PDA

View Full Version : Players of interest breakdown thread



bobblehead
05-23-2023, 04:47 PM
So I won't bother with Jordan Love or Jaire Alexander here, but some guys are entering crossroad seasons, and some rookies will have a learning curve that is worthy of discussion.

I'm going to start with Darnell Savage who I saw as a bust candidate last year and he didn't (or did) disappoint.

GB is making a mistake with Savage similar to the mistake they made with Hyde. Savage has a skill set that should work as a slot CB. He isn't a good safety. He needs to be utilized in a way where his quickness is an asset, and his lack of discipline/instincts aren't as much of a liability.

This leads me directly to Rasul Douglas who is instinctive and should be moved to safety. He is a fine boundary CB, but he would be a better safety. He is a good tackler and has a nose for the ball. GB should be swapping these 2 guys right now instead of week 7 which is when I am predicting as the week both will be switched. One might be moved before then, but I'm guessing that by week 8 both will be playing the proper positions.

I'll let everyone explain that I'm wrong before moving on to another player.

run pMc
05-23-2023, 05:01 PM
I don't hate Rasul at safety. I do hate him in the slot like they had him last year to start the season.
Agree Savage is more of a slot guy or better closer to the LOS, the trouble is he's on the smaller side for a safety and his tackling was bad last year. He was a much better fit for what Pettine ran, he's a bit of a mismatch with Barry's split safety zone coverages.

So... I don't really disagree with your take.

Player of interest I'll start with is Josh Myers. He has to show improvement this year or he's on the bench. Supposedly he can play G but IDK if I've seen it in a preseason game or heard him play there in practice. If he's not the C I don't see how he's in their starting 5. A R2 pick for a backup center would be a poor return on investment, and picking him before Humphrey makes it look worse.

Sticking with OL, my 2nd player of interest -- simply because of draft status and last year -- is Sean Rhyan. I barely saw this dude play, what can he do? Is he any good? Did a year in an NFL program get him to be stronger, smarter, and learn to be a pro? He's got physical talent but I wonder if he's got something between the ears... or if the switch from T to G was too much for him. If he turns into a player he pushes Jake Hanson or Royce Newman farther down the bench and breaks that R3 curse. He could also flame out and be a wasted pick if he comes back unable to play to his draft status (and get the "Amari treatment").

I have several others I'll be curious about, mostly rookies and year 2 players. Myers and Rhyan were the first to come to mind.

texaspackerbacker
05-23-2023, 06:39 PM
Good Idea for a thread.

I too think Douglas would be excellent at Safety. The way I look at it, though, either it is prime in the staff's mind already, or else they know something that isn't obvious to us in here about why that wouldn't work. The guy has seemed to be open to whatever helps the team the most. I WISH they'd scrap Barry's primarily zone pass coverage, although I guess that's not likely.

I'm a big Myers fan. He might have been down a little last season, but he still was/is damn good, and he is the kind of Center I prefer - big and strong even if not as mobile as some smaller guys at the position. Tom was a pleasant surprise to me last season. I still see him more as a "6th man" than starter, though. Rhyan, on the other hand is the complete opposite. I had real high hopes for him, but he apparently showed nothing. I still have a little bit of hope that he will get better this season, but really not much. Hanson seemed like pure crap. Newman, though, wasn't all bad and still might be useful.

I used to like Savage, and I still think with better coaching he could be good. I like him better as a deep Safety, though. I remember one game in particular where he and Amos roamed around and were good in two deep. Douglas might be good that way too. In case anybody hasn't heard, I think Casey Hayward is still available as a FA.

