Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Is McCarthy too conservative in key situations?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Is McCarthy too conservative in key situations?

    Why when on the road does McCarthy not go for it on a 3rd and 10 with 3 minutes left in the game and on the 44 yard line? McCarthy pulls back and plays it safe with the screen pass that never works ever, and takes the ball out of Rodgers hands when he was completing passes and driving us down the field. If he has Rodgers throw a pass 20 yards downfield and it gets picked off who cares? It's like a punt anyway. Well, McCarthy, you played to not lose and you lost, are you happy?

  • #2
    He kinda looks down syndrome ...

    Comment


    • #3
      I was pissed as well. Was he scared of the sack. Who cares about getting sacked at that yard line. A good punt still puts you in the same situation. I hated that call

      Comment


      • #4
        GET SINGLETARY!!!!
        They said God has a Tim Tebow complex!

        Brew Crew in 2011!!!

        Comment


        • #5
          i agree

          play not to lose,

          or win

          Comment


          • #6
            So, is it M3's fault that the D dropped 3 INT's? That Rodgers turned the ball over twice?

            It was a well fought game, but against a team like TN, we have to capitalize on everything.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by GBRulz
              So, is it M3's fault that the D dropped 3 INT's? That Rodgers turned the ball over twice?

              It was a well fought game, but against a team like TN, we have to capitalize on everything.
              he needs to tighten the reigns on his ship

              most of those were mental mistakes, he needs to make sure those are minimized

              its one thing if its just one or two guys. but when multiple guys are making multiple mistakes, then that has to fall on the coaching as well as the players

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by GBRulz
                So, is it M3's fault that the D dropped 3 INT's? That Rodgers turned the ball over twice?

                It was a well fought game, but against a team like TN, we have to capitalize on everything.
                I don't recall saying it was McCarthy's fault that those things happened. Yes we need to capitalize on everything in a game like this. However, we have the ball and a chance to win it at the end and McCarthy pulls back and plays it safe by throwing a screen pass that I don't recall ever working this year. Rodgers was on target with a lot of his passes that drive too. Instead of having no confidence in your QB and playing to lose like he did, why not grow some balls and go for the win. If you lose, at least you can say you tried everything you could do to win.

                Comment


                • #9
                  can I bump my, "Were we fooled" thread?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    some of the mental mistakes were improved today. Much less penalties than usual.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Can I bump my "MM shouldnt call the plays" thread that NO ONE replied to and laughed off as absurdity...

                      ???

                      Over and over again ... I'm sure it's all coincidental.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by channtheman
                        Originally posted by GBRulz
                        So, is it M3's fault that the D dropped 3 INT's? That Rodgers turned the ball over twice?

                        It was a well fought game, but against a team like TN, we have to capitalize on everything.
                        I don't recall saying it was McCarthy's fault that those things happened. Yes we need to capitalize on everything in a game like this. However, we have the ball and a chance to win it at the end and McCarthy pulls back and plays it safe by throwing a screen pass that I don't recall ever working this year. Rodgers was on target with a lot of his passes that drive too. Instead of having no confidence in your QB and playing to lose like he did, why not grow some balls and go for the win. If you lose, at least you can say you tried everything you could do to win.
                        It depends. If no one is open downfield, you dump it off short. I don't blame him at all if he didn't have an open receiver. Better to do that than take the sack--and I have seen that play work, usually with Driver across the middle. Now if they really always run that play in that situation to the point of predictability...
                        "Greatness is not an act... but a habit.Greatness is not an act... but a habit." -Greg Jennings

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          One of McCarthys biggest flaws in my opinion is his inability to finish, he doesnt have that killer instinct and thats why we are put in those situations. I mean what the fuck was going on right there it was at the 43 yard line and we punted, at least if we went for a FG it wouldnt feel like conceding defeat. He plays like he's scared to lose, not like he's going for gold. FUCK! His conservative play-calling at inopportune times and his lack of a killer instinct has cost us 4 games that i can think about off the top of my head. We need a running game to make this guy look good and i think thats kind of why we arent seeing the full potential of his play-calling, cos right now hes trying to win two-dimensional with a one-dimensional team.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by channtheman
                            Originally posted by GBRulz
                            So, is it M3's fault that the D dropped 3 INT's? That Rodgers turned the ball over twice?

                            It was a well fought game, but against a team like TN, we have to capitalize on everything.
                            I don't recall saying it was McCarthy's fault that those things happened. Yes we need to capitalize on everything in a game like this. However, we have the ball and a chance to win it at the end and McCarthy pulls back and plays it safe by throwing a screen pass that I don't recall ever working this year. Rodgers was on target with a lot of his passes that drive too. Instead of having no confidence in your QB and playing to lose like he did, why not grow some balls and go for the win. If you lose, at least you can say you tried everything you could do to win.
                            I'm with you, channtheman. I've been one to criticize his conservative play calling on many occasions. but today, I don't think we'd be bitching about the play calling as much if we had stepped it up and capitalized on some opportunities.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by mission
                              Can I bump my "MM shouldnt call the plays" thread that NO ONE replied to and laughed off as absurdity...

                              ???

                              Over and over again ... I'm sure it's all coincidental.


                              I'm one that agrees with ya Mission... its redundant horshit week in, week out

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X