If Brian Brohm is available at 30 would you want to take him

[BlueBrewer]

I have confidence in Arod but have this what if in the back of my mind. I personally think it would be a mistake and send a bad message to Arod. But on the other hand a talented rookie to push him and keep him sharp might not be the worst thing. Any thoughts?

[BallHawk]

I have confidence in A-Rod. There are guys out there that could give us Brohm level production if needed (David Carr comes to mind)

[Lurker64]

I would not take Brohm at 30. I would consider him at 56, however. Brian Brohm has not impressed me.

[BlueBrewer]

I would not take Brohm at 30. I would consider him at 56, however. Brian Brohm has not impressed me.

I think it is funny, if he would have come out a year ago he would have been a top 10

[Lurker64]

I think it is funny, if he would have come out a year ago he would have been a top 10

But I think what Brohm did last year is a good reason why he's going to drop. He faced adversity this year and he completely folded under pressure. That's not the kind of person I want to be my quarterback.

[BlueBrewer]

I think it is funny, if he would have come out a year ago he would have been a top 10

But I think what Brohm did last year is a good reason why he's going to drop. He faced adversity this year and he completely folded under pressure. That's not the kind of person I want to be my quarterback.

good point

[rbaloha1]

Brohm at #30

Yes, I would take him. Polished, pro ready pocket passer. Well schooled in a pro style offense.

If plays at a pro bowl level, Brohm can always be traded if he performs well in preseason like Detmer, Brunell, Brooks and Hasselbeck.


Colt Brennan would be a great 3 - 4 round pic.

[Partial]

I remember watching Brohm as a Sophomore against Miami. It was one heck of a game. He's a good player.

[Charles Woodson]

I remember watching Brohm as a Sophomore against Miami. It was one heck of a game. He's a good player.

Sad enough, basing it off one game isnt good enough, watching brohm this year showed that he isnt nearly as good as many thought

[Joemailman]

If he's available at 30 you try to trade down to someone looking for a quarterback. You can't draft a QB in the 1st round without creating the impression that you have doubts about Rodgers.

[Partial]

I remember watching Brohm as a Sophomore against Miami. It was one heck of a game. He's a good player.

Sad enough, basing it off one game isnt good enough, watching brohm this year showed that he isnt nearly as good as many thought

That is a true statement, and I don't know enough about him, but I also don't think he had a lot of players around him this year.

[Deputy Nutz]

No at the very most you trade down like an above poster stated.

[KYPack]

I have the feeling they get a QB with one of the two's.

[3irty1]

Brohm has no buisness being in the first round.

[twoseven]

Brady Quinn slid into the second round, not sure why Brohm wouldn't do the same.