Engabare is the "player of interest" I will contribute. I have hopes for a breakout season for him. Walker also, although that wouldn't be as big news considering his status as a fairly high first round pick.

red
05-23-2023, 07:04 PM
aaron jones might just put up massive numbers this year (even by his standards), with a QB who doesn't audible into a pass on 75% of running downs

does that count or is that kind of a no brainer?

stokes has to show something. he flashed his rookie year, then looked blah last year. i'd say he hasn't lived up to his draft status yet

safety could be a huge problem. maybe ford can hold down the fort, but i have no confidence in savage or anyone else we currently have. i also like the idea of trying douglas back there

Joemailman
05-23-2023, 09:18 PM
I'm kind of interested to see what Sean Rhyan can do. He's a Packers 3rd round pick and I like pulling for the underdog. Really though, he played at a high level against good college competition, and he's an athletic guy. I'm thinking he can't be as useless as he looked last year. He was taking some snaps today at backup Center. Anything would be better than Jake Hanson.

Fritz
05-24-2023, 09:16 AM
What disappointed me - and maybe it was just a seniority thing - was that since Bakh and Jenkins were out, the team trotted out the amazing Royce Newman at left guard with the "first team." Again, it may be just a nod to seniority, but my mom could probably beat out Royce Newman, so I'm curious to see how this camp plays out for Sean "I didn't play at all last year but got suspended anyway" Rhyan.

I'm also curious as to whether Quay Walker, who did not participate, will be more disciplined and improved this year. He definitely flashed last year but was a little out-of-control.

bobblehead
05-24-2023, 10:11 AM
I'm going to move from D backfield thru O backfield, so next up for me is Rudy Ford. I think By midseason Rudy will be starting at safety opposite Douglas. He is the most willing tackler of the entire defensive backfield, runs a 4.4 and seems to have the most desire. Guys like that find a way to succeed. He was hit and miss on defense last year, but flashed potential and for a guy who went undrafted he didn't look overwhelmed. We have a lot of pedestrian safeties accumulated, but I think Ford has a little Nick Collins in him. A guy who has flashed the potential but failed to put it all together. I like my safeties to be built like a slight RB and Ford fits the mold. Owens would be the wildcard in all this. He has also gone from UDFA to starter in his short career, but he is more like a stopgap guy. Like if no one else emerges at all he may be serviceable. I rewatched a few texans games from last year (its painful) and he never stands out. Then again I didn't see him trailing in coverage as if he was late to his assignment either. You can field a good defense with him, but he would have to be the weakest link.

Ford is my bet to be the best safety on the team by seasons end and a guy we all are happy to have.

Joemailman
05-25-2023, 01:54 PM
Eric Stokes is a guy worth watching to see if the looks like the 2021 rookie or the 2022 disappointment. Don't know when we'll see him as he just recently started running again after suffering a torn meniscus and lisfranc injury on the same play last year. His head seems to be in a good place though.


Then his second season began and, instead of building on the success of his rookie year, Stokes regressed. He was riding the high of a good introduction to the NFL, overconfident by his own admission, and it showed on the field. Stokes allowed four catches of at least 20 yards and two touchdowns in nine games, often appearing lost as he wandered the secondary. He missed seven tackles in 33 chances, the worst tackle rate in the Packers secondary.

“I absolutely hate looking at that film,” Stokes said. “But it’s just something I’ve got to do. I’ve just got to learn from it. It’s pretty much just the smallest details that you miss, it’s the small, little stuff that you take for granted, small, little stuff like simple, little things. Like getting ready. Just getting lined up and being ready.

“One thing that (former defensive backs coach Jerry Gray) taught me before he left was just having your gun ready, especially as a corner. You’ve always got to be ready because the ball can easily find you, no matter what, no matter when, whatever. The ball easily finds you.”

The ball kept finding Stokes last season over and over again. When a cornerback struggles, there is nowhere to hide. Not when New York Jets receiver Corey Davis beat him for 41 yards down the right sideline. Not when Stokes covered the wrong receiver in Washington, allowing a wide-open touchdown to Antonio Gibson. Not when his holding penalty nullified a Rasul Douglas scoop-and-score fumble recovery later in the same game.

It was one calamity after another.

