The only way TT and M3 walk away winners...

[Bretsky]

They win if Rodgers leads them to the playoffs.

They lose if they don't make the playoffs.

They lose even worse if Favre makes the playoffs on another team.

Do they lose their jobs over it? No. But it does increase the pressure for next year.

Green Bay Is Making the playoffs with even below average QB play IMO
so I definitely would not be that soft on your judgment

This is long term and I don't think TT or MM win or lose either way

[Badgerinmaine]

The poll question is slanted against Thompson and McCarthy. Favre is good for one, maybe two years. Whatever happens after that would have happened either way--this sage has little bearing on it.

Considering we haven't won a Super Bowl in almost 12 years with Favre, it's a bit much to say the only way they win this sage is to win a Super Bowl.

Exactly. I think this kind of "who wins" speculation isn't healthy for anyone and just adds to the overflowing pile of media hype. Only one team wins a Super Bowl a year; to say everyone else is a failure makes no sense to me.

[Gunakor]

The Buffalo Bills have never won a Super Bowl. Are you going to tell me that Marv Levy wasn't a successful coach, or that his 4 consecutive AFC Championships are insignificant without the SB win? The man earned his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning the big one.

Not that I am predicting this to happen, because I'm not, but what if MM earns his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning a Super Bowl. Would you consider him to be a winner or a loser?

[gex]

And Favre bringing us to the playoffs 13+yrs?
Thanx but management doesn't want you anymore.

[MJZiggy]

And Favre bringing us to the playoffs 13+yrs?
Thanx but management doesn't want you anymore.

I wonder why that is. Gex, why do you think it is that they don't want him anymore?

[gex]

And Favre bringing us to the playoffs 13+yrs?
Thanx but management doesn't want you anymore.

I wonder why that is. Gex, why do you think it is that they don't want him anymore?

HUH?

[The Shadow]

And Favre bringing us to the playoffs 13+yrs?
Thanx but management doesn't want you anymore.

I wonder why that is. Gex, why do you think it is that they don't want him anymore?

HUH?

Perhaps there are reasons?

[Gunakor]

And Favre bringing us to the playoffs 13+yrs?
Thanx but management doesn't want you anymore.

I wonder why that is. Gex, why do you think it is that they don't want him anymore?

HUH?

I don't know, but I'll wager it's a combination of Favre not wanting to play here anymore, Favre publicly lashing out at the organization, and a commitment to Aaron Rodgers. And a whole bunch of other reasons that you will likely never know. Both sides are okay with it at this point, so I guess it's okay. Isn't it?

[MadtownPacker]

The Buffalo Bills have never won a Super Bowl. Are you going to tell me that Marv Levy wasn't a successful coach, or that his 4 consecutive AFC Championships are insignificant without the SB win? The man earned his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning the big one.

Not that I am predicting this to happen, because I'm not, but what if MM earns his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning a Super Bowl. Would you consider him to be a winner or a loser?

When his name is brought up what is always mentioned? The great coach who lost 4 SBs in a row. Dont pretend it is not what history remembers him for.

[MadtownPacker]

The poll question is slanted against Thompson and McCarthy. Favre is good for one, maybe two years. Whatever happens after that would have happened either way--this sage has little bearing on it.

Considering we haven't won a Super Bowl in almost 12 years with Favre, it's a bit much to say the only way they win this sage is to win a Super Bowl.

If you dont like it dont vote. That simple. The question isnt slanted any way. Just a straight up question if this is the only way they shine after all this.

I can tell you right now that NOT making the playoffs this year wont go over well with many of you who now hate Favre.

[Badgerinmaine]

The Buffalo Bills have never won a Super Bowl. Are you going to tell me that Marv Levy wasn't a successful coach, or that his 4 consecutive AFC Championships are insignificant without the SB win? The man earned his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning the big one.

Darned right. I get sick of hearing how athletes' (or coaches') careers are somehow flawed if they weren't on a world champion. It's an absurdly high standard that just makes people miserable.

[Gunakor]

The Buffalo Bills have never won a Super Bowl. Are you going to tell me that Marv Levy wasn't a successful coach, or that his 4 consecutive AFC Championships are insignificant without the SB win? The man earned his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning the big one.

Not that I am predicting this to happen, because I'm not, but what if MM earns his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning a Super Bowl. Would you consider him to be a winner or a loser?

When his name is brought up what is always mentioned? The great coach who lost 4 SBs in a row. Dont pretend it is not what history remembers him for.

He's still in the Hall of Fame. He's still a great coach. Those were still great teams. Don't pretend they weren't. They made it to 4 consecutive Super Bowls, something that hadn't happened before and likely won't happen again. Give credit where it is earned.

[MadtownPacker]

The Buffalo Bills have never won a Super Bowl. Are you going to tell me that Marv Levy wasn't a successful coach, or that his 4 consecutive AFC Championships are insignificant without the SB win? The man earned his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning the big one.

Not that I am predicting this to happen, because I'm not, but what if MM earns his way into the Hall of Fame without ever winning a Super Bowl. Would you consider him to be a winner or a loser?

When his name is brought up what is always mentioned? The great coach who lost 4 SBs in a row. Dont pretend it is not what history remembers him for.

He's still in the Hall of Fame. He's still a great coach. Those were still great teams. Don't pretend they weren't. They made it to 4 consecutive Super Bowls, something that hadn't happened before and likely won't happen again. Give credit where it is earned.

Im not saying he wasdnt great. What I am saying is that the 4 losses are ALWAYS and I mean ALWAYS mentioned at some point. Four in a row was great but then losing four in a row is brought up.

[GBRulz]

Every player once he reaches a certain age will hit a wall. (We all gotta pray Harris and Woodson won't this coming year!)

Hopefully Harris has a chip on his shoulder and comes out swinging this year. Otherwise, I think he's well on the downside of his career.