Alternative History - The bears game

[Freak Out]

What if Napoleon had a B52 bomber at Waterloo?

[hoosier]

What if Napoleon had a B52 bomber at Waterloo?

He would have crashed it. No fuel.

[red]

This is just childish. All I know is Mr. Favre won another game(the most of anyone ever) and well Mr. Rodgers won #7. Talk to me when he reaches 100. (not likely)

First, the vikes won the game, just as the pack won theirs.

Second, if anyone "won" the game his name is AD.

i'm with ty on this one

it almost made me sick that the media was saying brad won his first game as a viking. they made it out that somehow biff was the reason they won the game

it was almost a footnote that AP ran for 180 yards and scored 3 td's. if any single player was responsible for that win it was ap

[Bossman641]

This is just childish. All I know is Mr. Favre won another game(the most of anyone ever) and well Mr. Rodgers won #7. Talk to me when he reaches 100. (not likely)

First, the vikes won the game, just as the pack won theirs.

Second, if anyone "won" the game his name is AD.

i'm with ty on this one

it almost made me sick that the media was saying brad won his first game as a viking. they made it out that somehow biff was the reason they won the game

it was almost a footnote that AP ran for 180 yards and scored 3 td's. if any single player was responsible for that win it was ap

Not so fast Red

You are forgetting that magical "it" Favre has. That unique quality that makes defenders react more quickly and jump higher, offensive players possess the strength of 10 men and make plays unknown to man, special teamers kick further and run faster, and also protects those around him from suffering injury.

AP may have run for 180 yards and 3 TD, but he has Favre to thank for it.

[SnakeLH2006]

Okay, Ty, first of all, enough with the "Bert" crap. He gets disrespected enough already.

If Brent Favre had started for the Pack...

That had me in stiches, Fritz....

As far as Brent being joyless....I dunno he looked happy here trying to injure his own WR....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24BRveFlcKg

I agree that he is just a game manager with a weak ass arm at this point. What's scary for the Vike's is what happens when they are down by 10 to some team this season and Brent tries winging up some ducks to the convention with that beat up arm? It's gonna look like Ty Detmer winding up to chuck a 25 yard bomb..... I think Brent is gonna have to be a game manager until that arm looks better (if it ever does)....

[Scott Campbell]

What if Napoleon had a B52 bomber at Waterloo?

What the hell is he doing in Iowa?

[Fritz]

If Napoleon had a B52 at Waterloo, the Packers would have won.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

What if Napoleon had a B52 bomber at Waterloo?

What if Sheepshead couldn't post youtube vids?

[MOBB DEEP]

This is just childish. All I know is Mr. Favre won another game(the most of anyone ever) and well Mr. Rodgers won #7. Talk to me when he reaches 100. (not likely)

First, the vikes won the game, just as the pack won theirs.

Second, if anyone "won" the game his name is AD.

i'm with ty on this one

it almost made me sick that the media was saying brad won his first game as a viking. they made it out that somehow biff was the reason they won the game

it was almost a footnote that AP ran for 180 yards and scored 3 td's. if any single player was responsible for that win it was ap

Not so fast Red

You are forgetting that magical "it" Favre has. That unique quality that makes defenders react more quickly and jump higher, offensive players possess the strength of 10 men and make plays unknown to man, special teamers kick further and run faster, and also protects those around him from suffering injury.

AP may have run for 180 yards and 3 TD, but he has Favre to thank for it.

Pretty funny bossy

[red]

This is just childish. All I know is Mr. Favre won another game(the most of anyone ever) and well Mr. Rodgers won #7. Talk to me when he reaches 100. (not likely)

First, the vikes won the game, just as the pack won theirs.

Second, if anyone "won" the game his name is AD.

i'm with ty on this one

it almost made me sick that the media was saying brad won his first game as a viking. they made it out that somehow biff was the reason they won the game

it was almost a footnote that AP ran for 180 yards and scored 3 td's. if any single player was responsible for that win it was ap

Not so fast Red

You are forgetting that magical "it" Favre has. That unique quality that makes defenders react more quickly and jump higher, offensive players possess the strength of 10 men and make plays unknown to man, special teamers kick further and run faster, and also protects those around him from suffering injury.

AP may have run for 180 yards and 3 TD, but he has Favre to thank for it.

well......

good point

[MJZiggy]

What if Napoleon had a B52 bomber at Waterloo?

What if Sheepshead couldn't post youtube vids?

The world would implode...

[Gunakor]

This is just childish. All I know is Mr. Favre won another game(the most of anyone ever) and well Mr. Rodgers won #7. Talk to me when he reaches 100. (not likely)

You spend a lot of time reliving your preferred version of the past, don't you. First of all, Favre didn't win all those games by himself. For half of his Packer career he had 2 bookend tackles protecting him, not a sieve like Allan Barbre letting everything get through to him. So at least acknowledge the differences between the two eras outside of who's playing quarterback. The team is different too.

Second, that wasn't the question in the first place. The question wasn't who has won more games over their careers, or even who played better on Sunday. The question was, could Favre have won the game against the Bears under the same circumstances Rodgers was under. Assuming you saw the Vikings game too and had the privilege of seeing Favre's slow ass get plastered a couple times himself while doing absolutely nothing of note individually (other than ride comfortably on the back of Adrian Peterson to victory), judge for yourself what he could or could not have accomplished against the Chicago Bears on September 13, 2009 had he still been under center for the Green Bay Packers of 2009.

I don't think he could have done a whole lot, simply because I think he's have spent twice as much time on the ground as Rodgers. And I'm pretty sure that's what the point of this thread is. Regardless how good a QB you are, you aren't gonna complete any passes or score any touchdowns while lying on your back. Even if he is still an elite talent at QB, he'd be staring at the sky too often to make a difference.

[Administrator]

Enough Favre banter on both sides. take it backchannel or better - To a Viking board.

[superfan]

...

[MOBB DEEP]

LOL...this thread appears to be quite one-sided

Cats need therapy