Better NFL QB Rankings

[SkinBasket]

ESPN's fantasy football preview lists the top 10 QBs as such:

Rank	Player	Yards	TDs
1.	Drew Brees	4827	30
2.	Tom Brady	4210	33
3.	Peyton Manning  4153	31
4.	Kurt Warner	4150	29
5.	Aaron Rodgers	4008	29
6.	Philip Rivers	3865	28
7.	Tony Romo	4001	28
8.	Matt Ryan	        3684	25
9.	Matt Schaub	3645	26
10.	Donovan McNabb	3749	22

If I was smarter I would make that look better.

[Scott Campbell]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

There is one conspicuous name missing from that list.

[Scott Campbell]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

[pbmax]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

There is one conspicuous name missing from that list.

Jeff Garcia?

[oregonpackfan]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

There is one conspicuous name missing from that list.

Rex Grossman?

[Joemailman]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

There is one conspicuous name missing from that list.

[Dabaddestbear]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

Ahh, makes all the much sweeter for after the season starts to watch the naysayers try and devour all the crow that will be served up...

[Scott Campbell]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

Ahh, makes all the much sweeter for after the season starts to watch the naysayers try and devour all the crow that will be served up...

I gotta admit, he sure looks the part of a Bear QB.

[cpk1994]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

Ahh, makes all the much sweeter for after the season starts to watch the naysayers try and devour all the crow that will be served up...

The only crow served will be eaten by Bers fans making Cutler the second coming when the realize he blows and start chanting "We want Wrex!" "We want Wrex!"

[Pugger]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

Look at his face!!! He looks absolutely thrilled to be in Chicago!

[Fritz]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

Ahh, makes all the much sweeter for after the season starts to watch the naysayers try and devour all the crow that will be served up...

It doesn't look like it's a problem for Cutler to devour anything. That is one well-fed boy.

[Guiness]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

ESPN's fantasy football preview lists the top 10 QBs as such:

Rank	Player	Yards	TDs
1.	Drew Brees	4827	30
2.	Tom Brady	4210	33
3.	Peyton Manning  4153	31
4.	Kurt Warner	4150	29
5.	Aaron Rodgers	4008	29
6.	Philip Rivers	3865	28
7.	Tony Romo	4001	28
8.	Matt Ryan	        3684	25
9.	Matt Schaub	3645	26
10.	Donovan McNabb	3749	22

If I was smarter I would make that look better.

What are the chances Warner has another year like that.

/fantasy football dweeb alert

[hoosier]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

ESPN's fantasy football preview lists the top 10 QBs as such:

Rank	Player	Yards	TDs
1.	Drew Brees	4827	30
2.	Tom Brady	4210	33
3.	Peyton Manning  4153	31
4.	Kurt Warner	4150	29
5.	Aaron Rodgers	4008	29
6.	Philip Rivers	3865	28
7.	Tony Romo	4001	28
8.	Matt Ryan	        3684	25
9.	Matt Schaub	3645	26
10.	Donovan McNabb	3749	22

If I was smarter I would make that look better.

What are the chances Warner has another year like that.

/fantasy football dweeb alert

On the down side he's 38 years old and you don't expect 38 year olds to do anything but show declining skills and get injured. But Warner's career isn't over, and when it's all said and done he just might show a real deviation from the norm. Remember that he looked all washed up back in 2002-03 when he was injured and unproductive in his last two years with the Rams. But since joining New York in 2004 his numbers have been consistently productive even if he hasn't held down a starting role for an entire season (pass ratings between a low of 85.8 in 2005 to a high of 96.9 last year). If Warner stays healthy in 2009, I would be willing to bet that, statistically speaking, he'll be in the same general ballpark as last year. What I don't think he'll be able to reproduce is the same unlikely trip deep into the playoffs. I predict the Cards will be settling back into their familiar mediocrity.

[Bretsky]

Re: Better NFL QB Rankings

ESPN's fantasy football preview lists the top 10 QBs as such:

Rank	Player	Yards	TDs
1.	Drew Brees	4827	30
2.	Tom Brady	4210	33
3.	Peyton Manning  4153	31
4.	Kurt Warner	4150	29
5.	Aaron Rodgers	4008	29
6.	Philip Rivers	3865	28
7.	Tony Romo	4001	28
8.	Matt Ryan	        3684	25
9.	Matt Schaub	3645	26
10.	Donovan McNabb	3749	22

If I was smarter I would make that look better.

Not Bad; I'd probbaly go

Brees
Brady
Manning
Warner
Rogers
Rivers
Romo
McNabb
Ryan
Schuab-if him and AJ stay healthy I could see him up a few slots as well

[Partial]

Am I the only pone who doesn't think Brees is a star? He put's up massive numbers, but he's also chucking the ball a lot in an offense scheme designed to put up big yardage. The QB is supposed to be the guy who has the biggest impact on wins and losses.

2003 : 4-12
2004 : 12-4 (0-1 post season)
2005 : 9-7
2006 : 10-6 (1-1 post season)
2007 : 7-9
2008 : 7-9

Career : 49 - 47 with a 1-2 post season record

Not spectacular by any means. He puts up huge numbers because NO can't run, not because he is a game changer imo. He's a top 10 QB, maybe even top 5, but he's not anywhere near the same league as Manning or Brady, and maybe even in the 3rd tier down.