No open competition...

[packinpatland]

This is more about "winning more games this season" than being "fair" by a long shot.

Really?

Then why isn't Favre the QB?

Maybe because every time Rodgers has gotten the chance, he has outplayed Favre.

I was at the Packer/Patriot game 2 years ago.........Rodgers didn't outplay Favre, Rodgers broke his foot.

Favre didn't finish the game.

Yes, I know that. You made the point that ARod 'outplayed' Favre......
Favre got hurt, Rodgers went in. Packers still lost..........

Yup............all Favre's fault......the Defense played flawless.

[Bretsky]

This whole thing is ridiculous. It's a shameful time to be a Packer fan, watching a once great organization bite its thumb at the player who made it what it was.

I still don't get it. Can somebody PLEASE tell me what the Packers did to Bart Starr?

They canned him as a coach about the time he was starting to figure out what the hell he was doing

[MJZiggy]

To be fair, I don't think trying to shift your weight to throw off of a broken foot is an easy thing to do. Compared to throwing with a broken thumb, I'd think that both are painful and Favre didn't always play so well with that injury. Yes, I recall a good game in there, but in general, he wasn't smashing and funny how a huge deal was made of it but no one remembers Rodgers running all over on a broken foot. I guess because he was the backup, no one made a big deal out of it.

[Chevelle2]

This is more about "winning more games this season" than being "fair" by a long shot.

Really?

Then why isn't Favre the QB?

Maybe because every time Rodgers has gotten the chance, he has outplayed Favre.

I was at the Packer/Patriot game 2 years ago.........Rodgers didn't outplay Favre, Rodgers broke his foot.

Favre didn't finish the game.

Yes, I know that. You made the point that ARod 'outplayed' Favre......
Favre got hurt, Rodgers went in. Packers still lost..........

Yup............all Favre's fault......the Defense played flawless.

0 points. 0.