“Just trying to be Superman,” Stokes said. “Just trying to do everything and all that stuff, when that’s not required. The only thing that’s required from me is guard the man in front of me. Bump everything else. The thing in front of me is the only thing I need to worry about. Not the bigger picture, not anything. Just stopping the man in front of me.”

smuggler
05-25-2023, 02:03 PM
His injuries were pretty bad. If we even get a capable player after those injuries, we should count it as a big win. 2021 Stokes no longer exists.

bobblehead
05-25-2023, 03:07 PM
His injuries were pretty bad. If we even get a capable player after those injuries, we should count it as a big win. 2021 Stokes no longer exists.

You are right, but I think you are overstating it. 2021 Stokes won't exist this year. He won't be fully recovered this season for sure. However, how well he recovers by next season only time will tell.

bobblehead
05-26-2023, 12:55 PM
Moving up into the front 7 and there is all kinds of reasons to be optimistic and pessimistic.

Quay Walker is my #1 guy to watch for obvious reasons. Honestly I think they are going to use him to get after the QB this year. I just get the feel they are looking at Micah Parsons as the blueprint for career arc. Walker has all kinds of talent. He got comfortable last year for the last 5 weeks or so. As far as the stupid temper things, guys tend to learn. Suh almost ended up bagging groceries, but he got his head right eventually. Walker literally has the skill to cover, tackle, sack. There aren't that many guys in the NFL like that. I hope it clicks for him because the sky is the limit. Of course if he is truly too stupid to learn how to handle himself or pick up responsibilities then he could be a monster disappointment.

I don't think anyone will shock us at the OLB position. Enagbare proved he belongs last year and I don't expect that to change. I think Hollins is a nice 3rd down specialist option. Gary just needs to recover. Predicting the final roster seems easy at OLB. Van Ness, Gary, Preston, Enagbare, Hollins. I don't really see it playing out any other way.

Bretsky
05-27-2023, 08:58 PM
Our last 3 1st round picks

Van Ness
Walker and Wyatt
Stokes

red
05-28-2023, 12:01 PM
i'll bring up josh myers again

a recent article i read brought him back to my attention

there was a clear can't miss, once in a decade center in the 2021 draft. we passed on him to take myers who most thought was a distant second best c in the draft. creed humphrey was draft one spot later

myer is rated as below average for centers in the league. humphrey is the best in the nfl

a classic example of gutey getting too cute and fucking up a pick

bobblehead
05-30-2023, 10:23 AM
So DL has no one I'm really keying in on. Like everyone I want Wyatt to show his late season surge is real, but I almost expect that to happen. The rookies are developmental and won't be on the field a ton this year. They are both tweener guys who played a decent amount of edge in college I think. Part of the deep edge class, but are too bulky to play it in the pros. I guess Ford is the guy I will sort of watch to see if he makes a 2nd year jump.

Joemailman
05-30-2023, 10:26 AM
Wyatt is certainly a guy I'll be watching. Packers run defense did improve last 3 games quite a bit with Wyatt replacing Lowry. Went from about 148 rushing yards per game to 96. Wyatt is about the same size as Jarran Reed and 20 pounds heavier than Lowry. He should be stout enough while providing more disruptiveness. The development of him and Walker will be huge key for this defense.

run pMc
05-30-2023, 01:15 PM
If Wyatt can hold up better against double teams, stay on his feet and in his gap it will be a positive. He struggled with that last year.
Not sure what two Day 3 rookie DL will get you, but I think they improved the DL pass rushing. I think there's a real possibility they have gotten worse at run defense -- unless TJ Slaton and Wyatt show improvement and consistency.

The defense gave up 5.0 ypc last year on average. You allow that and it doesn't matter who you have playing at corner or rushing the passer, it's just the other team running the ball down the field.

One caveat to this is the ILB and safeties - if they play their run fits better and improve their tackling that will help the run defense. DL has to hold up better at the POA though. Wyatt will play an important role and hopefully makes a jump. There have not been many Packer Year 2 jumps lately.

