Official Superbowl thread

[RashanGary]

Let's not get into Favre here, HH. This is about Terrible Tom, the guy who won 3 titles in his first 4 years and was herralded the greatest big game QB ever.

Since then:

Loses to Denver with a pick in the division game
Loses to Indy in the AFC championship
Loses in the SB against a team nobody thought had a chance.


Great first four years. I'll give him that. Since then? Not so good.

[Harlan Huckleby]

I think people over-react to a loss. this loss won't hurt Brady's reputation.

Marino, Favre, Unitis, Kelly, Tarkington lost Super Bowls.

[b bulldog]

Oh well, Eli should now be considered the best QB in the NFC and with that D, their youth and all of their capp room not to mention having Shockey back, they will be tough to deal with next year. I am very happy for Strahan, it looks as though he will retire a champion. he seems to be a great guy.

[Scott Campbell]

Sorry fellas, I'd hang this one on their OL - not on Brady.

[cpk1994]

Oh well, Eli should now be considered the best QB in the NFC and with that D, their youth and all of their capp room not to mention having Shockey back, they will be tough to deal with next year. I am very happy for Strahan, it looks as though he will retire a champion. he seems to be a great guy.

I think Shockey coming back is a bad thing. The team played better without him and his selfish antics.

[RashanGary]

Oh well, Eli should now be considered the best QB in the NFC and with that D, their youth and all of their capp room not to mention having Shockey back, they will be tough to deal with next year. I am very happy for Strahan, it looks as though he will retire a champion. he seems to be a great guy.

I'd take Eli right now over Brett. I like him a lot. Brett probably would have tossed 3 picks in that game.

[Harlan Huckleby]

Great first four years. I'll give him that. Since then? Not so good.

Brady just completed the greatest (statistical) season by any QB in the history of the NFL!

He lost a close game in the Super Bowl, but that was a team loss.

[motife]

http://www.weei.com/

the callers are not very happy. one guy just had an F-bomb and wasn't cutoff.

[Harlan Huckleby]

I'd take Eli right now over Brett. I like him a lot. Brett probably would have tossed 3 picks in that game.

Well, Favre has good and bad games, you never know. I'd take Eli just because Favre is nearing the end of his career.

[Scott Campbell]

Oh well, Eli should now be considered the best QB in the NFC and with that D, their youth and all of their capp room not to mention having Shockey back, they will be tough to deal with next year. I am very happy for Strahan, it looks as though he will retire a champion. he seems to be a great guy.

I'd take Eli right now over Brett. I like him a lot. Brett probably would have tossed 3 picks in that game.

I think the Packer offense would have scored more against the Pats. Though our D would probably have given up a lot more.

[RashanGary]

Brady just completed the greatest (statistical) season by any QB in the history of the NFL!

He lost a close game in the Super Bowl, but that was a team loss.

Nah, QB's are judged on winning the game. He failed.

Favre is the greatest statistical QB of all time but I think he's seriously flawed too.

Brady's a statue. Great player when he has all day. I'll give him that. Right guy at the right time, I'll give him that. Top 5? I can't say I've watched every QB play but I don't even think he's better than the guy we have and like I said, he's seriously flawed too.

[packinpatland]

Maybe if Brady could move alittle, instead of standing 'statue-like'. .........

Another subject.........why did BB leave the field before the game was over?
I missed that part..........had to take a phone call.

[RashanGary]

I'd take Eli right now over Brett. I like him a lot. Brett probably would have tossed 3 picks in that game.

Well, Favre has good and bad games, you never know. I'd take Eli just because Favre is nearing the end of his career.

Yeah, that's a big part of it but Brett's luster is wearing off on me. He's lost too many big games with stupid picks for me to turn the other way.

My only problem with Brady is that he's not the guy you build yoru team around. He's the guy that manages it.

[b bulldog]

The Giants are the best team in footbal;l right now, they have nothing else to prove. Their Dline is what I want the Packers line to get to and we are very far from that. Justin Tuck is 10 times the player 99 is. Pierce is probably my favorite LB in the NFC. He plays tough and nasty.

[Scott Campbell]

I'd take Eli right now over Brett. I like him a lot. Brett probably would have tossed 3 picks in that game.

Well, Favre has good and bad games, you never know. I'd take Eli just because Favre is nearing the end of his career.

Yeah, that's a big part of it but Brett's luster is wearing off on me. He's lost too many big games with stupid picks for me to turn the other way.

My only problem with Brady is that he's not the guy you build yoru team around. He's the guy that manages it.

I think all 32 GM's in the league could build a team around Brady. He's the MVP, and a well deserving one at that.