Partial's Big Board 2007

[Partial]

My prospect rankings:

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Adrian Peterson
3. Brady Quinn
4. Joseph Melanie Thomas
5. Laron Landry
6. Jamaal Anderson
7. Levi Brown
8. Ted Ginn jr.
9. Alan Branch
10. Patrick Willis
11. Amobi Okoye
12. Darelle Revis
13. Lawrence Timmons
14. Reggie Nelson
15. Leon Hall
16. Robert Meachem
17. Paul Posluszny
18. Dwayne Jarrett
19. Jon Beason
20. Dwayne Bowe
21. Adam Carriker
22. Brandon Merriweather
23. Eric Weddle
24. Marshawn Lynch
25. Mike Griffin
26. Jarvis Moss
27. Jamarcus Russell
28. Joe Staley
29. Charles Johnson
30. Craig Davis
31. Greg Olson
32. Anthony Spencer


I don't think they'll go in this order, but thats how I rate 'em. Post any questions or comments.

[HarveyWallbangers]

I'll play. From what I've read, and from what little I've watched:

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Joe Thomas
3. Adrian Peterson
4. JaMarcus Russell
5. Brady Quinn
6. Laron Landry
7. Patrick Willis
8. Levi Brown
9. Jamaal Anderson
10. Robert Meachem
11. Reggie Nelson
12. Gaines Adams
13. Adam Carriker
14. Darrelle Revis
15. Marshawn Lynch
16. Greg Olson
17. Michael Griffin
18. Sidney Rice
19. Ted Ginn
20. Dwayne Bowe
21. Joe Staley
22. Lawrence Timmons
23. Amobi Okoye
24. Leon Hall
25. Justin Harrell
26. Jon Beason
27. Ryan Kalil
28. Brandon Merriweather
29. Chris Houston
30. Eric Weddle
31. Eric Wright
32. Brian Leonard

[Bretsky]

Glad to see both of you rate Meachem well. I really don't want Revis round one, which both of you have rated well. We have too many holes to be drafting a #3 CB but I'm worried TT might just do that.

[Partial]

I'll play. From what I've read, and from what little I've watched:

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Joe Thomas
3. Adrian Peterson
4. JaMarcus Russell
5. Brady Quinn
6. Laron Landry
7. Patrick Willis
8. Levi Brown
9. Jamaal Anderson
10. Robert Meachem
11. Reggie Nelson
12. Gaines Adams
13. Adam Carriker
14. Darrelle Revis
15. Marshawn Lynch
16. Greg Olson
17. Michael Griffin
18. Sidney Rice
19. Ted Ginn
20. Dwayne Bowe
21. Joe Staley
22. Lawrence Timmons
23. Amobi Okoye
24. Leon Hall
25. Justin Harrell
26. Jon Beason
27. Ryan Kalil
28. Brandon Merriweather
29. Chris Houston
30. Eric Weddle
31. Eric Wright
32. Brian Leonard

I forgot Ryan Kalil. He's a good player.

I think you overrate some of the receivers and underrate some of the DBs.

I really don't like Jamarcus Russell. He is a ridiculously good prospect I don't think he'll pan out, though.

[LEWCWA]

Given Russell isn't lower than top 5 on anybodies draft board, rankings are bs at best...just looking for an I told ya so. Well you can throw that crap up on any QB and it will stick much of the time. You don't like him? Why is huge arm?

[Joemailman]

Glad to see both of you rate Meachem well. I really don't want Revis round one, which both of you have rated well. We have too many holes to be drafting a #3 CB but I'm worried TT might just do that.

A #3 CB will get as much playing time as a #3 WR. Plus, Woodson's injury history suggests at some point that the #3 CB will be needed as a starter. I know Woodson made it through last season without missing a game, but just barely. He was really banged up.

[RashanGary]

I wrote mine up last night, the top 20 anyway, and it's funny how close our are Partial.

[RashanGary]

Whoa...now that I look it's closer too Harvs..I'll post it soon.

[PaCkFan_n_MD]

Partial, were do you rank Adams?

[Bretsky]

Glad to see both of you rate Meachem well. I really don't want Revis round one, which both of you have rated well. We have too many holes to be drafting a #3 CB but I'm worried TT might just do that.

A #3 CB will get as much playing time as a #3 WR. Plus, Woodson's injury history suggests at some point that the #3 CB will be needed as a starter. I know Woodson made it through last season without missing a game, but just barely. He was really banged up.

I'm not sure I agree a #3 CB gets as much playing time as a #3 WR. They often come right out in 3 WR sets and w/o Green another weapon becomes even more of a need. But it might be close.

Our defense functioned fine with no stellar #3 CB once Jenkins was inserted and we started getting a pass rush.

Our offensive talent is going the wrong way and if TT wants GB to compete next year a #3 WR or pass catching tight end should be higher priortity than finding the #3 CB.


If the top rated LB falls to us I'm fine with that pick; if a stud DL falls to us I'll be ok with that.

