With him or against him

[Freak Out]

I went through 16 pages of crap and did not find a poll that asked the question...sorry if I missed one.

Trade him, release him, whatever...you either want him starting for the Packers or you don't.

[Gunakor]

It depends on if MM and Favre can get along. If they cannot put what has transpired over the last month behind them, then no I don't want him here. If they can put this behind them and work together efficiently, then I want him to stay.

One more thing though, if Favre stays then I'd like a guarantee from him that he will never ever ever ever pull this shit again. Ever. If you say you are done, then stay retired. No more waffling. Guaranteed. That is an absolute must if I were to want him here.

I am refraining from voting on this until I have more answers.

[Freak Out]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.

[Freak Out]

55 views and 12 votes. Wafflers all of you.

[falco]

its funny, i think this same poll a week or two ago would have been the opposite

now that he's here, suited up and fighting for the job, things have really swung in his favor

[Gunakor]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

[retailguy]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

b/c you don't have a $100m contract. so jump off the fence, will ya!

[falco]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

because freak out is forcing you to make a decision prior to free agency

[GrnBay007]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

Even if you make the wrong decision and change your mind, we will still let you post here because you're pretty good. :P

[Gunakor]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

because freak out is forcing you to make a decision prior to free agency

Well, the best I can guarantee at this point is I'll have made a decision before the trade deadline.

[falco]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

Even if you make the wrong decision and change your mind, we will still let you post here because you're pretty good. :P

agreed - gunakor is one of the best new posters here

[Freak Out]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

Pull a Gunakor.

[Gunakor]

BS....vote. You either want him now or you don't.


Why do I have to pull a Brett Favre and make a decision that I'm not completely committed to?

Even if you make the wrong decision and change your mind, we will still let you post here because you're pretty good. :P

agreed - gunakor is one of the best new posters here


Thanks guys!

[Bretsky]

Several forum Geniuses have the same B'day as him as well :lol:

[Gunakor]

No answers until tommorrow. Don't close the polls. When I get my answers, I'll vote.

[Bretsky]

No answers until tommorrow. Don't close the polls. When I get my answers, I'll vote.



commit already you waffler :lol: :lol:

[bobblehead]

I'm against him...until they say he is absolutely part of the team this year, at which time I will pull a favre and be totally behind him.

[Gunakor]

I'm against him...until they say he is absolutely part of the team this year, at which time I will pull a favre and be totally behind him.

If you pulled a Favre you wouldn't totally be behind anybody. Not willingly anyway.

[Lurker64]

I definitely think that this other poll (http://www.packerrats.com/ratchat/viewtopic.php?t=13770) supports more shades of gray than this one.

There's definitely more opinions to be had here between "kick his ass to the curb" and "install him immediately as the starter."

[Freak Out]

No answers until tommorrow. Don't close the polls. When I get my answers, I'll vote.

If he wants to play football do you want him starting for the Packers or not? Easy question.

[Freak Out]

I definitely think that this other poll (http://www.packerrats.com/ratchat/viewtopic.php?t=13770) supports more shades of gray than this one.

There's definitely more opinions to be had here between "kick his ass to the curb" and "install him immediately as the starter."

There are only two options here Lurker....you want the guy playing QB for you or not. Pure and simple.

[Lurker64]

There are more choices than "want him starting" and "want him off the team". For example, you might want him on the team and not starting.

[Gunakor]

I definitely think that this other poll (http://www.packerrats.com/ratchat/viewtopic.php?t=13770) supports more shades of gray than this one.

There's definitely more opinions to be had here between "kick his ass to the curb" and "install him immediately as the starter."

There are only two options here Lurker....you want the guy playing QB for you or not. Pure and simple.

It's not that simple, because it's about more than football now. Even if he's great on the field, I don't want him being a pain in the ass off of it. And I certainly don't want him playing in Green Bay this year if he's going to create all this bullshit again next summer. That all has to be taken into consideration.

[Freak Out]

I definitely think that this other poll (http://www.packerrats.com/ratchat/viewtopic.php?t=13770) supports more shades of gray than this one.

There's definitely more opinions to be had here between "kick his ass to the curb" and "install him immediately as the starter."

There are only two options here Lurker....you want the guy playing QB for you or not. Pure and simple.

It's not that simple, because it's about more than football now. Even if he's great on the field, I don't want him being a pain in the ass off of it. And I certainly don't want him playing in Green Bay this year if he's going to create all this bullshit again next summer. That all has to be taken into consideration.

This is about YOU right NOW....Favre could fall down the stairs and break his freaking neck on Tuesday for all we know. Do YOU ever want him starting for the Packers again? If your emotions say no because he was an asshole then vote no.

[Gunakor]

I definitely think that this other poll (http://www.packerrats.com/ratchat/viewtopic.php?t=13770) supports more shades of gray than this one.

There's definitely more opinions to be had here between "kick his ass to the curb" and "install him immediately as the starter."

There are only two options here Lurker....you want the guy playing QB for you or not. Pure and simple.

It's not that simple, because it's about more than football now. Even if he's great on the field, I don't want him being a pain in the ass off of it. And I certainly don't want him playing in Green Bay this year if he's going to create all this bullshit again next summer. That all has to be taken into consideration.

This is about YOU right NOW....Favre could fall down the stairs and break his freaking neck on Tuesday for all we know. Do YOU ever want him starting for the Packers again? If your emotions say no because he was an asshole then vote no.

Do I ever want him starting for the Packers again? Yes, IF he is committed to playing here for MM and TT, and IF he guarantees that the offseason bullshit won't happen ever again. I don't know yet if he is committed to playing for a coach and a GM he's thrown under the bus in the last month, and I don't know if he's going to act like a spoiled brat after the season is over. SO I DON'T KNOW IF I WANT HIM HERE ANYMORE. But IF all parties can put this behind them and work together efficiently, and IF Favre guarantees that he'll stay quiet and out of the media after the season is over, then ABSOLUTELY I'd welcome him back. That's alot of IF'S so I'm not voting yet. Clear?

[Gunakor]

Don't go trying to equate my indecisiveness to that of Favre either. Favre made his decision and then changed his mind. I have not made a decision yet, so I don't have to worry about changing my mind.

[Freak Out]

Don't go trying to equate my indecisiveness to that of Favre either. Favre made his decision and then changed his mind. I have not made a decision yet, so I don't have to worry about changing my mind.

Ha ha....I think you answered yes.

[Gunakor]

Don't go trying to equate my indecisiveness to that of Favre either. Favre made his decision and then changed his mind. I have not made a decision yet, so I don't have to worry about changing my mind.

Ha ha....I think you answered yes.


What I said, if you were paying attention, was yes, IF.

[Fritz]

I don't want Brett Favre starting for the Green Bay Packers, period. I think if he is here and he's starting ahead of a healthy Rodgers then MM has been completely undermined and it's the beginning of the end.

No equivocation from me. Favre = poison.

[Bretsky]

I've been consistently fine with a trade to whoever as well as Favre as a starter. Just hope it comes to an end soon.

[gex]

Favre starting....Hell yes, open competition.......yes, if its fair, Favre wins hands down. :D

[The Gunshooter]

Build a statue of him kissing Rodger's ass and then cut him. What was the question?

[HarveyWallbangers]

Favre starting....Hell yes, open competition.......yes, if its fair, Favre wins hands down. :D

Thank you, Bus Cook.

[gex]

Favre starting....Hell yes, open competition.......yes, if its fair, Favre wins hands down. :D

Thank you, Bus Cook.
:D