Originally posted by Pacopete4
Paco, what makes you think that A-Rod CAN'T do anything? Is there something I missed? Did you see something from Rodgers that the rest of us could not see? Why do you hate on Rodgers so?
I personally am not suggesting that Favre can't duplicate his success last season, so don't take that away from my arguement here. What I am stating is quite simply the risk of losing a talented 25 year old QB that could give this team 10+ seasons of winning football in favor of a talented 39 year old QB who could give this team one or two. It's just not worth it to me unless bringing Favre back this year was a GUARANTEE that we'd win a SB this year. Since it's not guaranteed, I'd rather take my chances over time with the 25 year old. Odds are far greater that Rodgers will win one during the remainder of his career than that Favre will win one during the remainder of his.
Don't get me wrong, I have no problems with a win now attitude. But I personally have a win consistently attitude, which sometimes doesn't jive real well with those who refuse to look beyond the coming season. People love to talk about Rodgers inexperience as his downfall, but those same people don't consider that if Rodgers feels lied to and leaves Green Bay for a better opportunity then we are stuck with Brian Brohm who has even less experience. That's kind of a downer to someone with a win consistently attitude like myself. To me it's not about making Favre happy anymore, since his career is almost over anyway. It's about keeping Rodgers happy so he'll be a Packer as long as Favre has been.

Comment