Revis and Hall do not have superstar talent. Both should be good and drafted in the 10-25 range; but neither will be any great value at 16.

If we draft a #3 CB in round one I'll be sick

[RashanGary]

1. Calvin Johnson *Moss and TO meet*
2. Joe Thomas *No worries at LT for the team who takes him*
3. Adrian Peterson *Health?*
4. Brady Quinn *Everything you want in a QB with nothing over the top*
5. Patrick Willis *Looks like Ray Lewis to me*
6. Jamarcus Russell *This is where the big reward outweighs the risk*
7. Gaines Adams *Instant 8+ sacks*
8. Jamaal Anderson *More dominating college player than Mario from the film I watched and the Badger game*
9. Dwayne Bowe *Stud after lasic*
10. Marshawn Lynch *Better than Maroney and I'd take Maroney here*
11. LaRon Landry *OVERRATED but still a very good player*
12. Amobi Okoye *OVERRATED but seems like a sure bet good starter*
13. Robert Meachem *Bretsky convinced me (looks like Walker on tape, injury slowed him early*
14. Reggie Nelson *Playmaker*
15. Paul Posluszny *SOLID*
16. Levi Brown *Might have some learning curve but has all the physical tools you look for*
17. Dwayne Jarrett *Playmaker*
18. Darelle Revis *All the tools and a solid college career*
19. Jarvis Moss *Will contribute early IMO*
20. Ted Ginn Jr.
21. Joe Staley
22. Ben Grubbs
23. Anthony Spencer
24. Brandon Merriweather
25. Leon Hall
26. John Beason
27. Kenny Irons
28. Brian Leonard
29. Charles Johnson
30. Jason Hill *My sleeper pick*
31. Ryan Kalil
32. David Harris *I trust bulldog on MI guys and this one looks like a sure bet good player similar to Demeco Ryans*



There mine are done...

[Partial]

I wonder how this will look 5 years from now.

[PaCkFan_n_MD]

I wonder how this will look 5 years from now.

Ganies Adams will make you look bad.

[Partial]

I wonder how this will look 5 years from now.

Ganies Adams will make you look bad.

Probably. He's from Clemson. But, he's got a motor and decent size/burst so I think he'll be alright.

[woodbuck27]

I'll play. From what I've read, and from what little I've watched:

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Joe Thomas
3. Adrian Peterson
4. JaMarcus Russell
5. Brady Quinn
6. Laron Landry
7. Patrick Willis
8. Levi Brown
9. Jamaal Anderson
10. Robert Meachem
11. Reggie Nelson
12. Gaines Adams
13. Adam Carriker
14. Darrelle Revis
15. Marshawn Lynch
16. Greg Olson
17. Michael Griffin
18. Sidney Rice
19. Ted Ginn
20. Dwayne Bowe
21. Joe Staley
22. Lawrence Timmons
23. Amobi Okoye
24. Leon Hall
25. Justin Harrell
26. Jon Beason
27. Ryan Kalil
28. Brandon Merriweather
29. Chris Houston
30. Eric Weddle
31. Eric Wright
32. Brian Leonard

Do you have a beat on Paul Posluszny Harvey? Why is he not on your board?

I'm guessing that he'll be our man, possibly after TT trades down.

[wist43]

Don't think TT will go CB in the 1st round, but I wouldn't be shocked if he did... one way or another, he'll take a CB w/in the 1st 3 rounds.

TT will ignore need and take the highest rated player on his board, regardless of position. Hell, we could end up with an OT in the 1st round.

[woodbuck27]

My prospect rankings:

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Adrian Peterson
3. Brady Quinn
4. Joseph Melanie Thomas
5. Laron Landry
6. Jamaal Anderson
7. Levi Brown
8. Ted Ginn jr.
9. Alan Branch
10. Patrick Willis
11. Amobi Okoye
12. Darelle Revis
13. Lawrence Timmons
14. Reggie Nelson
15. Leon Hall
16. Robert Meachem
17. Paul Posluszny
18. Dwayne Jarrett
19. Jon Beason
20. Dwayne Bowe
21. Adam Carriker
22. Brandon Merriweather
23. Eric Weddle
24. Marshawn Lynch
25. Mike Griffin
26. Jarvis Moss
27. Jamarcus Russell
28. Joe Staley
29. Charles Johnson
30. Craig Davis
31. Greg Olson
32. Anthony Spencer


I don't think they'll go in this order, but thats how I rate 'em. Post any questions or comments.

Scout Inc's TOP 32.