Fritz
05-30-2023, 05:13 PM
So DL has no one I'm really keying in on. Like everyone I want Wyatt to show his late season surge is real, but I almost expect that to happen. The rookies are developmental and won't be on the field a ton this year. They are both tweener guys who played a decent amount of edge in college I think. Part of the deep edge class, but are too bulky to play it in the pros. I guess Ford is the guy I will sort of watch to see if he makes a 2nd year jump.

Given that Ford wasn't even activated last year, I don't think, for him a second year jump will be just being on the game day roster.

bobblehead
06-01-2023, 03:06 PM
Given that Ford wasn't even activated last year, I don't think, for him a second year jump will be just being on the game day roster.

Like I said. Not a real exciting position group. Clark has to earn his money. Wyatt merely has to play as he did late in the season. I can't say any other players make me expect a lot. They all need to be serviceable in rotation while wyatt and Clark need to be good.....and that is all I expect or hope of them.

Fritz
06-03-2023, 10:08 AM
Like I said. Not a real exciting position group. Clark has to earn his money. Wyatt merely has to play as he did late in the season. I can't say any other players make me expect a lot. They all need to be serviceable in rotation while wyatt and Clark need to be good.....and that is all I expect or hope of them.

That's true. I had hopes for TJ Slaton (or is it "Slayton," or is that Chris?), but I noticed, when I focused on him during games, he seemed to get pushed around a lot. He makes splash plays but is not consistent, especially in what should be his calling card - stopping the run.

Wyatt really needs to play well for this defense to live up to any kind of the expectations you'd have for a defense that has a zillion first-round picks on it.

bobblehead
06-05-2023, 01:33 PM
Where to start with the offense. I'll start at the OL. I don't have any one guy I'm watching too intently as this is a great and talented group. What I will watch most is Yosh Nijman probably. He is sort of the key to a lot of things that could happen. If he takes that final step (and I hear LVN ate his lunch several times in shorts) a lot of options open up. The biggest one would be trading Bak since he is effectively in a contract year (40M hit next year). If Yosh looks good enough to be a starting T long term we have options. A healthy Jenkins can play LT. Yosh can play LT. A stronger Tom can play LT. The rest can fill in multiple ways.

There is constant chatter around trading Bak and I think its the right move long term, but if you can't trust Yosh to be more than he has been (adequate) then you can't trade Bak. Yosh has improved every year. The only thing missing now is a nasty streak. Steel sharpens steel. I would put him heads up with LVN every day over and over. Clifton vs. Kampman was an epic camp battle that made both players better. If Yosh can take that last step to being very good then Bak for a 2nd is viable.

I know people dump on Meyers and clearly Humphries has been better, but a healthy Meyers is decent at center. He reach blocks very well for a big man. He can man the C until we can do better. I could see a world where Tom plays center, but its certainly not the best scenario.

Joemailman
06-05-2023, 04:05 PM
Myers needs to step it up this year. He was hurt as a rookie, but started all 17 games last year. He was just too inconsistent. Jenkins and Tom are both capable of playing Center at a higher level than Myers did last year. And Sean Rhyan has just as much athleticism if not more.

Fritz
06-08-2023, 07:57 AM
Myers definitely playing for his job. It's his third year. Time to put up or shut up.

texaspackerbacker
06-08-2023, 03:01 PM
I hope Myers has a better year than last year. I expect him to be better - at least as good as his rookie season. I've always been convinced he's a better player than Creed Humphrey. But I hardly think Myers is "playing for his job".

This Sean Rhyan thing - switching to Center, I see that as just a last gasp of a chance for him - it is about who will be the backup. Hanson proved to be total crap. Tom could be the backup and still may be if Rhyan bombs, but I think they see Tom as better at Guard or Tackle.

run pMc
06-08-2023, 05:39 PM
Myers needs to step it up this year. He was hurt as a rookie, but started all 17 games last year. He was just too inconsistent. Jenkins and Tom are both capable of playing Center at a higher level than Myers did last year. And Sean Rhyan has just as much athleticism if not more.

