1982 5 Chicago Jim McMahon QB Brigham Young
1983 5 San Diego Billy Ray Smith OLB Arkansas
1984 5 Kansas City Bill Maas NT Pittsburgh
1985 5 Indianapolis Duane Bickett OLB Southern California
1986 5 St. Louis Anthony Bell OLB Michigan State
1987 5 Cleveland Mike Junkin ILB Duke
1988 5 Cincinnati Rickey Dixon DB Oklahoma
1989 5 Atlanta Deion Sanders CB Florida State
1990 5 San Diego Junior Seau OLB Southern California
1991 5 L.A. Rams Todd Lyght CB Notre Dame
1992 5 Green Bay Terrell Buckley CB Florida State
1993 5 Cincinnati John Copeland DE Alabama
1994 5 Indianapolis Trev Alberts LB Nebraska
1995 5 Carolina Kerry Collins QB Penn State
1996 5 N.Y. Giants Cedric Jones DE Oklahoma
1997 5 Detroit Bryant Westbrook CB Texas
1998 5 Chicago Curtis Enis RB Penn State
1999 5 New Orleans Ricky Williams RB Texas
2000 5 Baltimore Jamal Lewis RB Tennessee
2001 5 San Diego LaDainian Tomlinson RB Texas Christian
2002 5 San Diego Quentin Jammer CB Texas
2003 5 Dallas Terence Newman CB Kansas State
2004 5 Washington Sean Taylor FS Miami
2005 5 Tampa Bay Carnell Williams RB Auburn