Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Who Is MOST Responsible for the O-Line Mess?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Who Is MOST Responsible for the O-Line Mess?

    Let's play the blame game! Come on, it's the bye week and the Packers just lost! And, unless you're living in Tex's alternate universe, it's primarily on the offensive line.

    According to this article, there's plenty of blame to go around (of course), but this writer, Freddie Boston, drops most of it on Guter. Here are the major mistakes the author outlines:

    1. Bobble's favorite: drafting Josh Myers over Creed Humphrey
    2.Drafting Jordan Morgan instead of Graham Barton (remembering that some thought Morgan was best-suited to play guard and that's what some thought the Packers had in mind)
    3. Adding no offensive linemen in the 2023 draft
    4. Signing Aaron Banks, then doublin down this past offseason
    5. Drafting Travis Glover over Christian Mahogany (who is not a starting guard on the Detroit Lions, and playing, well, a lot better than Travis Glover!)
    6. Drafting Anthony Belton over Tate Ratledge, who was picked three picks after Belton, and is now the starting guard for, yes, the Detroit Lions

    That's a series of unfortunate mistakes, Guter.

    Eight critical decisions that Brian Gutekunst and Matt LaFleur got wrong, and how they're impacting the Packers' offensive line.
    "The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."

    KYPack

  • #2
    WTF? Buttkiss isn't one of those options? He's actually number ONE!!!

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by SudsMcBucky View Post
      WTF? Buttkiss isn't one of those options? He's actually number ONE!!!
      The article lists 8 mistakes. Mistakes 5 and 6 involve Butkus. Fritz only listed the 6 that would be considered Gute's fault.

      5. Hiring Luke Butkus


      After promoting Adam Stenavich to offensive coordinator in 2022, Matt LaFleur hired Luke Butkus to become his new offensive line coach. Butkus had been Stenavich's assistant for three seasons, but his only experience as an offensive line coach was with Illinois.
      ​
      6. Retaining Luke Butkus, not offering James Campen the job


      Hiring Butkus is one thing, but even more frustrating is LaFleur's decision to stick with him. It's an all-too-familiar problem throughout LaFleur's tenure. He kept Joe Barry at least one year too long, which is probably being generous. He retained Rich Bisaccia despite the special teams struggles, and it took Bisaccia resigning to force LaFleur into a change.
      ​
      It's easy to forget some of the offensive line woes from 2025. Pass protection wasn't nearly as dire as this year, but the run blocking wasn't much better – Jacobs' ability to add yards after contact masked many of the problems.

      Back in January, many, including T.J. Lang, called for LaFleur to hire former Packers offensive line coach James Campen.

      It made sense. Campen had spent time with the Packers' personnel department in recent years, so he presumably had a relationship with LaFleur. Instead, Mike McCarthy hired Campen for the role in Pittsburgh, where he's made an impact.
      ​
      The Steelers' offensive line has played at a high level this season. It's hard to compare and put it all on the coaches, as they have different personnel and schemes. But it's not exactly a hot take to say Campen would get far more out of the Packers' players. He has a proven track record with tons of NFL experience.
      I can't run no more with that lawless crowd
      While the killers in high places say their prayers out loud
      But they've summoned, they've summoned up a thundercloud
      They're going to hear from me - Leonard Cohen

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Fritz View Post
        Let's play the blame game! Come on, it's the bye week and the Packers just lost! And, unless you're living in Tex's alternate universe, it's primarily on the offensive line.

