If GM..and all played 3 years.......Arod, Favre, or Manning?

[MOBB DEEP]

VICK DA GREAT....

[Scott Campbell]

I'm not sold Manning is declining yet; he just has to get over the injuries and he'll be back.

To me this is an easy question

1. Manning
2. Favre
3. Rodgers

As much as I emotionally respect and admire Favre, I still believe Manning is the better QB. Rodgers has been very impressive in his first 6 starts. He is still too inexperienced to even mention in the same breath as Manning or Favre.

Yeah, but at the end of the three years you've got a 27 year old asset instead of a 42 year old.

Manning
Rodgers
Favre

[MOBB DEEP]

I'm not sold Manning is declining yet; he just has to get over the injuries and he'll be back.

To me this is an easy question

1. Manning
2. Favre
3. Rodgers

As much as I emotionally respect and admire Favre, I still believe Manning is the better QB. Rodgers has been very impressive in his first 6 starts. He is still too inexperienced to even mention in the same breath as Manning or Favre.

Yeah, but at the end of the three years you've got a 27 year old asset instead of a 42 year old.

Manning
Rodgers
Favre

et tu brute?

[HarveyWallbangers]

To me this is an easy question

1. Manning
2. Favre
3. Rodgers

To me this is an easy decision also.

1. Manning
2. Rodgers
3. Favre

[Gunakor]

If it were just this year, I'd take Favre or Manning. If I have 3 years and I only have to win a SB once to justify my decision, I take Rodgers.

[Bretsky]

To me this is an easy question

1. Manning
2. Favre
3. Rodgers

To me this is an easy decision also.

1. Manning
2. Rodgers
3. Favre

Well a .333 batting lifetime batting average for you should get you into the HOF in baseball

[HarveyWallbangers]

Well a .333 batting lifetime batting average for you should get you into the HOF in baseball

This is actually a good question. The reason Rodgers is QB'ing this team this year is because of this question. McCarthy and Thompson chose Rodgers. Of course, I think it was more obvious because Favre might not play 3 years and Rodgers could play another 10 years.

[Tony Oday]

oops

[Bretsky]

Well a .333 batting lifetime batting average for you should get you into the HOF in baseball

This is actually a good question. The reason Rodgers is QB'ing this team this year is because of this question. McCarthy and Thompson chose Rodgers. Of course, I think it was more obvious because Favre might not play 3 years and Rodgers could play another 10 years.

True

Good Thread Snake

[HarveyWallbangers]

Is it silly for me to say I'd take Aaron Rodgers for this season alone... not even considering the next two seasons? I'd probably still take Brett for one year because of his durability.

68.2 completion %, 6.8 yards/attempt, 13 pass TDs, 8 ints, 17 rush yds, 0 rush TDs, 15 sacks in 210 pass attempts (1 sack for every 14.0 pass attempts), 2 lost fumbles, 13 total TDs, 10 total turnovers

65.6 completion %, 7.5 yards/attempt, 12 pass TDs, 4 ints, 113 rush yards, 3 rush TDs, 13 sacks in 234 pass attempts (1 sack for every 18.0 pass attempts), 2 lost fumbles, 15 total TDs, 6 total turnovers