liked the Beatles song. But watch those videos of David Archuletta. He is an awesome, awesome singer. If he had any sort of personality he'd have it on lock down

[RashanGary]

I kind of liked the Beatles song. But watch those videos of David Archuletta. He is an awesome, awesome singer. If he had any sort of personality he'd have it on lock down

My mom likes him. For some reason, I just don't get into his type of music.

[Partial]

I kind of liked the Beatles song. But watch those videos of David Archuletta. He is an awesome, awesome singer. If he had any sort of personality he'd have it on lock down

My mom likes him. For some reason, I just don't get into his type of music.

Nor do I, but he is an amazing singer.

[BallHawk]

I thought this was the best performance of the year.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=GIvtcR6oeE0

Chris Daughtry was a WAY better singer. This guy is so gimmicky. I like the guy with the dreads and the weird face better. He is far more naturally charming, has the big smile that girls like, and isn't a jerk or a Daughtry wannabe. The whole instrument thing is really dumb and deters from the competition.

I never really thought Daughtry was that good of a singer. Eliot Yamin was a pretty good singer, IMO.

[Partial]

I thought this was the best performance of the year.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=GIvtcR6oeE0

Chris Daughtry was a WAY better singer. This guy is so gimmicky. I like the guy with the dreads and the weird face better. He is far more naturally charming, has the big smile that girls like, and isn't a jerk or a Daughtry wannabe. The whole instrument thing is really dumb and deters from the competition.

I never really thought Daughtry was that good of a singer. Eliot Yamin was a pretty good singer, IMO.

Ok now you're talking crazy. Elliot was a good singer but I think there are many people that are still convinced Daughtry would have won and something was fixed. My girlfriend called upwards of like 20 times and she said the line was always busy. Plus, if you followed the show closely you know he was clearly the front runner and it was a true shocker when he was
"voted" off. Dude has talent and charisma. His version of dead or alive is one of the best musical performances I've ever witnessed.

Anna is warming up to this Dave Cook. I don't like him.

[BallHawk]

They have at least one rocker on the show each year. I grow weary of them by the first few weeks. They all sound similar. Daughtry was a fantastic performer. He was a good singer. There's a difference.

[SkinBasket]

His version of dead or alive is one of the best musical performances I've ever witnessed.

Calling an Idol performance one of the best musical performances you've ever witnessed is kinda like going to Taco Bell and saying that soft shelled taco was the best authentic Mexican dish you've ever had. Or those French Fries at McDonalds might have been one of the best Franche-Comté dinners you've had the pleasure of tasting. And don't get me started on the classico Italian dishes at the Olive Garden. Soup salad and bread sticks with a tall coke. You don't get more true Tuscan than that.

[Partial]

They have at least one rocker on the show each year. I grow weary of them by the first few weeks. They all sound similar. Daughtry was a fantastic performer. He was a good singer. There's a difference.

OK. I disagree. I think he was one of the best they've had yet. I also think this kid is the best pure singer they've had yet by a landslide. He needs to pick better songs and get some charisma but he has a male aguilera voice.

[BallHawk]

He does need to pick better songs, or rather, pick better songs himself. Since he's so young I think he's easily swayed by the coaches, contestants, etc. The kid can definitely sing, he just needs to get it together.

[Partial]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJQSx-V8s8o

Constantine busting out My Funny Valentine. One of the best performances that I can remember on American Idol. He was a great singer.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5D8ixbEShBA
Awesome performance by Bo Bice. His voice reminds me of a much better Chris Cornell.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uk773QwyA4Q
Another good bo one

Bomb ass performance from Carrie Underwood
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMBSDpB3WB8


We always need Pat Benetar.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gXt8iVXbLQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJXwm150umQ&feature=related
Chris Daughtry's rendition of Walk the Line. I guarantee a million chicks immediately removed their panties and threw themselves at him. Hell, I think he looks hot in the cash attire.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ciXyuNae5No
bad ass

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oYneab5LJX8
He sounds better than the mastered version of the song.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yj5rnCcleJ8
Bon Jovi

Mancrush :oops:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6dHLl-5kEQ&feature=related
omg listen to this guy.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ebA2GLxBeKU
Listen to how in tune he is. It's really impressive. Never flat on his high notes. It's really impressive.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MUZ79aLar0Y


The kid is really good but he needs to stop having his Mom pick his songs. His selection is downright awful, but imo he has the best voice Idols ever had.

[BallHawk]

I admit, I was impressed when David sung the Long and Winding Road. Actually sounded like McCartney did it.

[RashanGary]

Bo Bice was awsome. I think David Cook is up there too.

Your man crush on Daugerty is strange. He's not that good.

[MJZiggy]

Daughtry has a good voice, strong clear and on key (as far as I can tell), but I was never tempted to toss my panties anywhere...

[RashanGary]

Constantine and Dougerty sucked. They were completely average guys who appealed to women.