Yeah, Myers and Rhyan were the first guys that came to mind for me, although last year the team really underperformed compared to the year before, so you could throw almost everyone on a list of "players of interest". I'd say any of the picks from this year's draft going back to Stokes/Myers draft of 2021 could be candidates.

Agree Myers is playing for his job. I don't think he's going to get cut - he's not a bad player - but if someone else can play C better they should bench Myers. Clock is ticking on Rhyan - they are going to look for any reason this camp to keep him. Remember, TJ Lang took a while to come around. I think he's a G but if he can play C that helps him greatly. They do have a lot of OL under contract and competition should be pretty fierce. Will be interesting to see it play out.

bobblehead
06-09-2023, 01:29 AM
I won't be watching Rhyan because he is a flop. A wasted pick. If the guy can't even break the gameday roster as a 3rd round pick then I have no faith in him making any real contribution this year. At best he is now a long term project except I haven't seen the developable traits that yosh or Jones has.

Joemailman
06-09-2023, 09:15 AM
I won't be watching Rhyan because he is a flop. A wasted pick. If the guy can't even break the gameday roster as a 3rd round pick then I have no faith in him making any real contribution this year. At best he is now a long term project except I haven't seen the developable traits that yosh or Jones has.

Mike Wahle was pretty useless until they found the right position for him. So we'll see. I think we'll find out pretty soon whether he can play. This won't be a multi-year developmental project like Yosh.

bobblehead
06-09-2023, 11:34 AM
Mike Wahle was pretty useless until they found the right position for him. So we'll see. I think we'll find out pretty soon whether he can play. This won't be a multi-year developmental project like Yosh.

I agree, because as I have stated he doesn't possess the incredible feet that Yosh has and his size is already maxed out for his frame. I thought he could maybe play tackle given his huge lower frame, but in the limited action I have seen him he doesn't have anywhere near the footwork required, nor the natural agility. As a guard he may be serviceable with enough work, but as you said, they won't spend that much time on him. You spend that kind of time on guys who have the natural ability to reach high levels. He just hasn't displayed that anywhere on tape.

Fritz
06-14-2023, 09:56 AM
I keep wondering what they saw that they drafted this guy in the third round. Fifth round, maybe? Okay. A flier. But the third round?

Joemailman
06-14-2023, 10:40 AM
I keep wondering what they saw that they drafted this guy in the third round. Fifth round, maybe? Okay. A flier. But the third round?

He was drafted about where most people had him rated. Some actually had him rated as a 2nd round pick. He was actually kind of a classic Packer mid-round pick. A guy who played LT in college who most think will have to play inside in the NFL. He's been getting reps at Center with he 2's, but you can't start to grade OL guys until the pads go on. We'll find out pretty quickly I think whether he's a talented guy who had trouble as a rookie transitioning to the NFL, or whether drafting him was a colossal mistake.

Sparkey
06-14-2023, 02:07 PM
I won't be watching Rhyan because he is a flop. A wasted pick. If the guy can't even break the gameday roster as a 3rd round pick then I have no faith in him making any real contribution this year. At best he is now a long term project except I haven't seen the developable traits that yosh or Jones has.

I think that is somewhat harsh. He was 21 on draft day, two years younger than Tom was when he was drafted. I think the kid still has a future. Guys with his athletic ability at his size don't grown on trees. I think he discovered that athletic ability alone isn't enough in the NFL. Obviously, this year is a big year for him.

smuggler
06-14-2023, 07:30 PM
I'd be happy to be pleasantly surprised by him, but expecting more than a bench player from him given his performance last year is a mistake.

