A Challenge to the irrational haters.

[TheCheese]

I thought this would be a good idea to discuss after reading all the posts lately and seeing all the negativity and hate.

To those of you, and you know who you are, who think TT is a horrible GM, or can't stand the fact that he is the GM of the packers, answer the following question.

List all of the GMs in the NFL that are better than Thompson. Go.

[falco]

Re: A Challenge to the irrational haters.

I thought this would be a good idea to discuss after reading all the posts lately and seeing all the negativity and hate.

To those of you, and you know who you are, who think TT is a horrible GM, or can't stand the fact that he is the GM of the packers, answer the following question.

List all of the GMs in the NFL that are better than Thompson. Go.

matt millen

oh you said IN the NFL

[TheCheese]

If you get bored with that, list all the other current head coaches in the NFL you would rather have than McCarthy.

[Rastak]

Head coach I rather have for the Packers? Brad Childress....

[retailguy]

Head coach I rather have for the Packers? Brad Childress....

He's perfect.... right where he is. Now that Matt Millen is available, I see the makings of a really good team. :P

[Gunakor]

Head coach I rather have for the Packers? Brad Childress....

You don't count. But your answer made me giggle, coming from a Queens fan.

[TravisWilliams23]

GM: Bill Parcells. Already doubled the Fins win total for last season.
He knows his football and he always has a hard hitting-tough team when he gets all the pieces together.
The coach he hired for the Miami job, Tony Sparano, seems to know how to
use what he has to get the job done. The offense he's using with Ronnie Brown at the QB position is causing opposing teams defenses nightmares.
I realize Green Bay has a good GM and a good HC but I think Parcells trumps Thompson. Just my opinion.

[texaspackerbacker]

GM: Bill Parcells. Already doubled the Fins win total for last season.
He knows his football and he always has a hard hitting-tough team when he gets all the pieces together.
The coach he hired for the Miami job, Tony Sparano, seems to know how to
use what he has to get the job done. The offense he's using with Ronnie Brown at the QB position is causing opposing teams defenses nightmares.
I realize Green Bay has a good GM and a good HC but I think Parcells trumps Thompson. Just my opinion.

As much as I respect Thompson/McCarthy, your post makes a helluva lot of sense. Sparano is VERY much like McCarthy; And Parcels has done it with several teams now, both as GM and as Coach.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Parcells hasn't won the superbowl in years...and certainly hasn't proven anything as a GM.

He wasn't GM of the Cowboys and didnt' win a playoff game.

[TravisWilliams23]

Ty, you're correct about Parcells as not being the Dallas GM. He isn't even the Miami GM. His official title is Executive Vice President of Football Operations.
His trouble with Kraft in New England was that he didn't have enough input with drafting decisions and it ended up with him leaving.
I just think he has that special knack to find football talent and that's what I like about him.

So, on the basis of being a better GM than Thompson, I'll have to give the nod to TT because he actually IS a GM.

[BEARMAN]

Coach of the Year, ..... LOVIE SMITH !

Go BEARS Go !

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Ty, you're correct about Parcells as not being the Dallas GM. He isn't even the Miami GM. His official title is Executive Vice President of Football Operations.
His trouble with Kraft in New England was that he didn't have enough input with drafting decisions and it ended up with him leaving.
I just think he has that special knack to find football talent and that's what I like about him.

So, on the basis of being a better GM than Thompson, I'll have to give the nod to TT because he actually IS a GM.

Miami: There is no doubt that the buck stops with him. So, while not a gm, i give him credit for the role.

Talent: We shall see. But, there is more to the role of GM than finding talent, it is making sure it stays, paying the right guys, attracting talent, hiring the right coach, etc.

Don't get me wrong. I like Parcells. But, if we are going by the facts..the facts are that he hasn't won in a long time...and he did have a ton of control with the Jets.

[Bretsky]

Re: A Challenge to the irrational haters.

I thought this would be a good idea to discuss after reading all the posts lately and seeing all the negativity and hate.

To those of you, and you know who you are, who think TT is a horrible GM, or can't stand the fact that he is the GM of the packers, answer the following question.

List all of the GMs in the NFL that are better than Thompson. Go.

Who is a TT hater in here ? Am I a hater because I point out he has not solved the OL problem yet and might want to use other means than just the draft ?

Is it alright to question his moves......or is he exempt from opinions that criticize ?

[Iron Mike]

Cooze of the Year, ..... LOVIE HOWELL!

Eeeew, that's nasty, dude.

[Brando19]

Re: A Challenge to the irrational haters.

I thought this would be a good idea to discuss after reading all the posts lately and seeing all the negativity and hate.

To those of you, and you know who you are, who think TT is a horrible GM, or can't stand the fact that he is the GM of the packers, answer the following question.

List all of the GMs in the NFL that are better than Thompson. Go.

Who is a TT hater in here ? Am I a hater because I point out he has not solved the OL problem yet and might want to use other means than just the draft ?

Is it alright to question his moves......or is he exempt from opinions that criticize ?

No doubt...it's getting really old when one of us complains about the OL or the run defense...someone has to go start a thread on all the TT haters. There's always room for improvement. Opinions are welcome here.