Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Who Is MOST Responsible for the O-Line Mess?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    I have a new answer: the Docs.

    The one's who apparently didn't say, this guy Banks ligaments are made of rusty tinfoil judged by the time he has missed.

    Also the one's who may not have been honest about the odds a partial patella tendon tear becomes a full tear.
    Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

    Comment


    • #17
      Nelson had a known knee issue that would require surgery. The hope was that he would get through the season and take care of it in the off season. Well... he played one game for Seattle, aggravated it to the point that he had the procedure immediately. The hope is that he will miss only a month, but who knows?

      I'm glad the Packers didn't roll the dice on that one.

      Comment


      • #18
        Who is to blame?

        The line looks like a total mess; confused, ill-prepared and playing with bad technique. That's coaching. Nothing to do with the GM. A number of players have not developed. Again, coaching.

        BUT...the fact that the roster had recognized holes, with no answers, just hopes; that's on Gute. The fact that many players do not seem to have the raw talent expected for where they were drafted or to justify the contracts they received; that's on Gute.

        Both having screwed up results in a line that is performing about as badly as any I have ever seen in GB.

        Comment


        • #19
          [QUOTE=Patler;n1670483]Who is to blame?

          The line looks like a total mess; confused, ill-prepared and playing with bad technique. That's coaching. Nothing to do with the GM. A number of players have not developed. Again, coaching.
          __________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________________________

          Very true, yet we have a winning record anyway, and we shoulda won at least a couple of the four we lost but for rotten officiating, turnovers, and questionable playcalling. As I've said repeatedly, O Line play doesn't have much relevance or correlation to winning games.
          What could be more GOOD and NORMAL and AMERICAN than Packer Football?

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by Patler View Post
            Who is to blame?

            The line looks like a total mess; confused, ill-prepared and playing with bad technique. That's coaching. Nothing to do with the GM. A number of players have not developed. Again, coaching.

            BUT...the fact that the roster had recognized holes, with no answers, just hopes; that's on Gute. The fact that many players do not seem to have the raw talent expected for where they were drafted or to justify the contracts they received; that's on Gute.

            Both having screwed up results in a line that is performing about as badly as any I have ever seen in GB.
            At this point it almost seems like a lost cause. They couldn't run their offseason stuff with what was left of the preferred opening day starters.

            They improved pass blocking but that was interrupted by the Rhyan injury.

            With neither Banks nor Zeitler starting, the run game has suffered with Glover in there.

            They are trying a LOT of different run plays (different systems: zone, split duo, counters, power) and that doesn't help reliability.

            And that kind of flux was there on day one. Its definitely on the coaches to solve it, but Gute left them WAY short of sensible answers. This line at times wouldn't pass muster for a rebuilding team.
            Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

            Comment


            • #21
              Well, it looks like we've got it covered: there's blame enough to go around for everyone. Coaches, the players, Guter, the docs. I personally also fault Tex, as I suspect that some smart-ass mole inside the organization was reading Packerrats and came across Tex's offensive-line-don't-mean-shit posts and decided to test that theory.
              "The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."

              KYPack

              Comment


              • #22
                That's a round-about way of saying that Gutekunst or whoever pretty much agrees with me - that O Line is a low priority and does not correlate very much with winning games. Thanks for that realization, Fritz.
                What could be more GOOD and NORMAL and AMERICAN than Packer Football?

                Comment


                • #23
                  Originally posted by texaspackerbacker View Post
                  That's a round-about way of saying that Gutekunst or whoever pretty much agrees with me - that O Line is a low priority and does not correlate very much with winning games. Thanks for that realization, Fritz.
                  Don't insult yourself Tex.

                  If you are tying your mojo, to Gutebag agrees with me than you are clearly a dumbassss too ))
                  TERD Buckley over Troy Vincent, Robert Ferguson over Chris Chambers, Kevn King instead of TJ Watt, and now, RICH GANNON, over JIMMY JIMMY JIMMY LEONARD. Thank you FLOWER

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    The idea that Gutekunst hasn't prioritized the offensive line just doesn't hold up when you actually look at his nine-year ledger (2018–2026). There is plenty to hammer this front office for regarding the state of the line right now, but "neglect" isn't it.
                    If you weigh all three investment channels—Day 1–2 draft capital, external free-agent dollars, and major internal extensions—across all 11 positional groups, Offensive Line ranks #3 overall in Gutekunst's entire tenure.