Anti-Polar Bear
06-14-2023, 11:22 PM
Ole Bobble, he dislikes Mellow Yellow (too sweat), Coldplay’s smash hit, “Yellow” (why would a person bleed herself dry for another person, asks Bobble) and yellow futbol players like Rhyan, Taylor Rapp and Younghoe Koo (too soft to be futbol players, reasons Bobble).

run pMc
06-15-2023, 08:31 AM
I'd be happy to be pleasantly surprised by him, but expecting more than a bench player from him given his performance last year is a mistake.

I'm not bullish on his chances, but you never know. He's not a bust just yet -- as mentioned he's young and a good athlete. Plenty of players have bad rookie seasons and turn out ok. TJ Lang took a while to figure it out. They don't need Rhyan to play meaningful snaps, which buys time to sort out whatever his issues are. Not much point in giving up on him so soon.

bobblehead
06-17-2023, 03:21 PM
Ole Bobble, he dislikes Mellow Yellow (too sweat), Coldplay’s smash hit, “Yellow” (why would a person bleed herself dry for another person, asks Bobble) and yellow futbol players like Rhyan, Taylor Rapp and Younghoe Koo (too soft to be futbol players, reasons Bobble).

But I like asian women so it balances out!

bobblehead
06-17-2023, 03:29 PM
So lets talk TE. In the Kraft thread I just pointed out we drafted a guy in the Kelce mold and a guy in the Kittles mold. Musgrave (kelce mold) will probably be more effective early as his NFL DNA has allowed him ample opportunity to be exposed to NFL concepts his whole life. He will still be more WR than multi faceted this year though.

This is going to be my favorite group to watch. Loved both picks and I'm interested to see if DeGuara puts it together in a more traditional LaFleur offense. I don't see big numbers, but impacting the game in many ways is an option. As a FB, as a blocker, as a guy who can misdirect the defense. If he can just make sure a good coverage LB is required to be on he field its a win. Or even better if a safety is needed to cover him. If he is just that good as a pass catcher it will help the run game a lot.

Musgrave I hope to be a matchup nightmare. Too fast for LB/S and too big for a corner. I don't expect big things from Kraft this year because, well TEs. But honestly in most drafts he's a mid to early 2nd round pick. The TE depth in this draft allowed us to grab 2 guys a round later than their talent would dictate. If we have a winning future I expect a lot of it will run through the TE room.

bobblehead
08-17-2023, 12:10 PM
I glanced back to see how my thoughts were playing out and realized I never covered WR/RB. RB is about as straightforward as can be with Dillon and Jones, but the WR group had some intrigue. I'll be honest, Reed has surprised me. I stated on draft day that he has a skill set that I don't feel translates well. It sounds like he has been lightning in short areas though. I still kind of think Torre plays a lot of slot before the season ends. But Reed seems to have done his job thus far. Watson is going to terrify defenses. Romeo has a lot of James Jones in him. He is such a dangerous route runner that when he shifts gears he gets behind the defense.

With Musgrave pulling safeties into the middle of the field I think regular shots downfield to Watson or Doubs will be a staple of this offense. We might run so much that we need to keep 3 active RBs on gameday just for the wear and tear. Ground and pound with dump passes, 10 yard crossers to WR and middle seam routes to musgrave. Then when the defense tightens up, boom, down the sideline. Our skill positions are set up for success.

run pMc
08-17-2023, 01:00 PM
Based on camp reports Musgrave has had plenty of rough moments but as a receiver has been a revelation. LBs and safeties are going to have trouble staying with him, and teams will have to decide how to cover him and Watson. It's going to leave swaths of the field open for savvy guys like Reed (and Doubs) to operate.

I liked Reed as a prospect, but didn't think he fit GB's thresholds so never seriously considered him as a pick. Pretty sure I posted as much in draft threads. He's basically what the team hoped Amari would have been. Reed's production in the slot at MSU was not great - he was better outside -- but it seems like he's adjusted to playing in the slot nicely in camp and that's where he's going to mostly be. He's going to be the new Cobb.

