All time Packers roster

[Bossman641]

Some new ones, and some nominations for replacing some already on the list:

#63 - Fuzzy Thurston over Adam Timmerman due to longevity, and Fuzzy's lifetime commitment to the Packers.

#23 - "The Roadrunner" Travis Williams for electrifying KO returns.

#16 - Scott Hunter (why not?)

#40 - Tom Brown deserves consideration

#21 - Bob Jeter over Craig Newsome (I don't think this is even a close call.)

#60 - John Anderson/Leroy Caffey

#89 - Dave Robinson over Mark Chmura (Again, not even close, in my opinion)

Is this list for the best player or the most memorable? We should probably nail down what this list is before deciding.

You guys can decide on that. I'd hope there's someone better than Derrick Frost to ever wear #6.

I was sort of thinking a combination of the 2, but I can see where that would lead to confusion and arguments.

I'm just listing everyone for now.

[mraynrand]

Didn't Herb Adderley wear #36

#43 Buckets Goldenberg (he also wore #31)

[Patler]

Some new ones, and some nominations for replacing some already on the list:

#63 - Fuzzy Thurston over Adam Timmerman due to longevity, and Fuzzy's lifetime commitment to the Packers.

#23 - "The Roadrunner" Travis Williams for electrifying KO returns.

#16 - Scott Hunter (why not?)

#40 - Tom Brown deserves consideration

#21 - Bob Jeter over Craig Newsome (I don't think this is even a close call.)

#60 - John Anderson/Leroy Caffey

#89 - Dave Robinson over Mark Chmura (Again, not even close, in my opinion)

Is this list for the best player or the most memorable? We should probably nail down what this list is before deciding.

Most of mine were on ability, except for my specific "memorable" nomination for Frost, and the lifetime award to Fuzzy T over Timmerman, who may have been better for his time. Brown/Eddie Lee Ivory I think is close. In my opinion, Jeter was a much better player than Newsome. and Robinson was much better than Chmura.

[mraynrand]

#27 Chuck Mercein or Terrel Buckley!

[Patler]

Didn't Herb Adderley wear #36

Not that I remember. Always 26 as I recall.

[Patler]

#68 - Gale Gillingham over Mike Wahle. Yet another one that I do not think is even a close call.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Yet another one that I do not think is even a close call.

Old timer.

[Bossman641]

OK let's go with best player to wear the number. I'm listing everyone suggested for now. Just tell me who to drop (bye Rubley, LeShon Johnson, and Frost)

1 - Curly Lambeau
2 -
3 - Tony Canadeo
4 - Brett Favre
5 - Paul Hornung
6 -
7 - Don Majikowski
8 - Ryan Longwell
9 -
10 - Jan Stenerud
11 -
12 - Lynn Dickey
13 - Chris Jacke
14 - Don Hutson
15 - Bart Starr
16 - Scott Hunter
17 - Craig Hentrich
18 - Doug Perderson
19 -
20 -
21 - Bob Jeter
22 - Mark Lee
23 - Travis Williams
24 - Willie Wood
25 - Dorsey Levens
26 - Herb Adderley
27 - Chuck Mercein/Terrell Buckley
28 - Willie Buchanon
29 -
30 - Ahman Green
31 - Jim Taylor
32 -
33 - William Henderson
34 - Edgar Bennett
35 -
36 - Leroy Butler
37 - Mark Murphy
38 -
39 -
40 - Eddie Lee Ivery/Tom Brown
41 -
42 - John Brockington/Darren Sharper
43 - Buckets Goldenberg
44 - Donny Anderson
45 -
46 -
47 -
48 -
49 -
50 - Johnny Holland
51 - Jim Ringo
52 - Frank Winters
53 - Fred Carr
54 - Larry McCarren
55 -
56 - Ted Hendricks
57 -
58 -
59 - Wayne Simmons
60 - John Anderson/Leroy Caffey
61 -
62 - Marco Rivera
63 - Fuzzy Thurston
64 - Jerry Kramer
65 - Mark Tauscher
66 - Ray Nitschke
67 -
68 - Gale Gillingham
69 - Bill Forrester
70 -
71 - Santana Dotson
72 - Earl Dotson
73 - Aaron Taylor
74 - Henry Jordan/Aaron Kampman
75 - Forrest Gregg
76 - Chad Clifton/Bob Skoronski
77 - Tony Mandarich
78 -
79 - Dave Roller
80 - James Lofton
81 - Desmond Howard
82 - Lionel Aldridge/Paul Coffman
83 - John Jefferson
84 - Sterling Sharpe
85 - Max Mcgee
86 - Boyd Dowler
87 - Willie Davis
88 - Keith Jackson
89 - Dave Robinson
90 - Ezra Johnson
91 - Brian Noble
92 - Reggie White
93 - Gilbert Brown
94 - KGB
95 - Bryce Paup
96 - Sean Jones
97 - Tim Harris
98 -
99 -

[Patler]

#69 - Bill Forrester. I remembered Forrester, but not his number, which I had to look up. Forrester was an All-Pro linebacker year after year in the late '50s and early '60s.