                    Where OL Actually Sits in Gute's Resource Hierarchy (2018–2026):
                    1. EDGE — Runaway #1 (Gary and Van Ness in the top 15, the 2019 Smith signings, plus two 1st-rounders and $188M for Micah Parsons).
                    2. QB — #2 (the Round 1 trade-up for Love plus top-of-market contracts for both Rodgers and Love).
                    3. Offensive Line — #3. Ahead of WR, CB, LB, Safety, IDL, TE, and RB.


                    The OL Receipts:
                    • High-end draft capital: Five Day 1–2 picks — Jordan Morgan (Rd 1, '24), Elgton Jenkins (Rd 2, '19), Josh Myers (Rd 2, '21), Anthony Belton (Rd 2, '25), and Sean Rhyan (Rd 3, '22).
                    • Relentless Day 3 volume: Zach Tom, Rasheed Walker, Jon Runyan Jr., Jager Burton, John Williams, and a stack of other mid-to-late swings.
                    • Real cash (both FA and extensions): Billy Turner in 2019, Elgton Jenkins' extension, Zach Tom's $88M deal, and a massive 4-year, $77M external swing on Aaron Banks in 2025—on top of scrambling in-season this year for Laken Tomlinson, Kevin Zeitler, and Mekhi Becton.


                    Compare that to positions Gute actually treated as secondary priorities for years:
                    • Interior DL: Spent exactly one Day 1–2 pick across eight drafts (Devonte Wyatt) while leaning on Kenny Clark, until finally resetting this year with Javon Hargrave and Chris McClellan.
                    • Wide Receiver (early tenure): Spent a single Day 2 pick from 2018–2021 (Amari Rodgers) before finally pivoting hard with Watson, Reed, Golden, and Savion Williams.
                    • Cornerback (mid-tenure): Went completely dry in the draft for three straight years after Eric Stokes, leaving a cliff that forced the disastrous $48M Nate Hobbs patch before taking Brandon Cisse this year.


                    So why does the line look like a train wreck?
                    Because prioritization and ROI are two completely different things. Two things are simultaneously true here:
                    1. Five starting spots dilute the spend. Only spending one 1st-rounder in nine drafts (Morgan) means five starting jobs chew through Day 2/3 capital and cap space fast, leaving very little margin for error.
                    2. The hit rate on his biggest swings has cratered. Releasing Jenkins, watching the $77M Aaron Banks signing backfire, letting Myers walk after one contract, and burning top-60 picks on Morgan and Belton without locking down stable interior play isn't a lack of investment—it's an evaluation and execution failure.


                    Saying Gute didn't prioritize the OL actually lets the front office off the hook. If they had ignored the line, the fix would be simple: start spending picks and cash on it. They already did—to the tune of the #3 resource allocation on the entire roster—and still ended up patching the trenches midseason off the street. That's a much bigger indictment than neglect.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by sharpe1027 View Post
                      The idea that Gutekunst hasn't prioritized the offensive line just doesn't hold up when you actually look at his nine-year ledger (2018–2026). There is plenty to hammer this front office for regarding the state of the line right now, but "neglect" isn't it.
                      If you weigh all three investment channels—Day 1–2 draft capital, external free-agent dollars, and major internal extensions—across all 11 positional groups, Offensive Line ranks #3 overall in Gutekunst's entire tenure.

                      ...
                      That's a fantastic breakdown Sharpe. My only minor quibble is that draft round is approximate at best for choices. They are also looking for value there which accounts for DEs who can rush the passer (still a weird blind spot for the team until maybe recently) and the reason for only 1 first round OT pick.

                      My preference would be to switch back to Ted mode for a bit, assuming the talent is distributed the same. Grab WR and CBs late looking for pure athleticism. Spend some higher day 3 picks (3-4 round) on a few more O lineman instead of waiting until later. The caveat is that many teams might be doing this and it wouldn't uncover anything better.​
                      Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        If you weigh all three investment channels—Day 1–2 draft capital, external free-agent dollars, and major internal extensions—across all 11 positional groups, Offensive Line ranks #3 overall in Gutekunst's entire tenure.​
                        ​
                        This is why I feel like the coaching is the biggest issue. GB was known for taking Day2/3 guys and turning them into good starting OL more often than not. They no longer have that reputation. Either Gute is on an all time cold streak for acquiring OL talent or the coaches can't develop a single decent starter from their recent picks.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Originally posted by pbmax View Post

                          That's a fantastic breakdown Sharpe. My only minor quibble is that draft round is approximate at best for choices. They are also looking for value there which accounts for DEs who can rush the passer (still a weird blind spot for the team until maybe recently) and the reason for only 1 first round OT pick.