        According to this article, there's plenty of blame to go around (of course), but this writer, Freddie Boston, drops most of it on Guter. Here are the major mistakes the author outlines:

        1. Bobble's favorite: drafting Josh Myers over Creed Humphrey
        2.Drafting Jordan Morgan instead of Graham Barton (remembering that some thought Morgan was best-suited to play guard and that's what some thought the Packers had in mind)
        3. Adding no offensive linemen in the 2023 draft
        4. Signing Aaron Banks, then doublin down this past offseason
        5. Drafting Travis Glover over Christian Mahogany (who is not a starting guard on the Detroit Lions, and playing, well, a lot better than Travis Glover!)
        6. Drafting Anthony Belton over Tate Ratledge, who was picked three picks after Belton, and is now the starting guard for, yes, the Detroit Lions

        That's a series of unfortunate mistakes, Guter.

        https://lombardiave.com/8-brian-gute...sive-line-woes
        I can't take sole credit for the Humphrey draft, I think 90% of the board scratched their head. I actually said I understood what Gutes was thinking in getting a guy who can block the 2nd level (I disagreed with it strongly though).

        I liked the Morgan pick sort of. I wanted him with our 2nd in that super deep LT draft. But yes, if you wanted a RG Barton was the easy pick. Mainly I wanted DeJean with that pick.

        Banks is an unmitigated disaster. Nothing else to say. And the Belton pick was similar to the Banks signing. An over reaction to getting pushed around by Philly's massive OL and trying to duplicate it. Belton can be good if he takes his job seriously in the off season and improves his play strength.

        I have settled on Stenovich who seems to be at the heart of every bad decision (based on his comments). From benching Yosh on the eve of the playoffs TWICE after solid performances to constantly putting guys in positions they haven't had enough practice at (because we were "cross training" so no one had enough time at one position...that part is on gutes). But even now, I like Williams, but I have a hard time believing he is the better call at center after a handful of camp snaps over Burton who played a lot of center in college and is an interior guy. Its a testament to Williams that he isn't a complete tire fire.
        The only time success comes before work is in the dictionary -- Vince Lombardi

        Comment


        • #5
          I think Gute is certainly responsible for the decreased talent on the offensive line. When he became GM Packers had Corey Linsley, David Bakhtiari, Bryan Bulaga and Lane Taylor. ZBB is the only guy Gute has brought in who would be considered comparable to those guys. However, the level of dysfunction on this year's offensive line has to point to coaching. I think that applies both to players knowing their assignments, and coaches assigning the right players to the right positions. I think they need a coaching change. They don't have the cap space or the draft capital to completely overhaul the offensive line all at once. They need coaches who can get more than what they are currently getting out of some of the players they have.
          I can't run no more with that lawless crowd
          While the killers in high places say their prayers out loud
          But they've summoned, they've summoned up a thundercloud
          They're going to hear from me - Leonard Cohen

          Comment


          • #6
            eh, IDK about some of these. This article reads like an angry fanboy on a barstool somewhere.

            Humphrey over Myers? I'll give him that. Humphrey was the clear top C and they got cute there. The Glover and Belton picks are a little murkier. I mean, I wanted Terry McLaurin over Jace Sternberger, blah blah blah. Everything seems obvious in hindsight. I will say the Glover pick was weird to me because he wasn't the typical RAS warrior, but as a developmental big body, sure.

            The Banks signing was bad then & now. He played something like 80% of the snaps for SF, so he had injury history already. They paid him what they thought he would be worth, not was he actually was worth. Injuries and failure to reach that projected ceiling make that signing look terrible. Rightfully so.

            Hiring Butkus is meh, keeping him is the bigger issue IMO. Yes, the talent has declined, but I'd also say the talent to replace who has left hasn't been coached up or developed. Jordan Morgan is ok, I'm fine with them taking a LT. If they hadn't drafted Morgan or Belton, who plays T?

            Then there's how they are being used within the offense - what they are asked to do. Can they execute a reach block? What do they do well, and what don't they do? Don't ask them to sustain pass blocks for a long time against an unpredictable blitz heavy defense.

            I put most of the issues on the Coaches 40%, then the Players 30%, then Gute 30%. The coaches have to coach better, and the players have to execute the plays. Gute has to restock the OL room - it can be done in one off season. Chicago did it by signing Dalman, and trading for Thuney and Jackson. The cap will limit what they can do, so the coaching/player development part of it is going to be crucial - I expect them to draft a couple of OL plus a RB to replace Jacobs/Lloyd.

            Comment

            Working...
            X