Announcement

**HarveyWallbangers** · 08-25-2008, 07:40 AM

Originally posted by Pacopete4

Best:
1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Favre
5. Brees
6. Palmer
7. Hasselbeck
8. Roethlisberger
9. Rivers
10. Cutler

Worst:
1. Croyle
2. Edwards
3. Boller/Smith/Flacco
4. Ryan
5. Orton (even though I think he'll do good, I have to til he proves me right)
6. O'Sullivan
7. Pennington
8. Tjack
9. Schaub
10. Young

I think Arod's gotta be around 15-19th ranked right now with a shot to move up on his play.. haven't see enough to warrant a high nor low ranking

Based on last year, these are fine. If projecting for this year, I'd take Brees and Big Ben over Favre. Probably Hasselbeck and Palmer also. That would still put Favre in the top 8 though. I think TJack will be better than 30th this year, but I'm not sure how big of a jump he'll make. I'd move Schaub up also--even further than TJack. ARod at 15-19 is fine. I have hopes that he'll be higher than that, but the proof is in the pudding.

**Tarlam!** · 08-25-2008, 08:09 AM

Young is the worst QB in the league? Phewie.

**Zool** · 08-25-2008, 08:12 AM

I think they're saying 10th worst situation for Young to be in. Croyle is in the worst situation over all.

**Tarlam!** · 08-25-2008, 08:16 AM

Thanks, Z. Clearly, I didn't get it.

**mngolf19** · 08-25-2008, 08:34 AM

TJack is not in the bottom 5 of QB's in this league. Sheesh, this will be his 3rd season for crying out loud. And the Vikes are not in the bottom 10 QB situations either. He needs to make a step up this year no doubt, but I'm confident he will to some extent. Enough for the team to win this year I believe. If I'm wrong, we'll find out soon enough on opening night. But that goes for everyone else too.

**Zool** · 08-25-2008, 08:43 AM

Originally posted by mngolf19

TJack is not in the bottom 5 of QB's in this league. Sheesh, this will be his 3rd season for crying out loud. And the Vikes are not in the bottom 10 QB situations either. He needs to make a step up this year no doubt, but I'm confident he will to some extent. Enough for the team to win this year I believe. If I'm wrong, we'll find out soon enough on opening night. But that goes for everyone else too.

Hard to base an entire season on 1 game, but I get where you're coming from. Setting the tone early helps the entire team.

**The Leaper** · 08-25-2008, 08:45 AM

My top 5 situations?

1. Pats...loads of talent with players and coaches.
2. Colts...loads of talent, dome, hands-off coaches.
3. Saints...lots of weapons, dome, progressive coach.
4. Jags...fabulous defense and run game in support.
5. Steelers...high level talent and strong run game.

Bottom 5?

1. Dolphins
2. Chiefs
3. Bears
4. Falcons
5. Titans

**texaspackerbacker** · 08-25-2008, 09:24 AM

Are these based on analysis of last season? Or are these predictions of the upcoming season?

Favre ranked third is very valid based on last year. This season, though, I say he is clearly upper bottom ten material.

**Gunakor** · 08-25-2008, 01:10 PM

Originally posted by The Leaper

My top 5 situations?

1. Pats...loads of talent with players and coaches.
2. Colts...loads of talent, dome, hands-off coaches.
3. Saints...lots of weapons, dome, progressive coach.
4. Jags...fabulous defense and run game in support.
5. Steelers...high level talent and strong run game.

Bottom 5?

1. Dolphins
2. Chiefs
3. Bears
4. Falcons
5. Titans

I don't know if I could put Miami on the bottom 5 this year. They got a proven starter in Pennington, who is lacking arm strength but makes up for some of that with his accuracy and efficiency. Behind him is Henne who was fairly highly rated coming out of college and just might become a solid starting QB for them in a year or two.

I can't really disagree with any of the other ones though.

**SnakeLH2006** · 08-25-2008, 02:26 PM

Originally posted by texaspackerbacker

Are these based on analysis of last season? Or are these predictions of the upcoming season?

Favre ranked third is very valid based on last year. This season, though, I say he is clearly upper bottom ten material.

I was projecting the current QB situations coming into this 2008 season. For example, Favre was prob. 2nd or 3rd last year and I have him 6th this year. T-Jack was terrible the last 2 years, but coming into his 3rd year, he is definitely not one of the worst 5 with the talent around him and his starting experience.

LOL about the worst QB in Madden as T-Jack, as I use Matt Ryan as my QB. I traded for all the best rooks and 2nd year guys for my Packer Franchise. A-Rod does well on there too.

**MOBB DEEP** · 08-25-2008, 04:13 PM