Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

More Banjo - Packers vs Vikings

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #46
    That picture may actually represent a singular defensive play call, yet it IS emblamatic of the Packers' offensive line woes this year. There are SIX defenders BEHIND the Packers' line of scrimmage. Dang. You'd almost have to try to be that bad.

    Part of what's frustrating is that if this line were even mediocre, this team could contend. It's frustrating because you've got Love in his prime, Golden and Watson in theirs, the best Packer defense we've seen in a few years, and that's pre-Parsons return, and, well, okay, kinda lousy kicking game and otherwise "meh" special teams.Still, you've got lots of pieces in place, but without a functional offensive line, you've got nothing.
    "The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."

    KYPack

    Comment


    • #47
      I would argue that every game we lost this year falls on the OL and/or officiating. Every single loss.
      The only time success comes before work is in the dictionary -- Vince Lombardi

      Comment


      • #48
        Originally posted by bobblehead View Post
        I would argue that every game we lost this year falls on the OL and/or officiating. Every single loss.
        no argument from me on that

        I think MIN is a bad matchup for GB - their bonkers pressures are unorthodox and break a lot of common OL blocking rules. MLF had a poor game plan. The players didn't talk and they didn't execute their blocks. All year they've had iffy footwork and poor hands (catching with arms outside instead of shooting them inside). Watch the run blocking this year and who resets the LOS - it's almost always the DL. Either they have tuned out the OL coaching or they aren't getting that coaching. Unfortunately it's supposedly really really hard to fix or teach fundamentals and technique in-season, and playing musical chairs with your lineup doesn't help either.

        I think Bill Huber called it an "organizational failure" and I think he's absolutely correct. From the talent to the coaching to the planning and then the execution it's bad.
        This is what they are. The fatal flaw of the 2026-27 GB is their OL.

        I do think Gute and Co. will gut and rebuild it this offseason, RB room included. Not sure what their cap will look like after cuts and extensions, but I'm assuming most of the help will either be through the draft or cheap vets who are replacement level. I hope MLF ditches Butkus and gets coaches who can develop players.

        Comment


        • #49
          Originally posted by bobblehead View Post

          There has been no point in Banks career that he has played up to this contract.
          I really don't care how much or how little a player makes. Either he plays well enough to be on the field, or he doesn't. His pay is irrelevant. I have never thought, "He's fine if he is paid $5M on a 1-year contract, but he stinks at $77M/4yrs."

          Besides, injuries don't care how much you are paid.

          Contract value matters in evaluating the front office, not the player.

          Comment


          • #50
            That's just wrongheaded, Patler. Two things about the $77 million or whatever for Banks: 1. It's money that coulda been spent for somebody else or several somebodys. Ya'all that get so hyper about the damn salary cap oughta realize that. 2. As I said, Banks has played so few games, and the team has not been noticeably worse the many times he hasn't played - which goes to the idea I keep repeating that the whole position group is low priority and very seldom correlates to wins and losses. The two Vikings losses might be exceptions to that, although I'd argue that officiating in the first one and turnovers in the second were bigger factors.
            What could be more GOOD and NORMAL and AMERICAN than Packer Football?

            Comment


            • #51
              Originally posted by Patler View Post
              Is Zeitler any more valuable to the Packers than Banks? He can't get on the field either. Six weeks, and virtually nothing from him. Another few million $ thrown out the window.

              YES HE IS

              How many games has Banks been available over the past 26 weeks ? And Zeitler ?

              There are times when I think the coaches were choosing not to play Zeitler. Which is indefensitble.

              How much have we paid Banks for the past 2 years ? CRAZY
              TERD Buckley over Troy Vincent, Robert Ferguson over Chris Chambers, Kevn King instead of TJ Watt, and now, RICH GANNON, over JIMMY JIMMY JIMMY LEONARD. Thank you FLOWER

              Comment


              • #52
                Zeitler has contributed virtually nothing, 20 snaps on offense in six weeks or whatever.

                Comment


                • #53
                  NFL Network has the game on.
                  I can't run no more with that lawless crowd
                  While the killers in high places say their prayers out loud
                  But they've summoned, they've summoned up a thundercloud
                  They're going to hear from me - Leonard Cohen

                  Comment


                  • #54
                    Originally posted by run pMc View Post

                    no argument from me on that

                    I think MIN is a bad matchup for GB - their bonkers pressures are unorthodox and break a lot of common OL blocking rules. MLF had a poor game plan. The players didn't talk and they didn't execute their blocks. All year they've had iffy footwork and poor hands (catching with arms outside instead of shooting them inside). Watch the run blocking this year and who resets the LOS - it's almost always the DL. Either they have tuned out the OL coaching or they aren't getting that coaching. Unfortunately it's supposedly really really hard to fix or teach fundamentals and technique in-season, and playing musical chairs with your lineup doesn't help either.

