TOP PLAYMAKER IN NFL ?????????????

[Bretsky]

Your Choice :
Honorary Mention :

Honorary Mention on Defense:


Discuss

[sheepshead]

Rex Grossman, hands down

[Bretsky]

1. Top Playmaker: Gotta Go All Day Peterson as my top playmaker right now. Real Deal and if he stays healthy he'll often be a NFC North Nightmare

2. Honorary Mention: I think I might say Payton Manning; I'm somewhat of an outside the box thinker who often goes against the flow. It's enjoying to watch him go toward the line of scrimmage and proceed to pick apart an entire opposing defense and drive their coaches crazy.

3. Defense-- Gotta go Ed Reed, and the GB inside reporters noted Shermy pondered him over Javon Walker.........would've been a sweet choice if he went the other way

[sheepshead]

Ok Ill play:

Tom Brady
Larry Fitzgerald

[HarveyWallbangers]

OFF Peterson, Fitzgerald

Others considered: Steve Smith, Andre Johnson, DeAngelo Williams, Calvin Johnson, Greg Jennings

DEF James Harrison

Others considered: Reed, Troy Polamalu, Charles Woodson

Nick Collins was actually a playmaker last year. Hopefully, he can prove it wasn't a fluke this year.

[Scott Campbell]

I'm going with Fitzgerald on O. And that Ahmulgavadashawicz from Oakland on D.

[Partial]

Peyton Manning
Adrian Peterson

Defense: Julius Jalapenos

[Fritz]

I'd take Adrian Peterson.

Peyton Manning is good, too.

[gbpackfan]

Offense: Jarrett Bush (for opposing O's-always good for a clutch pass int. penalty.)

Defense - Brett Favre - can produce turnovers like no one else.

Did I do this wrong? :P

[TennesseePackerBacker]

Right now: Ben Rothlesberger(sp?)
The past decade and honorable mention: Peyton Manning

Defense: Patrick Willis


The real playmakers are the offensive linemen. Without them there would be no 4000 yd passers or 2000 yd rushers. (Except maybe Barry Sanders).

[pbmax]

Your Choice : Logan Mankins

Honorary Mention : Marco Rivera

Honorary Mention on Defense: Vince Young (no one inspires Great 4th Quarter Defense like this backup)

[pbmax]

Seriously:

Top Playmaker: Larry Fitzgerald

Honorable Mention: tie Roethlisberger/A Peterson

Defense: Albert Haynesworth (based on last year alone and I wouldn't predict it again this year, but he was a BEAST)

[SMACKTALKIE]

Top Playmaker: Adrian Peterson

Honorable Mention: Chris Johnson

Defense: Ed Reed

[channtheman]

Top playmaker: Vince Young

[hoosier]

I'm going with Fitzgerald on O. And that Ahmulgavadashawicz from Oakland on D.

Asomugah is a great CB but the Raiders opponents NEVER throw his way. If he's so good that he basically eliminates half the field, is he really still a playmaker? :lol:

[sheepshead]

In history:

Walter Payton
Brett Favre


Hon Men: Deon Sanders

[RashanGary]

Brett Favre

L. Tomlinson

Ray Lewis


All HOFers. Best players right now.

[MadScientist]

Where are all the homers?

Best player: Aaron Rodgers
Honorable Mention : Greg Jennings
Defense: Charles Woodson

[KYPack]

Couple guys who deserve some mention.

Drew Brees had a special year that nobody noticed. He sure stomped a mud-hole in us last season.

Pat Willis is the top defensive player in the league (with Asomugah)

[Scott Campbell]

I'm going with Fitzgerald on O. And that Ahmulgavadashawicz from Oakland on D.

Asomugah is a great CB but the Raiders opponents NEVER throw his way. If he's so good that he basically eliminates half the field, is he really still a playmaker? :lol:



Yeah, I think a guy who takes away one side of the field on every single passing down is a play maker. But not in the ESPN highlight reel sense. Great CB's are exceptionally valuable.

[Cleft Crusty]

Your Choice : Brian Westbrook

Honorary Mention : Larry Fitzgerald

Honorary Mention on Defense: James Harrison


Discus: Robert Garrett - He won discus in 1896 at the first modern Olympics when he had no business doing so - the Greeks were far more skilled in the art.

[SnakeLH2006]

Jay Cutler. :shock:

[woodbuck27]

On 'O'

Drew Brees

RB 28 Peterson, Adrian ACT CAR 363 YDS 1,760 AVG 4.8 TDS 10 MIN

WR 11 Fitzgerald, Larry ACT REC 96 YDS 1,431 AVG 14.9 TDS 12 ARI

WR 85 Jennings, Greg ACT REC 80 YDS 1,292 AVG 16.2 TDS 9 GB

QB 18 Manning, Peyton ACT TDS 27 INT 12 YDS 4,002 RTG 95.0 IND

QB 9 Brees, Drew ACT TDS 34 INT 17 YDS 5,069 RTG 96.2 NO

On 'D'

James Harrison

CB 21 Asomugha, Nnamdi ACT TCKL 40 SCK 0.0 FF 1 INT 1 OAK

OLB 52 Willis, Patrick ACT TCKL 141 SCK 1.0 FF 1 INT 1 SF

FS 20 Reed, Ed ACT TCKL 41 SCK 1.0 FF 1 INT 9 BAL

OLB 92 Harrison, James ACT TCKL 101 SCK 16.0 FF 7 INT 1 PIT

DT 92 Haynesworth, Albert ACT TCKL 51 SCK 8.5 FF 3 INT -- WAS