Who would you take? Charles Rogers or Mike Williams??

[Partial]

It's really up to the Lions though. I think either of them would fit good in to our system and I think that we would benefit fron either of them.

I think it's really a moot point since you don't cut two top 10 picks. Especially after such a short period of time, with such a horrible coaching staff in the previous regime. They can throw all the idle threats out there, but come opening day, there first 3 receivers will be williams, williams and rodgers.

[Zool]

Scotty Vines has made enough of a name for himself that he will be in that top 4 mix. He's not spectacular, but he's consistant.

[Spaulding]

Gotta go with Rodgers. He was amazing at Michigan State and before he got injured. I've gotta believe as others have posted it's been a combination of maturity and coaching issues. If he gets past those and somehow stays healthy then he could be a legit #1 receiver. Given the fact that they have upgraded at QB and have Martz calling the plays I think his value will rocket and thus this may be the last chance to buy low.

Williams is lazy and slow. Short of playing jump ball in the redzone I don't see how he went so high in the draft. Not a player I'd want as a Packer.

I honestly like our receiving corps for this year and think we'll be fine in that area. No big studs but Mr. Consistency in Driver, some upside in Gardner, a hungry and good sized Boerichter (sp?), a budding starter and gifted player in Jennings, and a last shot Ferguson.

The WR's don't matter much if we can't run the ball as it will be another repeat of last year with possibly slightly better results due to depth but nothing to write home about.

I'm holding my breath until I see where the line stands by the third game of preseason and if Green has fully rehabbed.

[Dabaddestbear]

Rodgers.
MW is not only unwilling to listen to the coaches but he also is constantly out of shape and seems to be gaining weight. He has been less fit then he was in college. I thought it would be the other way around once he made it to the NFL. Every time I read about this guy in the Detroit press its all bad. But his ego doesnt suprise me since when he was first drafted he was promoting hiself as HOF bound on his website.

I have to admit I wanted the Bears to pick up MW in the worst way and wanted to blast the GM for not doing so. But that just goes to show that that is the reason why we are fans and they are the GM's.

[wist43]

There's still hope for Rogers, but I would have no interest in Williams. I didn't even view him as a 1st round pick the year he came out, and knew the Lions blew the pick when they took him at #10. I only saw him as a mid-late round pick.