Pinpointing the Problem

[Brandon494]

Saban is the best coach in the SEC and prolly all of college football.

The so called best coach in the SEC got his ass kicked in the Sugar Bowl last year against a mediocre Utah team. And by Meyer a few weeks before that. He's a fine coach, but he's only won the National Championship once.

I'll take Meyer.

Meyer also has had the golden boy each season he has coached at Florida.

I'd still rank them as Meyer, Saban, Carroll, Tressell, Brown, Stoops.

[Smidgeon]

I'd still rank them as Meyer, Saban, Carroll, Tressell, Brown, Stoops.

Say none of them jump to the NFL? Who in the NFL is the next hot coach? Is it a retread like Gruden, Shanahan, Cowher? Or is it some coordinator somewhere?

[Scott Campbell]

I'd still rank them as Meyer, Saban, Carroll, Tressell, Brown, Stoops.

Say none of them jump to the NFL? Who in the NFL is the next hot coach? Is it a retread like Gruden, Shanahan, Cowher? Or is it some coordinator somewhere?

I was hoping Jeff Fisher would get himself fired. Except Vince Young has single-handedly saved his job over the last two weeks.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Saban is the best coach in the SEC and prolly all of college football.

The so called best coach in the SEC got his ass kicked in the Sugar Bowl last year against a mediocre Utah team. And by Meyer a few weeks before that. He's a fine coach, but he's only won the National Championship once.

I'll take Meyer.

All coaches have bad games. Should we dismiss Meyer's 9-3 squad the year after the title. His second year with Bama.

Mediocre Utah. Mediocre teams aren't in the sugar bowl. LOL

That partial level trolling!

I'm sure you will. We will see in the coming years.

[Scott Campbell]

Saban is the best coach in the SEC and prolly all of college football.

The so called best coach in the SEC got his ass kicked in the Sugar Bowl last year against a mediocre Utah team. And by Meyer a few weeks before that. He's a fine coach, but he's only won the National Championship once.

I'll take Meyer.

All coaches have bad games. Should we dismiss Meyer's 9-3 squad the year after the title. His second year with Bama.

Meyer didn't coach at Bama.

[Scott Campbell]

That partial level trolling!

No. Partial level trolling would be arguing that Charlie Wies is the best coach in college football.

[mraynrand]

Again, please list the successful college coaches in the NFL.

Barry Switzer!

[Scott Campbell]

Again, please list the successful college coaches in the NFL.

Barry Switzer!

He did win a Superbowl - didn't he?

And then Jones fired him pretty quick for recruiting violations or sumthin.

[mngolf19]

I'd still rank them as Meyer, Saban, Carroll, Tressell, Brown, Stoops.

Say none of them jump to the NFL? Who in the NFL is the next hot coach? Is it a retread like Gruden, Shanahan, Cowher? Or is it some coordinator somewhere?

The 3 you mention will have jobs next year if they want them. And all will likely get what they are looking for eventually. Coordinators are where it's at in the NFL now. Vikes DC Frazier, Philly DC, NE OC, Dal OC. Just depends on what and how many jobs are avail. I'd say Was, Oak, Jax, Buf, Cle. Depends for Dal and Car. Very outside Chi, GB.

[Smidgeon]

Vikes DC Frazier, Philly DC, NE OC, Dal OC. Just depends on what and how many jobs are avail. I'd say Was, Oak, Jax, Buf, Cle. Depends for Dal and Car. Very outside Chi, GB.

The Philly DC? He's been on the job less than a year. Same with the NE OC. I get the Vikes DC and Dal OC (sorta). But why those first two? So far McDaniels is the only Belicheck disciple to have success after leaving NE. How can we know their current OC can do the same? Same goes for the Philly DC.

[mngolf19]

Vikes DC Frazier, Philly DC, NE OC, Dal OC. Just depends on what and how many jobs are avail. I'd say Was, Oak, Jax, Buf, Cle. Depends for Dal and Car. Very outside Chi, GB.

The Philly DC? He's been on the job less than a year. Same with the NE OC. I get the Vikes DC and Dal OC (sorta). But why those first two? So far McDaniels is the only Belicheck disciple to have success after leaving NE. How can we know their current OC can do the same? Same goes for the Philly DC.

He's been using Jim Johnson's scheme for many years. And remember some guys get hired straight from position coach, not coord. NE OC, only because everything NE or Belichick is hot when they are winning. Not saying I would want to go that direction, but really wouldn't want to go the college direction either. There just isn't alot of other options if the Big 3 turn you down.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Saban is the best coach in the SEC and prolly all of college football.

The so called best coach in the SEC got his ass kicked in the Sugar Bowl last year against a mediocre Utah team. And by Meyer a few weeks before that. He's a fine coach, but he's only won the National Championship once.

I'll take Meyer.

All coaches have bad games. Should we dismiss Meyer's 9-3 squad the year after the title. His second year with Bama.

Meyer didn't coach at Bama.

Ty knows that. It was in reference to the first sentence. Didn't feel like fixing it..thought you'd understand.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

That partial level trolling!

No. Partial level trolling would be arguing that Charlie Wies is the best coach in college football.

Ok. Point made.

Paco level of trolling!

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Again, please list the successful college coaches in the NFL.

Barry Switzer!

I'm all for a Switzer guy...as long as we have the talent the Boy's had.

[MichiganPackerFan]

I'd take Jimmy Johnson any day of the week

I think even just his hair could call a decent game.