Scouts Inc.'s Top 32
RANK NAME POS CLASS SCHOOL PREV WK
1. Calvin Johnson WR JR Georgia Tech 1
2. JaMarcus Russell QB JR LSU 2
3. Adrian Peterson RB JR Oklahoma 3
4. Joe Thomas OT SR Wisconsin 4
5. Laron Landry S SR LSU 5
6. Gaines Adams DE SR Clemson 6
7. Brady Quinn QB SR Notre Dame 7
8. Leon Hall CB SR Michigan 9
9. Levi Brown OT SR Penn State 8
10. Amobi Okoye DT SR Louisville 10
11. Patrick Willis ILB SR Mississippi 11
12. Darrelle Revis DC JR Pittsburgh 15
13. Alan Branch DT JR Michigan 12
14. Jamaal Anderson DE JR Arkansas 13
15. Adam Carriker DE SR Nebraska 14

*******

16. Greg Olsen TE JR Miami-FL 18
17. Dwayne Bowe WR SR LSU 16
18. Ted Ginn Jr. WR JR Ohio State 23
19. Marshawn Lynch RB JR Cal 17

20. Jarvis Moss DE JR Florida 19

21. Robert Meachem WR JR Tennessee 26

*******

22. Joe Staley OT SR Central Michigan 20
23. Lawrence Timmons OLB JR Florida State 21
24. Aaron Ross DC SR Texas 24
25. Paul Posluszny OLB SR Penn State 25
26. Reggie Nelson DS JR Florida 29
27. Justin Harrell DT SR Tennessee 28
28. Ryan Kalil C SR USC 22
29. Michael Griffin DS SR Texas 27
30. Ben Grubbs OG SR Auburn NR
31. Chris Houston DC JR Arkansas 30
32. Dwayne Jarrett WR JR USC 31

******* Golly ! *******

There has to be an offensively talented draft pick in there somewhere for the Packers.

[RashanGary]

I finished mine.

[Partial]

My prospect rankings:

1. Calvin Johnson BEASTLY
2. Adrian Peterson BEASTLY
3. Brady Quinn DAISY
4. Joseph Melanie Thomas BEASTLY
5. Laron Landry BEASTLY
6. Jamaal Anderson DAISY
7. Levi Brown HAMSTER
8. Ted Ginn jr. HAMSTER
9. Alan Branch DAISY
10. Patrick Willis BEASTLY
11. Amobi Okoye HAMSTER
12. Darelle Revis BEASTLY
13. Lawrence Timmons HAMSTER
14. Reggie Nelson BEASTLY
15. Leon Hall HAMSTER
16. Robert Meachem DAISY
17. Paul Posluszny BEASTLY
18. Dwayne Jarrett DAISY
19. Jon Beason BEASTLY
20. Dwayne Bowe BEASTLY
21. Adam Carriker QUESTION MARK
22. Brandon Merriweather QUESTION MARK
23. Eric Weddle
24. Marshawn Lynch
25. Mike Griffin
26. Jarvis Moss
27. Jamarcus Russell
28. Joe Staley
29. Charles Johnson
30. Craig Davis
31. Greg Olson
32. Anthony Spencer


I don't think they'll go in this order, but thats how I rate 'em. Post any questions or comments.

I got bored of doing this half way through.

Beastly = beast
Daisy = bust
Hamster = TBD w/ potential

[Lurker64]

It's an inexact science...

[Partial]

I still think Teddy Ginn is going to be one hell of a player, and Jamaal Anderson F'd everyone.

[Lurker64]

Interestingly, of the wide receivers/receiving TEs you bothered to rank on your boards in 2006 and 2007, by your own rankings we have:

3 Daisies
2 Hamsters
2 Beasts

Sort of interesting to think about if you're thinking that a trade back and picking Harvin might be a good idea. Harvin tested positive (http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/draft09/news/story?id=4087941) at the combine, BTW.

[Partial]

Interestingly, of the wide receivers/receiving TEs you bothered to rank on your boards in 2006 and 2007, by your own rankings we have:

3 Daisies
2 Hamsters
2 Beasts

Sort of interesting to think about if you're thinking that a trade back and picking Harvin might be a good idea. Harvin tested positive (http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/draft09/news/story?id=4087941) at the combine, BTW.

I'm not saying I want it to happen. I'm saying those are the two situations where I wouldn't be mad if they were to take a receiver. IMO, they need to either get Crabtree, or get Orakpo/TyJack.

[Zool]

Glad to see both of you rate Meachem well. I really don't want Revis round one, which both of you have rated well. We have too many holes to be drafting a #3 CB but I'm worried TT might just do that.

B you should be working for the Vikings or Bears front office as a covert op.

[Bretsky]

Interesting to note neither HW or Partial had Justine Harrell in their top 30; maybe they knew more than TT :?: :lol:

[HarveyWallbangers]

Interesting to note neither HW or Partial had Justine Harrell in their top 30; maybe they knew more than TT :?: :lol:

Look at #25 on my list.

[Partial]

The first time I heard of Harrell as a legit possibility in the top 20 was in the week before the draft in a CNNSI article, probably Peter King. I had heard of him and seen him play, but really he was an after thought and I didn't think he'd go anywhere near where he did.

[Bretsky]

Interesting to note neither HW or Partial had Justine Harrell in their top 30; maybe they knew more than TT :?: :lol:

Look at #25 on my list.

oops

so maybe Partial is the only smart one :lol: :lol:

[Partial]

I bet a lot of us had seen Harrell and Tennessee play and not even knew who he was. Tenn games are on a fair amount up here.