                    I think Bill Huber called it an "organizational failure" and I think he's absolutely correct. From the talent to the coaching to the planning and then the execution it's bad.
                    This is what they are. The fatal flaw of the 2026-27 GB is their OL.

                    I do think Gute and Co. will gut and rebuild it this offseason, RB room included. Not sure what their cap will look like after cuts and extensions, but I'm assuming most of the help will either be through the draft or cheap vets who are replacement level. I hope MLF ditches Butkus and gets coaches who can develop players.
                    Here's the problem as I see it with the above statement: Of all the positions to rebuild, the offensive line might be the hardest one to do on the fly. Other position groups require, first, fewer players (you have only two starting corners, maybe three. You have only three defensive linemen starting. You have two or three wide receivers starting. So in those position groups, not to mention, say, the running back room or the tight end room or the kicker room, where there is usually only one starter on the field at a time, you can rebuild more easily, just because you have fewer numbers. But the offensive line is five starters, four of whom are highly suspect as starters next year (I'm excluding Jordan Morgan, though maybe I should not). So first, you have more bodies to replace. Secondly, offensive linemen, as I understand the position, take longer to develop at the NFL level. It's a complex league with complex offensive line calls, plus the fundamentals that have to be taught or re-taught. In other words, it's a steep learning curve.

                    So on a team that is already tight under the cap, how do you rebuild an offensive line group in one off-season? Can you reasonably expect to bring in, say, four new offensive line rookies and think that between them and Jager Burton, all will be fixed? I think most of us understand that the odds of ZBB's returning to pre-injury levels of play is highly unlikely; in fact, he might never play again, or he might go David Bakhtieri and be yes-no-yes-no until he retires.

                    This is a problem that I can see stretching into next season, no matter what they do.
                    "The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."

                    KYPack

                    Comment


                    • #55
                      Originally posted by Patler View Post
                      Zeitler has contributed virtually nothing, 20 snaps on offense in six weeks or whatever.
                      Quite right. Simple math here.

                      Zeitler: one part-time game, $4.3 million dollars. $4.3 mil per game. (don't go check Pro Football Reference, no one gets paid this money for ST snaps)

                      Aaron Banks: 20 games, $77 million dollars: $3.85 mil per game.

                      Obviously Banks is the better deal. Not too mention that his $77 million gets you more of the Banksian experience for the next two years, so in the end he's almost paying the Packers to play, unlike that teat suckler Zeitler.

                      ::: we need the emojis back to convey the seriousness of this post :::
                      Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

                      Comment


                      • #56
                        Originally posted by texaspackerbacker View Post
                        That's just wrongheaded, Patler. Two things about the $77 million or whatever for Banks: 1. It's money that coulda been spent for somebody else or several somebodys. Ya'all that get so hyper about the damn salary cap oughta realize that. 2. As I said, Banks has played so few games, and the team has not been noticeably worse the many times he hasn't played - which goes to the idea I keep repeating that the whole position group is low priority and very seldom correlates to wins and losses. The two Vikings losses might be exceptions to that, although I'd argue that officiating in the first one and turnovers in the second were bigger factors.
                        If you read Patler's post, he isn't discussing the roster construction, playing time or GM decisions on contracts.

                        He says he's talking about the player, available or not.
                        Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

                        Comment


                        • #57
                          Did you read this, pbmax? [I really don't care how much or how little a player makes. Either he plays well enough to be on the field, or he doesn't. His pay is irrelevant. I have never thought, "He's fine if he is paid $5M on a 1-year contract, but he stinks at $77M/4yrs."] That's just plain wrong.

                          Ya'all who like to dwell on the salary cap so much should be at the head of the line saying the massive amount of pay IS relevant. If we'd picked up Banks for $5 million, both the few times he's played as well as his mediocrity when he did would be a helluva lot less relevant than for $77 million which arguably prevents the team from having $77 million worth of good players.
                          What could be more GOOD and NORMAL and AMERICAN than Packer Football?

                          Comment


                          • #58
                            Originally posted by texaspackerbacker View Post
                            Did you read this, pbmax? [I really don't care how much or how little a player makes. Either he plays well enough to be on the field, or he doesn't. His pay is irrelevant. I have never thought, "He's fine if he is paid $5M on a 1-year contract, but he stinks at $77M/4yrs."] That's just plain wrong.

