Rodgers vs Brohm

[RashanGary]

We'll see. I like Brohm. I don't hate Rodgers either. The team seems to love him. Everyone is behind him. JJ recently said that Rodgers knows the offense better than Brett and throws the ball just as hard (I believe it, Bretts arm is still good, but it really dropped off from 10 years ago when it was special). It'll be a fun time finding out who's the guy. I just hope it's one of them and I feel a lot better having two high picks duking it out rather than selling out on one.

[LL2]

Rodgers is the guy. He will have the year to prove himself, and if he sucks Brohm will get his chance next year. Brohm isn't ready yet. I'm in favor of letting a QB sit on the bench for a year or two. Even if Brohm plays lights out in the preseason it will only help his trade value not his chance to be the starter. There is a difference between regular season and preseason. Brohm is a couple years younger and provides great insurance.

What I like is that between Rodgers and Brohm the Packers have a really good chance of having a great starting QB for years to come. TT is a smart guy.

[RashanGary]

I woudln't say really good chance at a great one, but I'd say good chance at a good one which is better than hanging it all on an unproven Rodgers. I'm very happy with that pick.

[Tarlam!]

I just hope we got the better outta Henne and Brohm. If Henne turns into a HOFer, I might be disappointed.

[HarveyWallbangers]

I woudln't say really good chance at a great one, but I'd say good chance at a good one which is better than hanging it all on an unproven Rodgers. I'm very happy with that pick.

Brohm is even more unproven than Rodgers. Just look at where they were drafted to get a feel for what type of prospect each guy is/was coming into the NFL. Rodgers drafted late 1st round. Brohm drafted late 2nd round.

[Chubbyhubby]

It boils down to Rodgers durablilty. With Favre that was NEVER an issue but Rodgers is a question mark. I expect the Packers to really test all 3 QB's this summer. I am glad they addressed the QB in the draft. I had a feeling that they would draft 2 QB's just didn't know which one. All in all this draft class looks pretty damn good.