I think they'll play Toure everywhere - wherever they need him to be, although I suspect he might be better in the slot. Wicks is the presumptive WR5 and seems like someone who will push for more time outside, although he's shown some nice blocking chops so I could see him getting time as a big slot for run blocking. Heath, too.

It's a nice group of young receiving talent; I'm excited to see what they can do. I'm expecting a lot of bumps along the way -- camp reports have been a mix of wow plays, bad drops, and miscommunications. I think that's part of learning to be an NFL WR and they'll improve.

At RB I think Jones/Dillon are the locks and Taylor is the most dependable. With this team the RB3 is more about pass protection and ST than anything, and he's shown he can do both. The other guys are certainly pushing him. I'm not sure if they roster 2 and try to sign as many of the rest to the PS for gameday elevations/further development or keep 3 on the 53. Roster construction/Cutdowns are going to be fascinating. I really like Goodson, but he's on the smaller side (for a RB) and he needs to learn from Jones how to stay healthy.

The future at RB (2024 and beyond) is interesting - Dillon is a FA and Jones is in the last year of a contract with lots of cap hit kicked down the road into it.

texaspackerbacker
08-17-2023, 05:42 PM
The future at RB (2024 and beyond): Unless he gets injured, I'm pretty sure they retain Aaron Jones and beat the cap by restructuring him. I'd be just fine, make that very pleased, if they let Dillon go - get something for him if possible, if not, just let him go/don't pay a lot to keep him, and ABSOLUTELY don't keep him at the cost of losing Jones. I like Patrick Taylor better than Dillon, and probably Emanuel Wilson and maybe Goodson too.

Reed looked pretty good. I like Toure better, though. And Heath? You hear the word "twitch" used. Have we seen anybody in recent history that has more "twitch"/lateral quickness than him? 6 WRs is not too many. Let's keep all of those 6 mentioned.

Fritz
08-17-2023, 07:14 PM
Getting back to safety talk, I woud hope the Pack would not dick around - with the advent of Carrington Valentine, why wouldn't you move Rasul Douglas to safety now? You need another slot cover guy, so just move Savage now, too. Nixon needs to be available for all the other shit he can do. Then start Owens/Moore/Somebody opposite Douglas. Then you have your slot guys, and one good safety. Stokes will be back after mid-season, so you just need to have an outside corner opposite Alexander for seven or eight weeks or however long. And the way Valentine is playing, Stokes might never get his starting gig back.
s

smuggler
08-18-2023, 12:31 PM
Unfortunately, it seems that Rasul was not near as good in the slot as he was on the outside. If you're expecting your safety to spend a lot of time at the line, potentially matching up against slot receivers, maybe that's not the best place for Rasul.

If you want your safety deep, over the top, I think you want a rangey guy and fast decision-maker back there. I have the feeling Rasul is the latter, but not so much the former.

So what does that mean for him?

run pMc
08-18-2023, 12:43 PM
Keep Rasul at outside corner. That's it. He's good there, why put him somewhere where he's not as good?

He's not a slot corner, and he might have taken snaps at safety I don't think he's a great fit there. If he was the coaches would be looking at him more seriously there. The players they have at S now have warts but should be passable. I think they're all better than MD Jennings.

texaspackerbacker
08-18-2023, 01:45 PM
Not "rangy"? He's a 6'2" DB. I'd like to see him as the deep Safety, and choose from among Savage, Owen, Taveras, Ford, Nixon, or whoever at Slot. Maybe do it by committee depending on who lines up there on offense.

Or if you want to keep Douglas at outside Corner, maybe use Jaire in the Slot. I bet he'd be outstanding there.

Fritz
08-18-2023, 03:32 PM
Unfortunately, it seems that Rasul was not near as good in the slot as he was on the outside. If you're expecting your safety to spend a lot of time at the line, potentially matching up against slot receivers, maybe that's not the best place for Rasul.

