OFFICIAL Game Day Thread: Bengals @ Packers

[retailguy]

MM challenging the TD.

That he didn't cross the line?

Correct. Can't challenge for a fumble since the call wasn't made on the field at the time.

Ruling on the field stands. TD. GB charged a TD.

Was that a good challenge?

Not really in my opinion. Initial replay didn't show much, so tough to overturn. It was questionable that he got in though.

[imscott72]

Wow the Vikings look terrible..Lions in the red zone again..

[retailguy]

good head by Barbre. He gets points for that.

[pbmax]

John Kuhn whiffs on the pass block. And whiff doesn't do it justice.

[Brohm]

Wiff by Hall

[imscott72]

MM challenging the TD.

That he didn't cross the line?

Correct. Can't challenge for a fumble since the call wasn't made on the field at the time.

Ruling on the field stands. TD. GB charged a TD.

Was that a good challenge?

Not really in my opinion. Initial replay didn't show much, so tough to overturn. It was questionable that he got in though.

The ball definitely came out, but no way to tell who recovered. Ugh Arod creamed..Did Barbre whiff again??

[pbmax]

Clifton allow penetration to his DE and he trips Grant on a run that could have gone for much more.

[Fritz]

Lions just scored a td.

[Gunakor]

MM challenging the TD.

That he didn't cross the line?

Correct. Can't challenge for a fumble since the call wasn't made on the field at the time.

Ruling on the field stands. TD. GB charged a TD.

Was that a good challenge?

Not really in my opinion. Initial replay didn't show much, so tough to overturn. It was questionable that he got in though.

The ball definitely came out, but no way to tell who recovered. Ugh Arod creamed..Did Barbre whiff again??

No, the rush came from the left side. Barbre was the one who alertly jumped on the ball to retain possession after Rodgers fumbled it on the sack.

[Fritz]

The Packers are not exactly ripping it up, are they?

[Partial]

Worst. Fake hand off. Ever. That said, what is he Byron Leftwich holding the ball behind his ass on a huge release? WTF Rodg.

Big 3rd down here. Let's get this play.

[Fritz]

Some really weird play calling. It ain't working too well, either.

[Fosco33]

MM challenging the TD.

That he didn't cross the line?

Correct. Can't challenge for a fumble since the call wasn't made on the field at the time.

Ruling on the field stands. TD. GB charged a TD.

Was that a good challenge?

Not really in my opinion. Initial replay didn't show much, so tough to overturn. It was questionable that he got in though.

Questionable challenge - but way (way) too quick of a whistle and TD indication by the line judge. I thought they were waiting to make those calls now. Ed will give him a - mark for that in his grading I'm sure.

[imscott72]

Lions TD! 10-0..Wow..

[imscott72]

MM challenging the TD.

That he didn't cross the line?

Correct. Can't challenge for a fumble since the call wasn't made on the field at the time.

Ruling on the field stands. TD. GB charged a TD.

Was that a good challenge?

Not really in my opinion. Initial replay didn't show much, so tough to overturn. It was questionable that he got in though.

The ball definitely came out, but no way to tell who recovered. Ugh Arod creamed..Did Barbre whiff again??

No, the rush came from the left side. Barbre was the one who alertly jumped on the ball to retain possession after Rodgers fumbled it on the sack.

My bad. Trying to watch too many games at once..