[Patler]

Yet another one that I do not think is even a close call.

Old timer.

I'm trying not to be, but someone has to stand up for the greats in the past that all the young fans have no memories of!

[Patler]

OK let's go with best player to wear the number. I'm listing everyone suggested for now. Just tell me who to drop (bye Rubley, LeShon Johnson, and Frost)

87 - Willie Davis/Robert Brooks

Bye, bye Robert! You don't stand up to a HOF'er!

[HarveyWallbangers]

21 - Craig Newsome/Bob Jeter

Jeter

42 - John Brockington/Leshon Johnson/Darren Sharper

Tough one. Everybody remembers Brockington because there wasn't much else to cheer on back in those days, but Sharper probably had a better Packers career.

60 - John Anderson/Leroy Caffey

No idea.

68 - Mike Wahle/Gale Gillingham

Gillingham

74 - Henry Jordan/Aaron Kampman

Jordan was a Hall of Famer, so it's hard to vote against him. Some people think he deserved the honor--while others felt he rode on the coat-tails of a great defense.

76 - Chad Clifton/Bob Skoronski

No idea. How many Pro Bowls did Skoronski make?

80 - James Lofton/Donald Driver

Lofton is a Hall of Famer, but Driver may have had a better Packers career. For right now, Lofton. When DD retires, he might edge him out.

82 - Lionel Aldridge/Paul Coffman

Not sure. I liked Coffman a lot.

87 - Willie Davis/Robert Brooks

Davis.

89 - Mark Chmura/Dave Robinson

Robinson.

94 - KGB/Bob Kuberski

KGB.

[oregonpackfan]

Couple other things I noticed in looking up player number and Packer Hall of Famers.

Who is Henry Jordan? I don't think I've ever heard him mentioned when talking about the Lombardi defenses.

Who was Henry Jordan??? It makes me sad that he is not better remembered.
Henry Jordan was to DTs what Willie Davis was to DEs in the 1960s.

Part of why he has been forgotten is probably because he died so young. Dropped dead at 42. I believe he was the first of the Lombardi era greats to die. A real shock at the time.

Henry Jordan also had a great sense of humor and was a locker room leader. I had the pleasure of attending a sports banquet with Henry as the featured speaker. The guy was fantastic.

He was one of Lombardi's "steals". Got him from the Browns for a fourth round draft choice, I think the first year Lombardi was in GB. Jordan was a "no body" who then went on to a HOF career.

[Patler]

42 - John Brockington/Leshon Johnson/Darren Sharper

Tough one. Everybody remembers Brockington because there wasn't much else to cheer on back in those days, but Sharper probably had a better Packers career.

I agree - a tough one. Brockington's candle didn't burn very long. I would have to go with Sharper

60 - John Anderson/Leroy Caffey

No idea.

I think they were somewhat the same player, but I have to go with Anderson.

74 - Henry Jordan/Aaron Kampman

Jordan was a Hall of Famer, so it's hard to vote against him. Some people think he deserved the honor--while others felt he rode on the coat-tails of a great defense.

Jordan made an awful lot of All-Pro teams during his time, so it is hard to go against him

76 - Chad Clifton/Bob Skoronski

No idea. How many Pro Bowls did Skoronski make?

I think only one, but the feeling at the time was that he was always deserving, but with Gregg a certainty at the other tackle Skoronski was overlooked. I consider Skoronski and Clifton as equals in pass protection, with Skoronski a better run blocker than Clifton, so my pick is Skoronski.

80 - James Lofton/Donald Driver

Lofton is a Hall of Famer, but Driver may have had a better Packers career. For right now, Lofton. When DD retires, he might edge him out.

I can't see Driver being considered a better player than Lofton, regardless of how his career ends.

82 - Lionel Aldridge/Paul Coffman

Not sure. I liked Coffman a lot.

I liked Aldridge, and thought he was under-appreciated on those teams; but I would probably have to pick Coffman based on performance. It is hard to compare a DE and a TE.

[cpk1994]

71 - Santana Dotson

EDIT: Oops Santa was already mentioned. How about:

2 Mason Crosby
11 Ty Detmer