If you want your safety deep, over the top, I think you want a rangey guy and fast decision-maker back there. I have the feeling Rasul is the latter, but not so much the former.

So what does that mean for him?

I'd agree that Douglas would be better as a deep safety. So play him there, and put Savage in the slot, and let one of the Moore/Owens/Ford group take the other safety spot. Or something.

It's like the offensive line - you want your five best out there, and if that means one of your five best has to learn a new position, then so be it.

smuggler
08-23-2023, 06:45 PM
Not sure if it constitutes "Players of Interest", but the 49ers are moving on from Trey Lance.

He lost his job to Brock Purdy, who has almost three times as many passing TDs in the same amount of game action. Lance lost the backup competition to SAM DARNOLD...

Relevant because Christian Watson was part of the reason Lance looked like a good QB at South Dakota State.

run pMc
08-24-2023, 08:43 AM
Not sure if it constitutes "Players of Interest", but the 49ers are moving on from Trey Lance.

He lost his job to Brock Purdy, who has almost three times as many passing TDs in the same amount of game action. Lance lost the backup competition to SAM DARNOLD...

Relevant because Christian Watson was part of the reason Lance looked like a good QB at South Dakota State.


I think injuries and being very very raw hurt him. You'd assume he has command of the playbook but maybe it's going through progressions or something else. No idea.

NYJ WR Corey Davis is retiring. He came up in trade talks or as a FA target for GB in the past. Maybe Rodgers rolled his eyes and scowled too much his way.

Cowboys' Sam Williams, who GB had in for a predaft 30 visit last year, was arrested on possession and weapons charges.

Fritz
08-24-2023, 10:21 AM
Not sure if it constitutes "Players of Interest", but the 49ers are moving on from Trey Lance.

He lost his job to Brock Purdy, who has almost three times as many passing TDs in the same amount of game action. Lance lost the backup competition to SAM DARNOLD...

Relevant because Christian Watson was part of the reason Lance looked like a good QB at South Dakota State.

You know, when a team beats and beats up on your team a few times, especially in the playoffs, like San Fran did just a few years ago to our boys, you tend to look at that organization as if they've figured it all out - they're smarter, they're one step ahead.

But the Trey Lance debacle suggests they are human, too. They really went after him to get him in the draft, and now he looks like a turd they are trying to scrape a few kernels of corn from before they give up on the whole thing.

run pMc
08-24-2023, 11:55 AM
The 12 players drafted shortly after Lance include seven Pro Bowlers, including wide receiver Ja’Marr Chase, tight end Kyle Pitts, offensive tackle Penei Sewell, cornerback Patrick Surtain II, linebacker Micah Parsons, offensive tackle Rashawn Slater, and quarterback Mac Jones, whom Shanahan was rumored to be interested in leading up to the draft. The Dolphins used the three picks they got from the 49ers to draft a productive and dynamic receiver in Jaylen Waddle and as trade compensation for two star veterans in wide receiver Tyreek Hill and pass rusher Bradley Chubb. The Eagles, tangentially involved after Miami traded them San Francisco’s original no. 12 pick to go up to no. 6 for Waddle, traded in turn with Dallas to move to no. 10, where they selected receiver DeVonta Smith, who has 2,112 receiving yards through two seasons. The Cowboys took Parsons, probably the best non-quarterback of the first round, with the 49ers’ original pick at no. 12.

from https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2023/8/23/23843593/trey-lance-qb3-san-francisco-sam-darnold-lessons

looking like a pretty big swing and a miss. There's always some opportunity cost involved in acquiring a player via FA (salary cap) or draft (player X vs. player Y), but when you trade up for one I think it's magnified.

smuggler
08-24-2023, 12:09 PM
Yikes. Almost every player on the list is elite.

Fritz
08-24-2023, 02:25 PM
It reminds me of the Tony Mandarich draft. A zillion pro bowlers picked after the Packers took a turd.