                          My preference would be to switch back to Ted mode for a bit, assuming the talent is distributed the same. Grab WR and CBs late looking for pure athleticism. Spend some higher day 3 picks (3-4 round) on a few more O lineman instead of waiting until later. The caveat is that many teams might be doing this and it wouldn't uncover anything better.​
                          Fair point—and a good catch on pick slots. Counting strictly by round definitely flattens the gap between top-15 selections (Gary at #12, Van Ness at #13) and the back half of Rounds 1–3 where most of Gute's OL picks have landed (Morgan in the mid-20s, Jenkins at #44, Belton at #54, Myers at #62). On a pure draft-chart basis, OL investment sits closer to middle-of-the-pack than elite; it's stacking the cash on top (Tom, Banks, Jenkins, Turner) that pushes the total resource allocation into the top three.
                          On the board-value point explaining only one R1 tackle, you're right that consistently picking in the 20s wipes out the blue-chip OTs, and refusing to reach for the 6th-best tackle at #28 is defensible. The counter cuts two ways, though:

                          Gute moves up when he genuinely prioritizes a slot. He traded up for Love, Savage, Watson, and McClellan, and sent two 1sts for Parsons. Staying put in the 20s and shopping Tier 2 tackles is still a strategic choice, not just bad luck with the board.

                          Dodging the R1 OT tax created a worse FA tax. Passing on top tackles to coach up Day 2/3 versatility is a smart market inefficiency only when you have good coaching and the scouting hits. When it misses, you end up paying a much uglier tax on the open market, like $77M for Aaron Banks, just to stop the bleeding.

                          Weighting by actual pick slot definitely sharpens the picture on how they've tried to play the margins up front.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Excellenty post, Sharpe. And excellent follow-up to PB's point.

                            Here's where Ted found his gold:
                            Josh Sitton Guard 2008 4th Round
                            T.J. Lang Guard / Tackle 2009 4th Round (109th)
                            David Bakhtiari Tackle 2013 4th Round (109th)
                            JC Tretter Center / Guard 2013 4th Round (122nd)
                            Corey Linsley Center 2014 5th Round (161st)
                            Bryan Bulaga Tackle 2010 1st Round (23rd
                            ​
                            Given that Green Bay has two fourth rounders in 2027, plus likely another one for Malik Willis, might I suggest that Gute channel his inner Ted this year? Spend your round two and three picks on other positions, and just pick three fourth-round linemen - maybe even guys who play tight end who you'll move inside to tackle, or guys who play tackle you'll move to guard - and go from there.

                            But you've got to channel your inner Ted to nail those fourth rounders. Especially if you're trying to find a starting tackle.
                            "The Devine era is actually worse than you remember if you go back and look at it."

                            KYPack

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Originally posted by Fritz View Post
                              Excellenty post, Sharpe. And excellent follow-up to PB's point.
                              AI did the legwork on the research.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Originally posted by Fritz View Post
                                Excellenty post, Sharpe. And excellent follow-up to PB's point.

                                Here's where Ted found his gold:
                                Josh Sitton Guard 2008 4th Round
                                T.J. Lang Guard / Tackle 2009 4th Round (109th)
                                David Bakhtiari Tackle 2013 4th Round (109th)
                                JC Tretter Center / Guard 2013 4th Round (122nd)
                                Corey Linsley Center 2014 5th Round (161st)
                                Bryan Bulaga Tackle 2010 1st Round (23rd
                                ​
                                Given that Green Bay has two fourth rounders in 2027, plus likely another one for Malik Willis, might I suggest that Gute channel his inner Ted this year? Spend your round two and three picks on other positions, and just pick three fourth-round linemen - maybe even guys who play tight end who you'll move inside to tackle, or guys who play tackle you'll move to guard - and go from there.

                                But you've got to channel your inner Ted to nail those fourth rounders. Especially if you're trying to find a starting tackle.
                                I do think they need to be careful in the draft. This year might be the year to overdraft a targeted position or player.

                                They don't have a ton of cap space to sign FA to plug holes, they are already very young, and they might need a RT candidate most of all from a talent standpoint depending on how they really feel about Williams or Becton.

                                But Becton's greatest success has been at Guard.
                                Bud Adams told me the franchise he admired the most was the Kansas City Chiefs. Then he asked for more hookers and blow.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X