                            Ya'all who like to dwell on the salary cap so much should be at the head of the line saying the massive amount of pay IS relevant. If we'd picked up Banks for $5 million, both the few times he's played as well as his mediocrity when he did would be a helluva lot less relevant than for $77 million which arguably prevents the team from having $77 million worth of good players.
                            I really don't care how much or how little a player makes. Either he plays well enough to be on the field, or he doesn't.​

                            Did you read this part Tex? He's talking about the players availability. Not the contract.

                            For those who didn't follow it he followed he explicitly stated it in another two lines.

                            To him, the pay is irrelevant when evaluating the player's year. It would be relevant for the GM when constructing the roster in the offseason.

                            The cap is important for building a team for the year. But Patler doesn't like using it to discuss the performance of the player in-season.
                            Last edited by pbmax; 11-20-2026, 09:33 AM.
                            Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

                            Comment


                            • #59
                              I agree the contract is useful for determining the front office. That is to say, given the contract, compared to the league average did they get excess value for that player? It's a performance per $ kind of thing, I suspect they have internal metrics for that.

                              Availability 100% factors into the value - you can't perform if you aren't on the field.
                              Poor performance when you are available is also an issue, but at least that can be measured.

                              I think for fans the contract is important because it sets expectations of how that player will perform. Banks has not come close to meeting those expectations, performance or availability-wise. Fans will also use hindsight to point out opportunity cost in terms of what they should have spent on the contract or who they could have signed instead.

                              Like just about everyone, I thought the Banks contract was a big overpay but at this point the ink on it is dry and if I'd like to see him healthy and playing well for GB. (Wishful thinking I know)

                              Comment


                              • #60
                                Originally posted by Fritz View Post

                                Here's the problem as I see it with the above statement: Of all the positions to rebuild, the offensive line might be the hardest one to do on the fly. Other position groups require, first, fewer players (you have only two starting corners, maybe three. You have only three defensive linemen starting. You have two or three wide receivers starting. So in those position groups, not to mention, say, the running back room or the tight end room or the kicker room, where there is usually only one starter on the field at a time, you can rebuild more easily, just because you have fewer numbers. But the offensive line is five starters, four of whom are highly suspect as starters next year (I'm excluding Jordan Morgan, though maybe I should not). So first, you have more bodies to replace. Secondly, offensive linemen, as I understand the position, take longer to develop at the NFL level. It's a complex league with complex offensive line calls, plus the fundamentals that have to be taught or re-taught. In other words, it's a steep learning curve.

                                So on a team that is already tight under the cap, how do you rebuild an offensive line group in one off-season? Can you reasonably expect to bring in, say, four new offensive line rookies and think that between them and Jager Burton, all will be fixed? I think most of us understand that the odds of ZBB's returning to pre-injury levels of play is highly unlikely; in fact, he might never play again, or he might go David Bakhtieri and be yes-no-yes-no until he retires.

                                This is a problem that I can see stretching into next season, no matter what they do.
                                Yeah, agree rebuilding an OL in one offseason is a tall order. I think Rhyan, Morgan and maybe Burton could be pieces to work with. Who knows with Banks, I have to think he's gone as a June 1 cut. ZBB might end up retiring or playing C if he can't move like he used to. Belton needs a lot of coaching. So you're probably looking at 2-3 players. Maybe you bring Tomlinson back as a depth piece, but he's not a starter.

                                I initially liked Monk's college tape but now I think he's too small to be anything but a backup at C. I don't think much of Glover. Jennings is not worth keeping around except maybe as a camp body.

                                Chicago brought in Drew Dalman, Joe Thuney and Jonah Jackson in one offseason and drafted Izzy Trapillo. GB is going to be up against the cap, and after cuts (Jacobs, Banks, Hargrave, ???) and extensions (Williams, Bullard, Cooper?) who knows what things look like for cap space. They will definitely make some moves to shore up the OL, and if it is through the draft then they better get a new OL coach who can develop them.

                                I agree with you on that being a problem - I don't think you can roll out a line Week 1 with 2 rookies. You might be able to bring them along mid-season, but ideally you play them year 2, after they've had a full year in the system and time in a pro strength program.

                                Some people who are smarter than me claim they are in a window that closes after next season because Love's and Parson's cap numbers skyrocket. Maybe the cap does too, who knows, but having the 30th or 32nd ranked OL is not a recipe for success. If they can find a way to get to league average OL play and avoid injuries they have enough talent elsewhere to be a SB contender.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X