Give me Andy Reid over Mike Holmgren

[sheepshead]

any day of the week. I have never been a big Holmy fan, I think Andy will go down in history as a much better coach. Mike seems to be a better family man and for that he has my respect.

By the way, I think we saw some great coaching jobs over the weekend and that was the difference on our team this year. Not the General Manager.

[bobblehead]

Re: Give me Andy Reid over Mike Holmgren

any day of the week. I have never been a big Holmy fan, I think Andy will go down in history as a much better coach. Mike seems to be a better family man and for that he has my respect.

By the way, I think we saw some great coaching jobs over the weekend and that was the difference on our team this year. Not the General Manager.

Both great coaches, but my watermark is often who does it with more than one team...Holmy has, Reid hasn't. Reid is also trying to equal Holmy with a 2nd superbowl appearance, and has yet to win one. He has also had a very good QB in McNabb this entire time (though probably overrated).

Who is better...I'll take Mike, but not by a lot.

[sheepshead]

Im not a Holmgren fan for a number of reasons and Ol Andy has done a hell of a job this year. I'm pullin' for him.

[Brando19]

You do know Holmgren retired and his team isn't in the playoffs, don't you? What's the reason for this thread again?

[sheepshead]

You do know Holmgren retired and his team isn't in the playoffs, don't you? What's the reason for this thread again?

hmmmm...huh...what?

[GrnBay007]

What's the reason for this thread again?

Probably just an opinion. All are welcome I would hope.

[sheepshead]

You do know Holmgren retired and his team isn't in the playoffs, don't you? What's the reason for this thread again?

Not much of a football fan huh?

[LEWCWA]

Holmy has been to 3 superbowls.

[sepporepi]

Holmy has been to 3 superbowls.

And lost two...

[MacCool606]

I always thought Holmgren was better when he was young and hungry. Once he tasted success, he became more ego. So, I would take a younger Holmgren over Reid. Compared right now, I would take Reid.

[denverYooper]

I always thought Holmgren was better when he was young and hungry. Once he tasted success, he became more ego. So, I would take a younger Holmgren over Reid. Compared right now, I would take Reid.

Neither of those guys look particularly hungry .

[cpk1994]

Holmy has been to 3 superbowls.

And lost two...

But Holmy has a ring as HC. Reid doesn't.

[MacCool606]

Holmy should have had 2 - he let his want for the Seattle job get in the way of preparation for the 2nd.

[Fritz]

Sigh. Denver just went through the GB defense like it was butter on a summer's day.

I hate that.

[hurleyfan]

Holmy should have had 2 - he let his want for the Seattle job get in the way of preparation for the 2nd.

He let his ego get in the way!

The Packers were running & passing with great success in the first half, and Holmy pretty much abandoned the run in the 2nd half.. IMO