Cook is really good. Bice was a good rocker too. That beautifull clean Clay Aiken, David Archuletta stuff just doesn't do it for me. It's impressive to listen to because it's so clean and pure but it's really boring and not something I would ever listen to just for enjoyment.

[Deputy Nutz]

Without a doubt I think there are some really talented folks that have come through the "IDOL" door.

But they are doing covers of others who have performed these songs, in a way all they have to do is perform a copy to sound good.

[Partial]

Constantine and Dougerty sucked. They were completely average guys who appealed to women.


Cook is really good. Bice was a good rocker too. That beautifull clean Clay Aiken, David Archuletta stuff just doesn't do it for me. It's impressive to listen to because it's so clean and pure but it's really boring and not something I would ever listen to just for enjoyment.

You don't know anything about music. Constantine was a broadway performer with excellent pitch and Daughtry has been offered tons of lead singer spots in famous bands including Fuel.

[BallHawk]

Constantine and Dougerty sucked. They were completely average guys who appealed to women.


Cook is really good. Bice was a good rocker too. That beautifull clean Clay Aiken, David Archuletta stuff just doesn't do it for me. It's impressive to listen to because it's so clean and pure but it's really boring and not something I would ever listen to just for enjoyment.

You don't know anything about music.

And what makes Partial such a music expert? :roll:

[Partial]

Constantine and Dougerty sucked. They were completely average guys who appealed to women.


Cook is really good. Bice was a good rocker too. That beautifull clean Clay Aiken, David Archuletta stuff just doesn't do it for me. It's impressive to listen to because it's so clean and pure but it's really boring and not something I would ever listen to just for enjoyment.

You don't know anything about music.

And what makes Partial such a music expert? :roll:

Nothing, but to say they sucked is moronic. They were two of the best to ever be on the show. The two biggest things that I notice on American Idol is how flat people are on pitches, and the song selection. Those two people were great at both.

Daughtry, Clarkson and Underwood have had the most success out of those people this far. My guess is when all is said and done Daughtry will have the most.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Admission: I didn't read the entire thread.

My wife made me watch Idol at first, but let's be real, there have been some people that can really friggin' sing on this show. Better than a lot of the talent people pay money to watch in concert.

However, this year blows for me. I can't really get behind anybody. They are a bunch of Justin Guarinis to me. There are a couple that I think are alright, but nobody that I think will be a star.

Daughtry can sing. Carrie Underwood can sing. Even Kelly Clarkson can sing. No standouts this year.

[Harlan Huckleby]

Admission: I didn't read the entire thread.

Then STFU. This is a serious discussion, come back when you've done your homework.

[RashanGary]

Archuletta had a nice week. The rest sucked.


They can just get rid of everyone and give it to David Cook. The only other guy who has a chance is Archuletta but his music is just boring and old fashioned. I don't enjoy it at all. I guess the tatoo girl has a chance, but ever since her breakout performance a couple weeks ago she's been disappointing too.

Kristy Lee Cook can leave rigth now. Watching her dance makes me cringe. She's just awkward and uncomfortable. Her singing is just average too. The black girl sang Whitney Houston on Dolly Pardon day and butchered it. Trying to make a statement that you don't like country music? See ya. They can just cut her ass now and nobody would care. The tatoo girl has been forgettable for 2 or 3 weeks now. Archuletta and Cook are the only two that are decent and Cook stands out as the only one that can make current, marketable music.

Game over. End it now.

P.S. Anyone who likes Dougherty and Constantine is more interested in man meat than music. Buy a miniskirt and gutter-slut sparkley thong and go on tour as a groupie polishing each band members respective knobs after each show. Fuck, Partial; what is wrong with you?

[Partial]

I appreciate talent, not tools.

You're way too cocky dude. I bet the kid ends up winning.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Daughtry has talent. There are a handful of idol contestants who have had real talent, and he's one of the them. I wouldn't count Harrell's secret man crush, Constantine, as one of them.

[Deputy Nutz]

I appreciate talent, not tools.

You're way too cocky dude. I bet the kid ends up winning.

Are we now talking shit about who is going to win American Idol?

[MJZiggy]

The part that frightens me just a little is that the two of them are fighting about the MALE contestants.

Count me in the Daughtry yes, Constantine no category. And that's based purely on their singing, I'm not particularly attracted to either of them.

[the_idle_threat]

Constantine and Dougerty sucked. They were completely average guys who appealed to women.


Cook is really good. Bice was a good rocker too. That beautifull clean Clay Aiken, David Archuletta stuff just doesn't do it for me. It's impressive to listen to because it's so clean and pure but it's really boring and not something I would ever listen to just for enjoyment.

You don't know anything about music. Constantine was a broadway performer with excellent pitch and Daughtry has been offered tons of lead singer spots in famous bands including Fuel.

To be fair, Fuel offers the lead singing gig to practically anyone who will listen.