Favre Retirement Idea

[scooterwfr]

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

[HarveyWallbangers]

Sounds great, but I doubt Thompson will want to push him. Favre's people might misread it as Thompson trying to push Favre out the door again. The Packers have made it clear that the door is open when Favre is ready to retire as a Packer, so I'd assume they'll wait for Favre to make the first move.

[Zool]

I get what Scooter is saying tho. Be the first to extend the olive branch. Its not a bad idea but who knows how it would be received.

[Gunakor]

Re: Favre Retirement Idea

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

I think it's better to avoid the Favre situation entirely, at least for the next few years. This isn't about football, so his being retired has nothing to do with it.

Furthermore, about the one day contract deal, it's not necessary nor important. His number will be retired and his name put in our Ring of Honor regardless of whether he signs another contract with the Packers. He will have his own section in the Packers HOF even if he never drops the grudge with Thompson. Anything that would have happened had he just stayed retired in 2008 is going to happen anyway. So I don't think pressing the issue on Thompson OR Favre is a good or necessary thing. I'd just let the chips fall as they may, let time heal the wounds, and celebrate when the time is right for both Favre and Thompson. That's what I think anyway.

[swede]

Re: Favre Retirement Idea

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

I think it's better to avoid the Favre situation entirely, at least for the next few years. This isn't about football, so his being retired has nothing to do with it.

Furthermore, about the one day contract deal, it's not necessary nor important. His number will be retired and his name put in our Ring of Honor regardless of whether he signs another contract with the Packers. He will have his own section in the Packers HOF even if he never drops the grudge with Thompson. Anything that would have happened had he just stayed retired in 2008 is going to happen anyway. So I don't think pressing the issue on Thompson OR Favre is a good or necessary thing. I'd just let the chips fall as they may, let time heal the wounds, and celebrate when the time is right for both Favre and Thompson. That's what I think anyway.

I absolutely agree.

Even a very sweet note to Favre from Mark Murphy saying, "Please know that when you are ready we would like to celebrate your retirement in a way that respects the fine accomplishments of your storied career. Let us know when you are ready to plan such an event." would read to the Favre Camp as "Hey Has-Been! You'll never play another down of football in the NFL so why don't you just grovel back and let us put a foot on your throat in front of 70,000 at Lambeau."

Better let this one lay a while.

[falco]

why would favre come retire as a packer again when it is clear he wants to keep the door open to playing next year if he so desires??

[pbmax]

Well, the hard feelings might reside on more than just the Favre family side. Thompson got hit last year. Campen had his name and story leaked for being a messenger. And Murphy was made to look like a fool for going down in the middle of the standoff and making the marketing deal offer.

I doubt McCarthy wants to get involved. Who else is left? Lee Remmel?

I do agree that a call now would give Favre less room to claim he is unloved later, since he is fond of getting calls from Green Bay. But I don't think anyone wants to touch this topic until he remains retired through a season.

Maybe we should just send Greg Bedard. Or Harlan.

[Maxie the Taxi]

pbmax, I disagree. I think the perfect goodwill ambassador to send to Kiln, Mississippi is Cleft Crusty. If Cleft can't mend fences, nobody can.

[Patler]

Re: Favre Retirement Idea

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

No reason at all for the Packers to stick their necks out again and give Favre another opportunity to smear the organization. There is nothing to be gained at this time. Let it sit at least a year. I would let it sit a couple years.

[sheepshead]

[cpk1994]

Re: Favre Retirement Idea

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

No reason at all for the Packers to stick their necks out again and give Favre another opportunity to smear the organization. There is nothing to be gained at this time. Let it sit at least a year. I would let it sit a couple years.

Besides, Favre is the one who should be making the first move anyway.

[Gunakor]

Re: Favre Retirement Idea

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

No reason at all for the Packers to stick their necks out again and give Favre another opportunity to smear the organization. There is nothing to be gained at this time. Let it sit at least a year. I would let it sit a couple years.

Besides, Favre is the one who should be making the first move anyway.

Well, Favre should be the one to make the initial phone call, yes. Ted Thompson is still the GM of the Packers. He's not retired. He has a job to do, and it doesn't involve pacifying Favre.

But as soon as Favre makes that phone call, I'd expect Thompson would give him his full attention. They'll decide together when to do this. It's not Favre owes us this or Favre owes us that, then we'll talk. Nothing like that.

The first move, as you say, is nothing but a simple phone call.

[The Shadow]

Re: Favre Retirement Idea

[quote="Gunakor"]

So, I don't post out here at all... I tend to just do a lot of reading at work but what do you all think of this?

In light of Favre's release, if I was Ted Thompson or Mark Murphy, I would be on the line with Brett TODAY. Call him up, make amends, perhaps discuss the previous endorsement offers, and sign him to a one day contract to retire as a Packer. Then they could retire his number on opening day, Sunday Night Football, Lambeau Field, against Chicago.

I can't think of a better scenario. I know it may be early, and he may need more time... but if he is truly DONE, why not??

Sorry for the Favre talk, I know we are all sick of it, but thought this was interesting. Thoughts?

I think it's better to avoid the Favre situation entirely, at least for the next few years. This isn't about football, so his being retired has nothing to do with it.

Furthermore, about the one day contract deal, it's not necessary nor important. His number will be retired and his name put in our Ring of Honor regardless of whether he signs another contract with the Packers. He will have his own section in the Packers HOF even if he never drops the grudge with Thompson. Anything that would have happened had he just stayed retired in 2008 is going to happen anyway. So I don't think pressing the issue on Thompson OR Favre is a good or necessary thing. I'd just let the chips fall as they may, let time heal the wounds, and celebrate when the time is right for both Favre and Thompson. That's what I think anyway.[/quote]

I agree.
Personally however, I am in no hurry anyway to see Favre anywhere near the Packers for some time. Moreover, in my humble opinion, I think it would demonstrate a degree of personal character growth for #4, after the selfish shenanigans, to be the one to extend the olive branch.

[Packnut]

Favre

There are times when it's just better to put some distance and space when hurt feelings are involved. No hurry. Some day when the time is right Brett will retire in the beloved Green&Gold.

[Joemailman]

I don't think the Packers organization needs any time. The only issue is whether Favre wants to do it now, or whether he needs more time. The potential problem with waiting is that it creates the perception that the wait is due to the rift between Favre and Thompson. Because of what happened last year, I think the sooner there is a reconciliation between Favre and the Packers, the better.